Wo men de xi nan lian da (TV Series 2020– ) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Engaging drama about students in Sino-Japanese war
HangInThere20233 May 2023
Something interesting is going on. Not only am I watching historical events in this drama, something historical might also be happening relating to its broadcast.

This drama follows a group of students from top universities in China who witnessed their schools being bombed or occupied by the Japanese during the second Sino-Japanese War from 1937 to 1945. They followed their teachers south to establish the Changsha Temporary University and eventually the National Southwestern Associated University in Kunming.

I'm not a fan of war movies/dramas but this completely engaged my attention with its well-recreated historical events and interesting characters, including famous historical figures like poet Wen Yi Duo and Tsinghua University president Mei Yiqi.

This drama can foster patriotism from Chinese citizens and expatriates. Might the intended audience just be the Chinese community then? Might this be the reason no official subtitles are provided, no matter how much international viewers have been clamoring for them? The timing is curious, considering what's going on in the world today.

What makes it doubly interesting is the reception from its intended audience.

As an international viewer struggling to understand the Youtube auto-translation of the drama, I've been deeply moved by the powerful historical portrayals like the bombings of Nankai University and Changsha, the passion of the teachers and students to serve their country and the depiction of how much residents' lives changed during the war. I've been crying since the second episode.

Yet, comments on Chinese social media are more concerned about the airtime the male lead is getting compared to other characters, the love triangle, deleted scenes, and other gripes about the production that, considering the subject matter, are petty and nit-picky.

Nitpicking is a common strategy to sabotage a show. Or, might this be reflecting the Chinese people's low interest in being dragged into a war at present? It seems like they are more interested in fantasy dramas and other forms of escapism than having their patriotism stoked.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Review from a Non-Chinese perspective
ladydewine15 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Watched the drama on YouTube relying on the auto-translation that the app generates which is sometimes either not accurate, completely missing or out of sync with the dialogue delivery. I do have a small understanding of the language so I managed to follow the story.

The ingredients of war are certainly at the forefront of the entire drama. What I liked most are the bonds of friendship, camaraderie, family and that of student & teacher that the drama softly but surely, highlights in a period of great strife in a country.

How they (the producers & directors) managed to squeeze in 3-4 love story equations (maybe more 😅) without compromising on the focal point of the drama, is quite amazing.

I had a feeling there were deleted scenes but wasn't sure until I read the review below from a different viewer. Not a fan of war movies myself but I really love storytelling where true stories are narrated and depicted as close as possible to the actual events.

Loved all the characters and their performances... it was outstanding. Got quite emotional when watching a few scenes especially when Runming loses his life. Gotta say... Wen Jie became a paper shredder (he tore up a lot of paper 😂) & Hua Jun started a haircut trend that Amei & Runqing followed 😁

The drama was filmed 4 years ago and although it takes time for the film authorities to approve its release, the timing of the release now given the current events in the world, can make one apprehensive. I do recommend everyone to watch it... and watch it with a kind heart and an open mind 🤗👍🏼
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed