Thimbleweed Park (Video Game 2017) Poster

(2017 Video Game)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Well worth it for anyone wanting to revisit the genre
cdalley197910 August 2017
I really loved the setting of this game. It was both unique and a very practical choice for a game of limited size and scope- not unlike the Caribbean islands of its predecessor in that respect. The pixel art was really masterfully done and helped create a strong sense of place. That's something that has always been important to me in the adventure genre. I did find the music somewhat lacking- it conveyed the tone well enough but wasn't nearly on the level of Monkey Island. But maybe I'm setting the bar a bit too high there.

The puzzles were great as well. If anything tends to turn me off from the genre, it's poor puzzle design. You know what I'm talking about...the ones you can only figure out by interacting with objects in about every possible way. Thimbleweed has puzzles that are difficult enough to be satisfying without being nonsensical- with perhaps only a couple exceptions.

I quite enjoyed the story as well. The ending will be divisive but I found it very memorable. Kind of surprisingly somber but it will definitely stick with me.

The one major complaint i have is the writing for Ransom the clown. If you're going to write a famous and successful insult comic, you can't have him spout off insults that are bland and tired and forgettable. A shame, because there was a lot of potential there. He also feels very tacked-on, with minimal connection to the actual story.

Overall, I would say that this game is well worth it for fans of the genre, and I hope that we see another release from the developers in the future.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Flawed, but with some redeeming characteristics
rtalley-315 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
There were quite a few things to like about this game, but overall I can't recommend it unless you're a fan of the genre. It doesn't stand on it's own without banking on some nostalgic feelings from players, due primarily to a lack of good writing. In the point-and-click adventure genre, the game-play is very limited, so the game really has to focus on fine dialog, immersive and intriguing worlds, and interesting plots. This doesn't quite accomplish that.

Things it does well: Beautiful art. A few good characters. What I thought was a wonderful ending. Pretty good (and very authentic) adventure game puzzles.

Things it does poorly: Very mediocre music. Dialog ranging from 'just okay' to downright terrible. Humor didn't land for me, oftentimes. Some bad voice acting (though there are exceptions).

Even though I'm being hard on it, this is worth playing if you are into this genre, or you played Maniac Mansion or Monkey Island back in the day. The fact that only a very small number of people made this game is nothing short of incredible, and it is most certainly ORIGINAL, which I give it big props for.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
How nostalgic
residentgrigo13 April 2017
Thimbleweed Park 100% succeed in feeling like a better looking late 80s adventure game. Just with great voice acting and more ambition, due to the 5 playable characters you need to control and freely switch. At least 2 too many if you ask me but the game fully achieves a sense of time and place. To such a degree that you need to be a fan of the games this one spiritually succeeds to like it. My biggest gripe is the way too meta and out of nowhere 3rd act twist that feels like a lamer version of the Monkey Island 2 ending. Fans of the genre already finished this game and no one else knows that it even exist. Just as you would expect from a crowd sourced game. 7,5/10
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
This is a gem
emptyyetfull6 July 2017
OMG, this is the best game I have played for many many years. I really felt like being a teenager again playing Zak McKracken, Monkey Island or Maniac Mansion again. I surely hope there will be more of this kind of games. I played it on PC-Windows (Steam), but heard its available on more platforms.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
You need this one
fb-259276 July 2017
If you loved Monkey Island and want to feel the warm fuzzies again, this game will throw you back. This is what happened to me. Thimbleweed Park is an interesting, atmospheric, and hilarious game that will twist your brain into knots while tickling your funny bone. Fans of Philip K. Dick and Twin Peaks, I think you should get this game. It's a steal for the price and it's lovingly, painstakingly crafted to its very detail. Get it, don't regret it.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed