"It's a Sin" Episode #1.5 (TV Episode 2021) Poster

(TV Mini Series)

(2021)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Masterpiece
petermoss-0910913 February 2021
The hospital scene in Episode 5 will go down in history.

It is beyond masterful. It is beyond perfection. Every aspect of it, the acting, the script, the direction, scenery everything is not just great but together is something beyond and unique.

The viewer is taken on the twisting and perverse journey of someone struggling to reason through sudden grief. You are beyond being there you are going through it with them. Flung violently and unexpectedly as you are marched through the hospital. Clip clip clip clip.

The other quality to this series is the humanity and empathy. Davies never blames people for their bigotry and prejudice but nor is he an apologist. He simultaneously presents the damage it does and the reason for ignorance behind it. And finally, between Jill and Valerie, he holds them accountable. But he shows us that they are still loving human beings who care as deeply as anyone else but are shackled by the "common sense" of the time. And he reveals the deep emotional struggle and consequences of holding harmful points of view by stripping ignorance violently away.
32 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Incredible finale.
Sleepin_Dragon27 January 2021
The finale.

A breathtaking end to what's been a wonderful series, there is no let up in this final episode, we see human nature at its best and absolute worst, we see panic, fear, jealousy, hate, and best of all we see pure love.

It's been phenomenal from start to finish, and this finale is as good as it gets.

Olly Alexander, once again, he's going to win awards for his surely.

Now, Keeley Hawes, I said previously, lovely that she appeared and took on a small part....... but you don't give Keeley Hawes a part in a series and expert her not to so what she does best, maybe she even steals the show in this episode. She's incredible.

Powerful and heart breaking in equal measure. 10/10.
32 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Everybody hurts
xmasdaybaby196623 January 2021
A powerful final installment. I know it is supposed to be about gay men but it is the women that shine in this episode. Keeley Hawes finally gets to do some serious screen time with a few great scenes of heart-wrenching ignorance, pain, denial and agony. Hopefully, this series will waken people up to dangers of viruses, whether it's one from the 80s or present day. The loss suffered by the friends is moving but great memories shine through. Great performances by the cast and wound up as well as possible which hopefully will change a few people's views.
26 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Bravo Keeley Hawes😢😭
rhmacl3 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Being fifty-something, and gay, in California...there is so much about this series that digs in and pulls up a lot of very unhappy memories ... and good ones. This episode revealed a conflicted mother's rage and love; two powerful forces seemingly irreconcilable. But Keeley Hawes found a way to express that world-stopping instinct of a mother willing to throw herself between her child and the predator, or whatever it is posing a threat to her offspring. With no other defense, Hawes' Mrs. Tozer forsakes her dignity; in a single scene she transforms a house-mum into a tidal wave of pent-up rage grasping for anything to gain control of an uncontrollable situation, the unnaturally early impending death of her beloved little boy for whom she has already sacrificed so much. The marching through the hospital halls reminded me of an army being summoned in her battle. A supreme show of force, so organized and well assembled, but for no victory, as we all well know now. This performance is truly remarkable and ugly and beautiful. Well done. Bravo!
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best series finales I've ever seen
tomcook-6857431 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
No perfect goodbye or happy ending. This episode perfectly sums up the gut-wrenching cruelty of this virus and the impact it had on so many young lives both then and still today.

The acting is perfect and as has already been stated the female cast are outstanding. Lydia West is impressive as she has been throughout but Keeley Hawes truly shines. Her denial and ignorance is portrayed perfectly and the intense hospital scene which is filmed almost in one shot shows her intense feelings, blaming everyone but herself.

Parallels with Covid-19 are also inescapable. How many other Ritchies have died alone in this pandemic without their loved ones? The irony of course in this show being that he is in his home with his 'real' family but still so isolated whereas his adopted family are shut out. What shines through at the end are happy memories and that is all we really have left in the end.
25 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Human...
W011y4m523 January 2021
Russell T. Davies' early years as a young gay man were shaped by his experiences of the AIDS crisis & yet until "It's A Sin", the topic was a subject he'd never covered with his writing... So it's no surprise to see that with his first address, he has so much - that's of value - to say; the finale therefore feels like a much needed catharsis; all the pain & the loss & the anger is finally unburdened & channelled in to one last, cutting installment to the series, concluding with what may be one of the most powerful & damning observations I've ever seen him embed within the dialogue of his scripts.

It's thoughtful, considered & deeply personal - solidifying this as one of the best narratives he's ever crafted in his entire career... And despite the fact that the wounds inflicted during this crisis will have formed scars that will never fully heal - it's reassuring to know that a writer like Russell has used the pain he endured as a way to ensure the victims are never truly forgotten.
35 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Episode 1.5
Prismark1019 April 2021
Warning: Spoilers
It was noticeable in the final episode how both Ritchie and Roscoe found warmth from their fathers.

Roscoe learned that his father was shocked to discover how people with Aids were treated back in Nigeria. He asked for Roscoe's forgiveness.

Richie found an understanding from his father, while his mum still could not comprehend her son's lifestyle.

The final episode was a tour de force from Keeley Hawes when her character learned that her son has Aids. A mixture of confusion and anger as she rushes up and down the hospital corridor.

The punch to the gut being she denies Richie's friends to say their final goodbyes to him.

There were flaws when it came to the blame game. I too found Jill's final words with Richie's mother hit a false note.

Overall It's a Sin was a series that avoided the obvious morbid cliches. It had a fizz but also the sourness without being too maudlin.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Don't overthink it.
hartj-759832 April 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I adored the character of Lydia and had I not known people just like her in real life would consider her to be too good to be true but even though I am one of her biggest fans I believe she was wrong to blame the Keeley Hawes character for how her son turned out.

It was the character's only bum note in the entire series but we are all victims of victims of victims. Why blame a person for being homophobic when society has formed them in that way?
1 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed