Intrusos en Manasés (2008) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
1/10
A Powerful Beginning, But It Is All Downhill After That. Too Bad, This Film Had Promise.
Michael-703 April 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Why should I be upset over a minor horror film that falls apart at the end? A fair question, but let me explain why God's Forgotten Town was a disappointing insult to my humanity.

After the credits, Syra (Marina Gatell) and Roberto (Armando del Rio) a writer and photographer for a Spanish magazine covering the paranormal, visit the high-rise apartment of a distraught woman and her disturbed daughter. This woman is being driven insane by voices that only she seems to hear.

Sensing there is no "paranormal" angle here, Syra helpfully offers her the name of a good psychologist and the woman gets angry and demands that Syra and Roberto leave. Apparently, Syra and Roberto are not big believers in the paranormal and they are both doing this because it is a paying job until something better comes along.

Then, out in the hallway, Syra begins to hear a conglomeration of bizarre sounds and voices just like the woman described so she races back into the apartment just in time to see the woman sitting on the balcony railing with her screaming daughter; but before Syra can do anything, the woman jumps off the balcony with her daughter, both falling to a horrible death.

This got my attention!

This event really affects Syra and it is some time before she feels well enough to go out on another assignment. This time, Syra and Roberto, are paired with a video camera operator named Julia (Sonia Lazaro) and a sound man named Ruben (Miguel Angel Munoz). They are sent out to investigate a 60 year old mystery regarding the complete disappearance of the inhabitants of a small Spanish town called Manases after a Nazi airplane crashed nearby in 1945.

But Syra has changed, she now thinks if she had only believed the woman when she was talking about voices and spirits, perhaps the woman would not have jumped. This means that Syra is now in a frame of mind to believe that every stray breeze or bump in the night is a real paranormal experience. Sure enough, when this Spanish road company of The Blair Witch Project arrives in Manases, all kinds of strange things happen and it's just one cliché after another.

We have quick cuts to frightening images combined with loud bangs on the soundtrack to jolt us, their car, which has functioned perfectly up till now, suddenly dies and when the group tries to leave on foot, Syra twists her ankle and can't go on any further.

Julia and Ruben decide to walk back to the nearby town, but instead of walking along the safe highway, they decide (as only people in horror movies ever do), that walking through the dark mysterious forest is the best way to go. At one point, an exasperated Syra says to the still skeptical Roberto, "I don't see why it's so difficult for you to accept all this" referring to the paranormal events.

Well, let me answer for him.

How about this, before he gives up on every bit of scientific evidence, every piece of intelligently understood knowledge and well considered theories about the physical world which have been tested time and again over the millennia, he's going to need a bit more evidence than some dopey woman's "intuition" or the "gut feelings" of a camera operator who is always smoking a joint.

In one sequence, the spirits gather up a variety of crockery and telekinetically smash it against the walls of a house. Everybody witnesses this and I suppose it means the spirits just want to communicate something.

Here's my question, if the spirits have the ability to throw pottery all around the room, why don't they have the ability to pick up a pencil and just write a nice note explaining what they want? Does becoming a spirit only effect your penmanship, but not your throwing arm?

Unsurprisingly, the whole mishegas of this film is related to the Nazi plane that crashed nearby in 1945 while en route to Berlin. Apparently, the plane had been carrying some kind of "scepter of power" (whatever that is), which would have enabled the Nazi's to win WWII.

But the plane crashed and the power scepter never reached Hitler, so the surviving Nazi officer tried to use the power scepter himself and apparently in order to do this, he had to have all the inhabitants of Manases killed, seemingly for no reason.

I don't want to defend the Nazis, but even they didn't go in for wanton killing. In fact, what made the Nazis so chilling was they were quite clear about their reasons for killing, no matter what we may think of them now.

In fact, this is the point in the film where I got insulted. The Nazis were one of the cruelest, most dangerous threats to civilization ever to challenge us and they ran roughshod over most of Europe for well over a decade.

Because of the Nazis, the world was plunged into one of the worst wars ever fought. Millions upon millions of people were killed fighting their incredible war machine. The Nazis were also responsible for one of the most vicious and nearly successful attempts at genocide in the entirety of human history.

It took a worldwide effort to defeat them. From Stalingrad to D-Day and beyond, the Nazis lost because of brave, dedicated and above all ordinary men and women who did not want the world to run according to the visions of Hitler, were willing to lay down their lives for that cause.

And now this dinky little piece of horror trash from Spain tries to sell us the idea that none of that other stuff mattered and that all the Nazis needed to win was some dumb scepter of power from South America?

This film is a turkey. Please avoid it.
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Ghost town
jotix10028 January 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Julia, an investigative reporter, experiences a shocking moment after interviewing a disturbed woman as she sees the lady grab her daughter and jump out of a window into what was a sure death. Julia was having a hard time getting over that experience. When she is asked to do a piece for television about a mountain town whose people disappeared during WWII, she puts together a team to cover the story for television.

As the group arrive in the abandoned village, they begin to sense the ghost of the former inhabitants of the town. Julia is followed by a young girl who, as the story unfolds it is clear she and the rest of the villagers died a horrible death at the hand of a bunch of Nazis as their aircraft crashed nearby.

Unfortunately, director Juan Carlos Claver goes for the cheap visual effects that do nothing to enhance the story. As written by David Munoz and Daniel Garcia, the screenplay is poorly conceived as it appears that Julia's traumatic shock at the beginning points, in some way, or even justifies, what follows once the television crew gets into the abandoned village. This film was produced some years ago and evidently, it did not get a theatrical release for quite some time. Evidently, the producers did not even trust the material because of their fear of unfavorable acceptance by the audience they targeted.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed