The Sunderland Experiment (2014) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
3/10
It just doesn't hold together
Deep-Thought22 September 2021
Reviews of this film are mostly favorable. Those viewers must have understood the film much better than I did.

The plot (sort of): Ten years ago, an alien came to Earth, and set up shop in the isolated town of Sunderland (get it? Sunderland; like it's sundered from the world), somewhere in the southwestern desert (hence the original title of the film, "The Sunderland Experiment"). The people of the town call it the Angel. The town is now fenced in with a keyed electric gate. All normal life has ended there. The Angel has taken over the minds and bodies of the adults, and now that the children are growing up, they face a choice: They can attend "school" to learn the teachings of the Angel, and "be blessed" or "evolve" like their parents, or they can "fall," meaning live their lives in the wasteland at the edge of town, where their small rebellions are tolerated as long as they remain within the confines of Sunderland. To be "blessed," the Angel feeds them something from its own body that joins the human's mind, and even the human's body, to its own, promising a life of transcendental bliss. Of course, don't you believe it: The adults are now zombielike drones, mentally linked to the Angel, who are raising their kids to suffer the same fate. When a person dies in Sunderland, they're "planted" - literally. They are reborn as plants, with the person's head at the top of the stalk.

The town is beyond squalid. That keyed gate is the only working electrical device in the area. It looks like the town has been without electricity, running water, or telephone service for the whole 10 years since the Angel arrived. Nobody ever changes their clothes. Ever. In fact, it's forbidden to take them off. But the clothes don't look nearly filthy enough. People sleep on worn-out mattresses on the floor. Someone from the town is allowed to go out and buy supplies for the townspeople. How do they cook? Do they now have outhouses in place of bathrooms? (You don't see any.) They have practically no possessions, but they DO have ammunition for their guns. Also, has no one on the outside, like the post office or the authorities, noticed that the town of Sunderland has fallen not just off the grid, but off the map? After 10 years, don't you think they'd be curious?

The special effects and the little bit of CGI are well done. But except for a handful of scenes, I found the film to be essentially incoherent. Some of this, I think, was the clumsy editing; but a good film starts with a good script, and this film either didn't have one, or it got fatally diluted on the way to the screen. I had trouble keeping track of who was who, of who'd been killed and then reanimated and who hadn't, of what was real and what a character hallucinated, and which characters had had little spidery things implanted by the Angel and which didn't. The behavior of some of the characters was completely illogical, even for an illogical imaginary world. The acting is quite amateurish, which isn't surprising in a low-low-budget film like this one, and you have to accept that.

This is an ambitious film with a great premise and a few good moments, but on the whole, "Exile" falls far short of its ambitions.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Me no lixee much
begob22 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Boy and girl fall in love and battle to escape the community that has held them back since birth.

Not sure what to make of this. It's definitely weird, but it ain't sci-fi or horror. The other reviewers describe it as Cthulhu, and I'm not a fan of Lovecraft. It's situated in a world of mid-western Christian cult with Body Snatchers paranoia, and there's potential for social metaphor - but meh.

It's pretty well shot in a dirt cheap location and the editing is fairly quick. Actors are convincing - apart from Shaun - but I like to figure how each character is essential and this time I couldn't tell. Maybe because the predicament is imposed on them, with the condition of Who Gets Out ALIVE?

There is a unique character running around in giant underpants, with a sort of Derek Jarman vibe. But when one wacky dude turns up in a screenplay I'm always on guard for the dwarf from nowhere, wearing Aladdin shoes and gold earrings - or some sh*t like that. In other words, I don't dig bizarre for the sake of it.

In the end it does turn conventional, when the lead actor develops a hero's smile and the pickup truck comes to the rescue. Ta da!

Music was interesting.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Exile: Bizarre yet entertaining
Platypuschow17 September 2017
Exile is such a strange little creature and the front cover is highly deceptive! Telling the tale of a small society governed by a being referred to as an angel the citizens reach a point of their studies where they have to choose whether to be "blessed" which will have them merge with an alien entity or "fall" which means they'll be exiled.

Following one young man as he makes his decision and the impact on those around him.

Truth be told it's not the simplest story to follow and there is little background given forcing heavy interpretation and assumption but regardless the concept is really quite good.

Flawed in several areas the movie certainly isn't without its faults but provides a unique tale that certainly got my attention.

The Good:

Brilliant concept

The Bad:

Could have been made a tad better

Story is riddled with holes

Finale was pretty weak
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
For what it is - a low budget sci-fi flick - it's refreshing
ethancase23 April 2015
An exploration of Western boredom, religion, drugs, and freedom.

There is an alien that attempts to make people conform via ritual, there is crime and fitting but arbitrary punishment, and there is exile and death all set in almost post-apocalyptic desert ruination. A little gross, but not too gross. The characters are as unreal as the place and just as disturbing, but they are all honest to the point of hurting through their interpellation, ignorance, and resulting quirks.

No tropes or overwritten moments in this one - I never knew what was going to happen next. It's not fun or pretty, but it's obvious that there was a real thinking human who made the movie.
16 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Warrants more than one viewing
samandor-157814 February 2016
Warning: Spoilers
After seeing the low score and reading the scant number of reviews about this flick, I have to conclude that most simply didn't get it. The world hasn't been taken over by an alien invasion - just one remote outpost has been taken over by a single alien. The community of Sunderland was likely an apocalyptic survivalist sect, in self-imposed isolation - hence the religious overtones of Angel's "teachings" (beginning with calling itself "Angel"), why outsiders don't find it too strange that they've been seeing less of these folks, and why it was a perfect place for this sort of alien invasion.

The bizarre life cycle of the alien apparently requires nearly a decade of gestation inside its host - the film occurs at the end of this period for the first adults to be "blessed" by the psychic, parasitic organism, at which point they have to plant their heads in the garden, to produce the next vegetative part of this life cycle. What happens after that remains unknown. The young characters in this film would have been around 4-6 years old when their parents were either "blessed," or killed. Older siblings have been either blessed, killed, or fallen.

Why the Fallen aren't killed is a bit of a mystery, except that the one adult who wasn't "blessed" (but wants to be) is the only person allowed outside of the compound, to obtain supplies. He's getting old enough that he might need replacement. The "blessed" wouldn't pass as normal outside the compound.

Another weird thing to ponder is why it seems important to the "angel" to teach the kids math and genetics (along with fealty to the Angel, and not joining "the worm and the slit" - a primitive form of abstinence is the only thing these kids have been taught about sex). Since the parasite apparently acquires knowledge from the host, perhaps this gives the next generation a leg up. Teaching in the womb?

There's a lot more going on in this flick than you're likely to get in one viewing.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Bold and Original
scythertitus11 June 2016
This ultra-low budget sci-fi horror has a lot of originality put into it and is experimental in the extreme, creating its own world in a very basic environment. Along with this the film leaves a lot of blanks for the audience to fill in about the state of the world and what caused it, but that all works to its credit.

One gripe viewers could have is with the editing as it comes across as sloppy and jarring, although this might have been by design, but in either case it takes away from the viewing experience. Also the story, while original, lacks focus and it is easy to get lost in all that is happening. The film also takes very little time to pause and let the audience get to know its characters and so they feel a bit disconnected.

Overall this is a film with a lot of good ideas and I hope the writer/director gets to go onto more things as they clearly have talent. With more money and scope this film could have been something akin to District 9, as it is there is a little too much confusion and limitations to be truly great, but it certainly has a lot of potential and for what it lacks it makes up for in originality.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Surprisingly good indie movie
Steneslore20 April 2015
I wasn't expecting much from this but was pleasantly surprised, this movie is quite a gem. It's very original and interesting, the pacing is good and the practical effects and CGI are quite competent. Unlike a lot of other indie films in the same budget range it's never boring, and it always shocks and intrigues you into wanting to see what happens next.

The characters are very well written and believable. There's a lot of bizarre and frightening things happening, but they seem to accept it all as normal because they don't know any different. They have no understanding of the outside world because they've been isolated and kept ignorant. You actually care what happens to them as their characters develop and they learn horrible truths about their existence.

If you like indie sci-fi or horror films you'll probably like this one. It's relentlessly weird and bleak, and it will keep you interested till the end. I will definitely be watching the next film these guys make.
11 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Just give it a watch
snakepaws20 September 2016
There's a lot that can be said about this film. It's not great, and definitely not without flaws - in some cases, you can poke a hole big enough to sink a small boat. But this is one of the few films that I can honestly say, by the end, I was left reveling in what the filmmakers got RIGHT, that what flaws were noticeable melted into back of my mind. If you want an indie low-budget sci-fi film that doesn't follow the mold, give it a shot. This has the makings of a cult classic. It pays homage to Cronenberg and Lovecraft - not to oversell it, but it's weird and not soon forgettable. You've come this far, so hit the play button.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
My Review Of "Exile: The Sunderland Experiment"
ASouthernHorrorFan19 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
First off- let me say "What The F@ck?! This is the most wild and twisted exploration into the human condition that I have ever seen, and I loved every bleepin' minute of it! "Exile" is probably the perfect blend of low budget indie filmmaking and science fiction surrealism. Directed by Adam Petke and Sean Blau, although the story's pace and fluidity is so strong that you would think only one mind controlled the direction of this film. A lot of people will push it aside as ridiculous, but to be honest most people will see this film as I did, a true, original, captivating, emotional journey of human suffrage and escapism seen through the eyes of the youth.

The story is a moving, disturbing, coming of age in the wasteland that is so stripped down to a realness that is so recognizable and transferable into any genre. It just happens to be framed by a nightmarish, H.P. Lovecraftian form of first contact and the dichotomy of life inside a cult. "Exile" gives a relatable, recognizable premise and brings it into a hellish reality that is beautifully disturbing and effective.

The acting is pretty tight on all fronts, the cast are completely immersed in their characters, the script is evenly paced with chilling moments of horror and emotional segments of "life of the children that fall through the cracks". The story moves with a somber beat of loss, despair that develops into determination and self preservation. Not to mention all the "real world" subtext symbolism that permeates this film. The direction Petke takes by keeping the style organic, and personal creates a deeply moving and unsettling reality for the characters

The special effects is the same concept as films like "District 9" but on a much smaller scale in regards to the CGI elements with the alien creature known as the "Angel". The horror elements, and there are some awesome, dark, gory horror moments in "Exile", stay practical and visceral. There is some CGI blood added during interactions with the Angel, but during the more dramatic scenes between the characters which end in horrific displays of Lovecraft inspired nightmares, the effects and blood are practical ones.

The soundtrack, sound effects used on "Exile" blend eerie instrumental sounds of sorrow and loss with added sound effects that are chilling. Together the sounds create a tense atmosphere of suspense that just elevates the emotional and dramatic struggle of the characters into areas of that are more horror than sci-fi. Honestly I would say that "Exile" is a horror drama more than it is a horror scifi blended story. Overall the film is a powerful, indie horror that gets everything organically right. It is honest, compelling, emotional, and entertaining. A truly chilling exploration of the human experience in horrific conditions. A must see film!
7 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed