(TV Series)

(1950)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Almonds and tobacco... a deadly combination
XhcnoirX20 May 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Ice hockey star William Free disappears after an alcohol-filled and rowdy night on the town. William Gargan is called him to find him, as his team needs him for an important final game of the season. He finds him in time, but Free suffers a nasty fall during the game, and dies. At first ruled accidental, the scent of almonds from the last bottle of brandy Free drank in the locker room, makes Gargan suspicious. When the scent turns out harmless, all seems well, except for Gargan's gut feeling.

William Gargan ('Night Editor') was TV's first Martin Kane, and he also played the character on the radio. He gives Kane a calm, contemplative edge, offset by regular Walter Kinsella as the often dumbfounded police detective who's always outsmarted by Kane. Add the 'creative' use of a tobacco store where they often hang out for some really in-your-face product placement, and you have the basic premise of the show. The stories are really basic, necessitated by the half hour time slot, but fun to watch.

What sets this episode apart is a sequence in the middle where a number of suspects are interrogated, who were all in the locker room when Free drank the bottle of brandy. It's shot in a totally noir way, stark single-source lighting on the suspect's face in an otherwise completely dark space, camera looking up at the suspects faces. Nice work, adding some grittiness to this episode.

A nice episode in a nice series, of which way too few episodes have survived. 7/10

As a nice piece of trivia, this episode has a cameo by TV and radio sports announcer Win Elliot, who also happens to be the brother of Biff Elliot, who played Mike Hammer in 1953's 'I, The Jury'.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The plot itself lacks zeal, but at least it ends with an important appeal
AlsExGal13 July 2023
This week's episode of Martin Kane needs to be sponsored by Geritol, because the plot has iron poor blood.

An obnoxious and chronically drunk hockey player dies on the ice with what looks like a head injury, causing the team to lose the game and control of the team to be thrown to an underworld figure. But Martin Kane, P. I. thinks that the player was poisoned instead and prods the police to investigate.

This episode was rather boring with an extended "third degree" section in which ill defined characters with which we are not familiar are drilled over the dead hockey player's death.

In the one scene that actually has some life in it, tobacco store owner Happy McMann tries to repair a radio and almost burns down his store. Or, I should say, Sergeant Ross does the repair that almost burns down the store, crediting his electronics ability to his Harvard education. There certainly is some bias against the college educated in these old shows, back when a college degree was not very common.

The end of the show has William Gargan reminding people to give to the March of Dimes and he mentions polio, which will be a big problem until a vaccine is devised and released in 1955.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed