Alan Wake's American Nightmare (Video Game 2012) Poster

(2012 Video Game)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Not losing any sleep over this one
TBJCSKCNRRQTreviews21 March 2014
With Alan(Porretta, still an obsessed, troubled writer, albeit here it isn't really explored) where we left him(not giving it away, for anyone who don't know the ending), he is now chasing his evil double, Mr. Scratch, who leaves behind video recordings(live-action, as most cutscenes in this) that show his exploits, brutally torturing and murdering people in his path. What exactly are his motives and the limitations to his powers? These questions and more, will not be answered here – in Night Springs, AZ(no, seriously… yes, it's framed as an episode of the Twilight Zone-esque show, compete with Rod Serling-ish narrator).

Anyway, our protagonist is trapped in a time-loop, which would be an excellent way to do a straight adventure title, where you have a time limit before you go back to the start of that scenario, and you have to gather clues, figure out what to accomplish and how, and only when you do it just right do you get to progress to the next one, with compelling characters and a gradually unfolding plot that explains what's going on. Unfortunately, nothing like that is here. It's 3 hours long, with few settings, since, well, it has nothing to say that isn't there purely to make a single-player campaign. It's another recent release that has to include that to justify its own existence.

The focus here is on the gunplay, the amount of which has been increased, in spite of there already being a bit much in the original(and that one, we loved for its engrossing story and carefully built atmosphere, neither present here), which this is an in-universe spin-off to – not sequel, that one is supposedly and hopefully still coming. It also wasn't a third-person shooting experience that you'd really drop everything to go get. With a handful of new weapons that don't really fit the otherwise unaltered gameplay(SMG, nailgun, etc.), and uninspired enemies, it's meant to be rejuvenated. Why are Taken, blue-collar workers using the tools of their trade(firemen with axes, etc.) possessed by a dark, Venom-like substance, still your foes? The tone has shifted without bringing the engine along.

This was made for the Arcade mode, where you have to survive for ten minutes in one of five arenas(cemetery, ghost town, etc.), in one of the two difficulty settings(and you have to do well on early ones in order to unlock later ones) of this, against increasingly dangerous opposition. There are international leaderboards for this. And that's about it. This is meant to attract more people to the franchise, but how? By showing off an OK aspect, one that is outdone by many others? This should have been a free DLC for those who already had the first one – it's what you'd have called an expansion pack some years back. They didn't even fix the few actual issues, like when you try to pick something up from a group of items, and it doesn't cycle past(or just pick up what it can – they're nearly always in piles!) the closest one, even if that one is at your full capacity.

You still have a flashlight to remove the "dark halo" before you can take someone out with bullets, and you have to balance those two(use it at an "unnecessary" time, it'll essentially stun) with the time-it-just-right dodge mechanic in order to do well at this. Lampposts serve as checkpoint saves and the way to heal. This is too stand-alone for it to be worth it, with a thin, poorly done(although in spite of what some have said, it does make sense) plot that doesn't affect anything. The people you come across in it have nothing to do, and could have been replaced with the now-manual-like, this-time-devoid-of-subtlety manuscript pages that grant access to boxes that each have a high-level weapon.

This is not well-paced. It starts with you fighting(rather than letting you absorb where you are and what's going on), after an exposition dump that doesn't recap previous events(this doesn't give away anything that has already happened… it also spends almost no time of its 3 hour length explaining something that was built up and explored over the 9 and a half hour 1st), no, it sets up what's going on! Show, don't tell! There is no suspense, dialog is seldom as clever as it wants to be, and the whole thing lacks the production values of first. It feels lazy, rushed.

In a lot of ways, this is similar to the two chapters that came as DLC. Surreal, you having to get through unpredictable areas and having encounters with others that are "off". However, that was much more creative, had a lot of fun with the concept and actually added thematically(if not with progression in the overall story). While I wouldn't spend money on it if it didn't come with purchasing that full game, something I wholeheartedly encourage you to do, it easily beats this.

The mini-map/GPS shows icons for the new ammo refill spots(…ugh), and other things you might need to find. You can carry one sidearm(pistol or the like), one two-handed(shotgun, hunting rifle, etc.), flashbangs, flares and a gun for the latter. If close enough, those can be highly useful in the fight. You can only carry 3-5 extra clips for any of them, so you do have to stay on your toes, look around for more. Well, mostly in the "survival" part, in the single-player, you have to work hard to come close to running out. Heck, this threw three different secondary arms at me before I had anything to use even one of them on! Barry(Berman, enthusiastic, big-city type) returns, often on the radio, now managing The Old Gods of Asgard(!). That's not the only nod/reference, either.

There is some disturbing, violent and suggestively sexual content in this. I recommend this to those who want everything with Mr. Wake's name on it, and no one else. Anything this offers, you can get better elsewhere. 7/10
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Tough game unless you are a VERY GOOD, HC gamer (mild spoilers)
mp390a157 June 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Visiting a friend out of town, I played it over a couple of days. I Have to admit though I used a trainer of his. Hey, this is a VERY hard game. The whole flashlight thing focusing on fast running bad guys with axes, etc, then WAITING for seemingly eternity focusing on ONE GUY (three to five seconds) for their "dark evil" force-field to allow your varied weapons to take them down. Umm, did I fail to mention that your all too critical flashlight only boosts a high-beam for about 8 seconds when you have about 6-10 nasties ranging from: rotary saw equipped, fast and slow zombie-like lumberjacks 8 feet tall; highway patrolmen with bats; huge, fat bikers with sledgehammers, farmers with sighs; tall, skinny, tattooed, meth looking dudes who multiply when you hit them; firemen with sharp axes; chubby mechanics who throw something nasty that kills; invisible poltergeists who throw big, heavy things; hordes of spiders and birds that turn into very fast, spooky guys. All of the above at the same time, and you have a flashlight that lasts for 8-10 seconds, and your ammo is very limited, plus you can only carry one primary weapon, one sidearm, and some flash grenades and flares as well as a flare gun that is like a nuke, but VERY hard to come by for ammo.

I could have never gotten past the first few levels without the trainer cheats.

Toughest shooter game I have ever played. There is also some seriously creepy stuff and startles in the dark a few times, so intense, that it could induce an involuntary "shart" ("dude, I sharted during my date" sort of context in a panic kind of way). Lol. Pretty cool, potentially stinky at times, but, _damn, it was tough for me without some trainer cheats. Don't even get me started on the arena battles. I'm dead in two minutes just looking for weapons and ammo, lost in the dark as ten guys who run fast with axes chop me up into zombie, livestock feed. Cool game with lots of psychological storyline twists, deja-vu, filmesque noir, and narration in a "Twilight Zone" dedicated and celebrated flair. I would recommend it for survival-horror genre fans who are very skilled gamers only (Twilight Zone, Rod Sterling and X-Files Fans will love the ambiance and graphics). I've never known and played the prequel to this, I just might might buy them both and play from the beginning as I did with Max Payne (same writer and similarities). The entire flashlight thing (light as a main weapon) being the central part of the combat made this game very unique and the toughest game I have ever played in story mode. I give it a 7. An 8 for graphics and spooky bad dudes with nasty implements.

Bill Murray as a weatherman on the TVs should have had a cameo in this, just for grins and giggles. You will know why when you play it through for the first time.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Fighting In The American Shadows
kervindonngo19 September 2023
Alan Wake's American Nightmare is the first game that I played in the Alan Wake franchise and it is one of the games that I absolutely got in Epic Games. I was not able to play the first game of Alan Wake but I managed to get the second game

The story assumes that this takes place in a TV show called Night Springs and the storyline actually appears to be about Alan Wake fighting against his evil version of himself named Mr. Scratch the shadowy evil version of Alan Wake. At first the graphics it felt a little bit odd considering the fact that the game does not support NVIDIA but on the absolute bright side this game still manages to play without any lags. The combat is absolutely descent. Not just that I can use a gun but I can use a flashlight and a flare gun. But no melee attacks for some reason.

Despite the game having some obstacles to face my only complaint is that this game has levels repeated because it felt like I just had to start the game all over and the final boss in the game is absolutely anti-climatic. I was looking forward to getting a chance to see a fight Mr. Scratch but even it had a happy ending having it without a final boss felt very empty, and anti-climatic and did not bring the build-up on just what I have always wanted.

The game almost brought the " American Nightmare" but in the end, it may have a happy ending but it did not bring the "adrenaline in my soul"
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
As Good as the First, in Different Ways
ARTaylor29 September 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I really liked Alan Wake. It was a different shooter game. I was quite disappointed that it didn't do better with audiences. Certainly not getting the recognition it deserved, thus not making enough to warrant a sequel. So I was very happy to hear that while we may not be getting Alan Wake 2, we got something more than just DLC like The Signal and The Writer.

American Nightmare isn't Alan Wake 2 but nor is it just DLC. It's a full game in its own right. Not really part of the story but a part of the universe. The closest thing I can think of is Halo 3: ODST. Fans of the game will certainly enjoy the new story, characters, settings, weapons, and enemies. Though I don't think it will draw in new fans since so much of the story relies on the previous game.

The game follows Wake, still trapped in the Dark Place, as he navigates a television show he wrote that came to life thanks to his evil twin Mr. Scratch. He meets three women who help him along the way. I'm a little disappointed that the only three people he meets are gorgeous supermodels when the first game featured more realistic women. When he reaches a certain point, Scratch resets the story and Wake tries again. Scratch is constantly tormenting Wake with what he's doing while the good guy's trapped. Each cycle Wake and his friends do a little better until Scratch is finally defeated. As I said, it doesn't seem part of the story as it doesn't have much to do with Wake leaving Cauldron Lake, but we'll have to wait for Alan Wake 2, if any, to see if this does matter.

The game play is essentially the same. Burn off the darkness before you can kill Taken. There's new enemies like those who split in light and can be defeated right away, flocks of birds that form into men, and giants. I don't care for the giants as they're a bit too stereotypical of video game enemies, and Alan Wake was anything but typical. You're given much more weapons than the first game. In the other, you had two shotguns, a rifle, pistol, and two "grenades". This features a wide variety including nail guns, magnums, semi- and automatic weapons. You can also access weapon caches basically for unlimited ammo. It makes the game slightly easier as it's easier to take down bigger foes and no real need to watch your aim.

If I have any complaint, it's that the game isn't as scary as the first. The first was tense, suspenseful, and fear inducing. I've read some reviews saying this is more like a Tarantino film, and I generally agree. I had lots of fun, but there was never any part I was afraid to go on. At times I felt a little too invincible. I don't think I actually died at all. This time around, only concentrating the light burns off darkness (rather than the first game where it simply burned it faster). But then the batteries quickly refill so I almost never had to replace batteries except in tough battles. The story is somewhat short, though I didn't bother with the arcade mode. Also, beyond The Twilight Zone, there's not really the book, television, and movie references that were a big part of the first game.

This is another entry is a very enjoyable series. I'm saddened that it doesn't sound like Alan Wake 2 is coming any time soon. But what we did get was worth the ride.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
A pointless follow-up to an excellent adventure
those_who_dig4 November 2016
The original 'Alan Wake' game was one of the most unique single-player experiences I ever had. The story was compelling, the characters were original, and the gameplay was quite inventive. If you're looking for these things in 'American Nightmare', I say: look elsewhere, or simply replay 'Alan Wake'. In this sequel, you follow Alan through a series of dreamlike sequences, and fans of the Jake Gyllenhaal films 'Donnie Darko' and 'Enemy' will be familiar with the ground covered in this game. Unsurprisingly, repeating and attempting to rewrite reality isn't quite as fun in video game form, and so 'American Nightmare' very quickly degenerates into several hours of mindless repetition. The handful of characters accompanying Alan Wake in this game are incredibly uninteresting, and so the dialogue scenes really aren't worth sitting through. The developers seem to attempt livening the game up with a number of additions in the weapon and enemy departments, but these, again, aren't anything special. I'd only recommend this to: (a) people who've replayed 'Alan Wake' dozens of times, and are lifelong devotees of the character, and (b) people who spot this game massively reduced (i.e. £1 or less).
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed