"The Fall of the House of Usher" A Midnight Dreary (TV Episode 2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
11 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Mike Flanagan really knows how to spoil us.
GregTheStopSign9512 October 2023
A gripping opening to what promises to be even better than his Haunting series', this episode sets the tone for what's to come BRILLIANTLY. The production design is gorgeous, with all the promise of the decadence and debauchery to come, the cast - again made up mostly of Flanagan Family members, with a few newcomers - are showcased well but without anyone feeling shoe-horned in needlessly, the music is suitably dark and decadent...in short, Mike Flanagan is once again in perfect form and I can't WAIT to see what the rest of the series has in store for us.

On a side note, it's interesting and fascinating to see the Flanagan Family play such wildly different roles to what we've seen from them so far. Almost everyone has previously played 'nice', if occasionally brusque, characters. Well-meaning, if guarded, characters. With the exception of Sam Sloyan (who was INCREDIBLE as Midnight Mass's true villain - Bev), they've all been immediately likeable and never really stopped being so. Here, though, they're all shaping up to be brilliantly crooked, and nasty, perhaps even bordering on evil...and I am HERE for it!
48 out of 65 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Totally unexpected!
icantoo13 October 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I had not heard of this and thought it was about Usher. I kept seeing it and finally took a closer look. My favorite series is American Horror and this season is so bad I want to cry. This show has made me feel better. It is what I would have expected from AH.

I am so friggen happy to find this wonderfully dark series. Finally something so different and so interesting.

The first episode is EVERYTHING it should be and more. It establishes characters, the tone of the show and PROMISE of what is to come! The casting is amazing, the writing phenomenal. Everything a good series need this has. Even though most of the season is out as I write this I will not watch unless I can give my undivided attention as it is THAT good!
13 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
S1.E1 - Pretty Good [9/10]
panagiotis199321 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
(S1. E1) My Live Reaction / Review for The Fall of the House of Usher Season 1 Episode 1 ''A Midnight Dreary''. I've heard many people talking about this show so im gonna give it a chance. So we have a family and its members keep dying, interesting, I wonder why they die. Damn, this Longfellow guy is heartless, their mother worked for him for so many years and he doesn't care at all. Disgusting human being. Their mother came back from the dead? How? She killed Longfellow? That's satisfying. This is a family with lots of secrets, it's fascinating to watch. Roderick Usher has so many kids from different wives, it's a bit weird. Roderick sees things? Overall this episode was good, my rating is 9/10.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Poe as pretext
Kirpianuscus16 October 2023
The first feeling is the use of Edgar Allan Poe text as pretext for a mini series with some political - social accents, mixing mistery, power and death , justice and survive ,influence of Interview with a vampire and some Gothic atmosphere , good actors and crumbs from Poe work in one of dark stories proposing some tension, some thrills , a story about power and vulnerability.

In essence, nothing bad, good premises, admirable job of Bruce Greenwood and correct definition of terms of game.

Sure, the memory of original short story works scene by scene but it is not a surprise the desire to use a sort of seduction tool for proposing a version very personal by a director.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
good premiere
nerrdrage6 March 2024
This episode sets up the story pretty well and sets expectations. I'm a big fan of Mike Flanigan, from his scary stuff (Haunting of Hill House) to the not-so-scary but still excellent (Midnight Mass). This one looks like it will depend less on scares than on dramatic heft.

But I'm not sure how much any of this has to do with Poe. It's more of a mashup of Succession, Dopesick and even an Agatha Christie mystery with a very good cast of talented actors to keep things engaging.

I suppose each episode will probably detail how each of the siblings died, Ten Little Indians style. That's a good format but I'll wait for someone else to do a legit Poe adaptation, which I really don't expect from this at all.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Who's talking to the feds?
Sleepin_Dragon15 October 2023
The head of The Usher family, Roderick Usher, learns that one among the family is a mole, and exposing their corrupt dealings to The Government. A $50m dollar bounty is offered for finding the guilty party.

Midnight dreary, I feel that was a fairly accurate description for the debut episode.

I have a feeling this is going to get better, I don't think this was the most exciting or engrossing first episode, I found it a little slow, but there's a lot of ground work put in here, it's an interesting story, I'm hoping for more of the horror vibe.

What on Earth happened to the family? I'm keen to learn.

They are definitely one toxic mixed bag of a family, there are some interesting characters, and some familiar faces from previous.

6/10.
18 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Dull, unengaging start
grantss14 October 2023
The Usher family is never far from controversy. The fortunes of siblings Roderick and Madeline Usher were made through Fortunato Pharmaceuticals, a company whose products are often under scrutiny due to health concerns. Assistant District Attorney C. Auguste Dupin is determined to land a conviction and his case against Fortunato and the Ushers has gone to trial. Now, right in the middle of the trial, Roderick's children are dying under mysterious circumstances.

Having read many of Edgar Allan Poe's works and watched many of Roger Corman's adaptations of them, including "(The Fall of the) House of Usher", I was intrigued by this mini-series. Being a mini-series I didn't expect that it would simply be an 8-part adaptation of the book. However, the episode titles implied that other Poe works would also be adapted as part of the mini-series.

Turns out this series has very little to do with Edgar Allan Poe. Writer-director Mike Flanagan simply abused the name of Edgar Allan Poe to give this series some credibility. The only things Poe-like in this series are the title of the series, the titles of the episodes, the family name and the fact that the Assistant AG is C. Auguste Dupin, the detective in many of Poe's works. The plot has very little semblance to any works of Poe.

Poe non-adaptation aside, this episode, and the start of the series, isn't any good anyway. Slow paced with loathsome, unengaging characters. Flanagan tries to make everyone seem edgy but they're actually just vacuous and despicable.

It gets better: from Episode 3 the tension, action and plot development tick up several notches but I almost didn't get that far - was seriously thinking of giving up during Episode 2.
22 out of 73 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Boring
Ingalilla12 October 2023
I was looking forward to this but it is not what I was expecting at all. I love Poe's stories but this ain't it. It's modernized beyond necessity and to make it more sellable I guess they have thrown in unnecessary amounts of x-rated content that add nothing to the story. It feels misplaced when almost all the characters talk about it when it has nothing to do with the story. Everyone seems to be sleeping around or having some sort of a kink AND the need to talk about it with everyone they know. I kept waiting for the actual story and ended up fast forwarding through this added stuff. I'm not beyond liking some added sex if it has anything to do with the story but come on. This just feels silly.

Oh and the Usher story beneath it all? I guess it's there somewhere...
26 out of 92 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Everyone is Gay!!!
smoon-3778929 November 2023
Mike Flanagan does it again.. but this time he just doesn't care.. literally everyone is LGBT... it's so pushed and not realistic. Then again it's a ghost story so it's make believe anyways. I just miss good character writing .. not only does he keep using the same cast members he is getting so lazy with writing these characters he isn't even taking risks anymore. Other than that this episode sucked so I hope this show gets better .. Mark Hammil was awful in his role .. the only good actor was the attorney during the court scene .. at least he had some acting range in this episode.. but don't worry he is gay too LoL.
9 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The death of the Usher
AvionPrince1612 October 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I need to say that im pretty disappointed. It lack clearly of mysteries, implicit scenes, horror scenes(psychological too?). Instead we had some talks of law, contract, politics, money, family. We had a brief scene where the horror was kind of effective (with the mother when Roderick was young). The story show us the present and the past. The present make us more understand the past and also the opposite is true but clearly i didnt see anything that engage me into the story: so unclear in the intentions too and clearly lack of directions. So if i really understand the main interest of the episode is to understand how the family died trough the story of Roderick and what will be the consequences of the future? Ok i guess but too much scenes was unnecessary in my opinions. Some talks too but its ok i guess. And let be clear here! Put some jumpscares in the episode cant make the horror and we needed instead a mood, an ambience, something more visually interesting

I will watch more to see what its really about. And of course the end let us a little bit worried: what happened to Roderick? We need to see more but really a little bit disappointed and expected something more mysterious, more engaging and with more horrors. But it is what it is.
10 out of 43 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Agenda Strangles Story.
jamericanbeauty12 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Mike Flanagan's first horror Netflix miniseries - I loved the tale of the heartbroken, haunted family, trapped in a cycle of gloom and doom all tied to a spooky family home with individually interesting characters. There was one sibling who indulged in girl on girl action...ok, didn't add to nor distract from the central story.

Mike Flanagan's second horror miniseries - I liked the tale of the heartbroken American nanny, escaping her grieving past, just to land in an English mansion that holds a heartbreaking and tragic past of a doomed love affair and supernatural evil trying to possess the living. The actor playing the handsome evil was the stand out, but overall the cast was good. I didn't like the never-ending final episode, but I liked the miniseries overall. There's a random girl on girl loving relationship that added nothing nor took away anything from the main plot.

Mike Flanagan's third horror Netflix miniseries Midnight Mass was incredibly acted, paced, written and shot until the final two episodes. It went from something profound to just a basic gory supernatural horror miniseries. Hamish Linklater was brilliant as the mysterious, charismatic priest and I refuse to believe anyone out-acted him in 2021! How did he not get nominated for all the awards?! Zach Gilford is also perfect in his role and his final scene on the boat is unforgettable. I think a nurse might have liked women. She's sidelined most of the runtime, so I don't remember. If so, it's not the focus.

Mike Flanagan's fourth and latest horror miniseries - I could not finish the episode. Good cast, although I would have preferred the original casting of Frank Langella as Roderick Usher. Already, I see Flanagan is not staying true to Poe's tale. Ok, I'll stick with it. I like the dark cinematography and how the story starts. Pretty early on, you see Flanagan is committed to pushing an agenda, not his pen. We're supposed to root for the strangle death of a "powerful" man because, because he's powerful. He was mean. Is that punishable by death though? I guess the Eat The Rich agenda makes Flanagan feel cool, despite him being rich. Mr. District Attorney has a Husband. Ok. An Usher daughter has a girlfriend (Wife?). Ok. An Usher son is getting serviced by a sexy girl who he hides from his boyfriend. Another Usher daughter says a Fox News host makes her sick to her stomach. Here comes the politics. Sigh. I exited out. Hollywood, same-sex loving is not edgy or shocking. It's 2023, not 1953. If you go by percentages, no family has all that going on. And why must DNC politics be in everything? Mike Flanagan, no fifth miniseries please.
3 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed