Alice stays with Del thinking Del may sell the family farm. Meanwhile, Kat travels back to 1814 via a pond. She locates Jacob indirectly by meeting Elijah. Kat doesn't expect Jacob to be the same as she remembers.
Alice reevaluates the past and her friendship with Elliot; Kat discovers that history is told by the winners; Del questions the stories she tells herself.
The big Founder's Day is approaching in Port Haven and it brings up memories for Elliot, Del and Alice. Kat searches for answers between the two worlds.
Emotions are high for the Landry women while Kat works on a rescue. Alice is concerned as she sees Dell going through a wave of grief as some old wounds are opened.
The Landry women learn things aren't always as they seem as each of them uncovers new past and present truths. Elliot questions how much of Kat's heart is in 1814.