Secretariat (2010) Poster

(2010)

User Reviews

Review this title
164 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Good, but not GREAT!
howardhorsehold13 October 2010
My grandmother was a parent during the '50's and liked everything neat and clean and in its place. Heaven forbid if things get too out of hand; too "real". I have waited my entire life for Hollywood to tell Secretariat's story and after watching Disney's Secretariat my heart remains unsatisfied. It was a good, "feel good" movie, but "good" is the keyword. I felt like Grandma edited this movie. Again, it is a good movie with some interjections of great cinematography, yet Secretariat was a GREAT horse and deserved a GREAT movie. This was an Oscar winning story, with an Oscar winning cast, but the script was emotionally impotent. There were no risks and risk is what horse racing is all about. The movie is so safe and there wasn't anything safe about the facts that surround this horse and his rise to be the greatest race horse that ever lived.

Still today, when I watch Secretariat run on YouTube, I cry!!! I'm not sure why, but the tears flow from the depths of my being. Rationally, I try to tell myself that he is just a horse, but something overcomes me every time, no matter how many times I watch him run. That overwhelming surge of emotion is what this story deserved. If you've ever been in the presence of a great horse, you will know what I am talking about. They are strong and confident. You can feel their aura. There is a low rolling thunder of excitement when you are near them. Talk to the people who were there. Read the first hand accounts of their emotional state when they saw this horse run. He was mesmerizing, captivating, unexplainably breathtaking. The audience deserved to feel the thunder roll through them in every scene.

I expected so much more from director Randall Wallace. The power and emotion of Braveheart, We Were Soldiers, Pearl Harbor, The Man in the Iron Mask, is what Secretariat deserves. Where was that? I'm not sure what research he did for this movie and how much his hands were tied by the real life characters or the studio, but the main character became the background and what was in the forefront was a "sugar coated" conflict of a woman with a driving passion and the place society and her family was trying to lock her into; however, even her passion didn't spill out onto the audience as it should have. I felt like the accomplishments of Penny Chenery and Secretariat have been shrunk down and placed into a nice, neat little box fit for a good little housewife and her sweet little horse. I felt as if I was the one being squelched, because I wanted so badly for everyone to share the emotion I feel at the sheer audaciousness when this horse ran. To accomplish what they accomplished, he and his owner had to be completely audacious to rise above the negativity and overwhelming odds surrounding them.

Diane Lane is one of my favorite actresses; however, her role left me doubting the character. For example, when a woman talks to her horse, she does more than look into his eye for a few seconds and say, "Well OK then". When a woman truly needs to know something from her horse she breathes him in, they breathe each other in, as their souls entwine and one knows the other. You will see it on his face and you will see it on her face, without human words being spoken. This is a rare and special event, but it happens, and it could have carried this movie. If you have seen Diane Lane in "Unfaithful" you will realize this is an actress that could translate this kind of communication and emotion to the screen.

The audience should have been allowed to feel the emotional range that surrounds all involved in preparing a horse for the greatest races any thoroughbred will ever run. Just watch horse racing on television and you will see real raw emotion that these people explode with at the end of the race. So much was on the line for everyone involved and yet throughout the movie everyone handled the stress with subdued emotion, never getting too far off the scale. Just when you thought someone was going to show some real feelings, they apologized for it. Real life is just as ugly as it is beautiful. Without the dark of night, the brightest stars would never beam their intense beauty upon us. Every masterpiece must have its extreme contrasts to fulfill the emotional needs of its audience.

I'm not blaming anyone. I am sure everyone involved did their best. I am simply sharing with the reader my disappointment in what I thought would be a thrilling tribute to a horse so deserving.

Ron Turcotte said the film captured the story "pretty well". I ask you, is "pretty well" good enough for the greatest race horse who ever ran on the track? Secretariat's heart was two and a half times the size of a normal horse's heart; I feel the portrayal of his story should have been two and a half times the size of any regular movie. He gave us everything he had when he ran the Belmont; thirty-one lengths ahead of Sham who was an amazing, record breaking horse in his own right. Don't we owe it to him, to give him everything we've got, to see that generations to come understand the events that transpired to make him who he is? Have we as a culture become so jaded that there can be no magic in the truth? Can the epic only be found in fiction? I don't believe it. I believe that purity of a moment of perfection forever locked in time is where magic can be found and that magic is why it brings inspiration and tears to the eyes of the soul who seeks it.

Suzette Howard
113 out of 156 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Secretariat is another of those enjoyable feel-good true-life stories Disney has a reputation for
tavm18 October 2010
In a change of pace, I decided to watch this inspirational true-life story of a woman's deciding to keep the title character horse in ownership instead of selling to the highest bidder because of the animal's potential and not the usual comedy films I view with my movie theatre working friend. We both enjoyed those race scenes that involved Secretariat that showcased both his struggles and triumphs. On the drama front, while there are some compellingly played scenes of quiet desperation and of occasional conflict, it's the uplifting parts that really gets to the heart of the matter. Only thing I really have a quibble with is some of the lines betray the time period like that character played by Fred Dalton Thompson wouldn't compare something to Super Fly since that movie came out in 1972 and his scene takes place in 1969. And how about the kids not noticeably aging during the four-year setting. Otherwise, Secretariat is a quality feel-good movie that one always expects from The Disney Company and is recommended.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Big Red with Wings
ferguson-616 September 2010
Greetings again from the darkness. The story of Secretariat is legendary in the world of thoroughbred racing. Being a sports fan, it is always fascinating to witness domination by a singular athlete - Michael Jordan, Tiger Woods, Roger Federer. Secretariat was the Michael Jordan of racing. In 1973, Big Red dominated racing like no other.

What makes this even more amazing is that Secretariat is actually the second most interesting story ... his owner, Penny Chenery Tweedy (played here by Diane Lane), was his match in competitive spirit. This Disney movie actually spends as much time on Ms. Tweedy as it does the fabulous horse.

Disney does what Disney does best. This is an all out feel-good, rah-rah movie in the vein of "Seabiscuit", "The Rookie", "Rudy" and even "Hoosiers". Don't expect in-depth analysis of the racing world or horse training or even horse farm operations. This movie is made to deliver a warm fuzzy via the perseverance of a strong-willed lady and an incredibly majestic animal.

Expect some over-the-top touches such as John Malkovich's portrayal of trainer Lucen Laurin, horse-whispering by Ms. Lane, and plenty of heart-string tugging as is customary from the fine folks at Disney. Expect historical facts to be treated a bit lax in some scenes (no mention of 1972 Derby winner Riva Ridge, also from the Chenery stables). Expect none of that to matter as this is a crowd-pleaser, not a documentary.

In addition to Mr. Malkovich and Ms. Lane, there is some fine support work from Fred Thompson, James Cromwell and Nelsan Ellis (so great as Lafayette in True Blood). Directed by Randall Wallace, whose most recent directorial effort was 2002's "We Were Soldiers", this is entertainment for all ages and an easy introduction to the champion that was Secretariat.
62 out of 86 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Good movie, but Secretariat was a GREAT horse, and he deserves nothing less than that.
chica7218613 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I went into this movie not expecting anything brilliant, but a fun movie that portrayed a great horse which is exactly what it was(especially since it's a Disney movie). I had no problem that the story was mainly about Penny Chenery and what she did, my problem was that they took the most memorable and moving race of all time (The Belmont) and turned it into a rushed scene. I felt as though they did not spend enough time on Secretariat's magic that happened that day at Belmont. The fact that the race wasn't recorded at Belmont isn't the problem, because there are so many other problems with this scene. The music was just silly - no emotion whatsoever (when I watch the actual footage of this race, there is SO much emotion!). They could have made this scene far better than it was. Maybe I'm comparing it too much to the Match Race and the last race scene from the movie Sea Biscuit - now those were scenes and music put together that gave me goosebumps and tears to my eyes. Secretariat just gets a quick race scene with some silly music as he comes down the last turn. Not too emotional if you ask me.

Diane Lane did a wonderful job as Penny Chenery and you are always rooting for her throughout the entire movie. I can't say the same for her family. Her husband was an ignorant jerk, as was her brother. And why did her peace loving hippie daughter get the extra screen time that Secretariat deserved!? That really irked me. Before this movie came out, so many people were assuming that Sham, Secretariats biggest rival, was not going to be mentioned at all. Well that certainly was not the case as they did a good job at letting the audience know just who Sham was, which really impressed me.

I own race horses and I watch actual footage on youtube of the great ones, especially Secretariat, and I get chills and get a tear to my eye just watching him run (mainly the Derby and the Belmont), and I thought for sure there would be at least one time in the movie where I would get emotional, but no, not one scene had that effect on me. If you know a lot about horse racing and/or truly see how much of a wonderful horse Secretariat was, you will not think this movie is up to par. I also think the movie Sea Biscuit involved more emotion towards the horse from the audience more so than Secretariat does. If you are aware of how great of a horse he was, you will love him, but if you're going into this movie not knowing much about Secretariat, the director fails to bring you emotionally involved with him. I will most likely buy this movie when it comes out because overall I did enjoy it, but I just wish it could have been better.

Simply put, like my title says, Secretariat (the horse himself) was nothing short of great, and this movie is decent at best, and I'm sorry, but the best race horse of all time does not deserve "good" or decent" ... he deserves "GREAT."
17 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Secretariat is my hero
jamesquinlan-422201 April 2021
I really enjoyed this movie and Secretariat is my hero because he is a horse just like me. I really like watching racing and he is my favourite racer. When I grow up I want to be a race horse just like him and I really think I'm on the right track.

Get it? Track, because horses run on tracks, and Secretariat is a horse and I am horse.

Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the track? Because Secretariat is a horse just like me and horses run on tracks? Do you get the joke?

Anyway how do you not be sad?
28 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Exciting Fare
JohnDeSando7 October 2010
"It is beautiful to watch a fine horse gallop, the long stride, the rush of the wind as he passes—my heart beats quicker to the thud of the hoofs and I feel his strength." Richard Jefferies

Secretariat is no exception. It's the story of the fastest horse in history, first known as Big Red, who went on to win horse racing's triple crown on 1973, a feat not accomplished in 25 years. After that he sired 600 foals, much to the delight of his investors, the first to invest solely in a stud future.

But then I love Seabiscuit (2003) for it depression-era cheerleading. This is what American filmmakers do well--a rouser with messages, big–screen chases, and sentimentality for the little guy. Seabiscuit is Rocky for horses, a suspenseful crowd pleaser with characters such as the whisperer played by Chris Cooper, who said, "You don't throw a whole life away just because it's banged up a little." The thought resonates for almost everyone in the film, a tribute to unity of theme and expression of actor.

Similarly there's more than just a racing film in Secretariat; after all National Velvet has a more interesting story and a younger heroine in Elizabeth Taylor, but that was decades ago. This true story is about the grit of Penny Chenery, who took over Virginia's Meadow Stables from her father and beat the male-dominated odds.

This quintessential Disney movie depicts her as tough and loving, a mother and a businesswoman, who can serve as a model for young women aspiring to reach great goals even in this liberated 21st century, which still has a ways to go before it expunges fully the sexism scourge.

The photography is bracing, often putting the camera right by the prancing hoofs or mid-level close to the steed's haunches. Although nothing new here, it is still exciting fare. Because we all know going in that our horse will win the crown, director Randall Wallace is especially successful in keeping us interested and worried for Secretariat.

Disclosure: I like most Hollywood horse-racing stories.
30 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Secretariat, U.S. Triple Crown Champion 1973. Penny Chenery, Owner, Housewives Champion.
hitchcockthelegend10 February 2013
Secretariat is directed by Randall Wallace and written by Mike Rich and Sheldon Turner. It stars Diane Lane, John Malkovich, Margo Martindale, Amanda Michalka, Dylan Walsh, Scott Glenn, Kevin Connolly, Dylan Baker, James Cromwell and Drew Roy. Music is by Nick Glennie-Smith and cinematography by Dean Semler.

With the success and quality of production that came with 2003's Seabiscuit, it was perhaps inevitable that someone would turn their hand to making a film about a horse that many agree is the greatest American horse of all time. With Disney funding the cash flow and an "A" list cast assembled, Secretariat the movie is every inch the professional production you would expect. However, thematically it's surprising that the horse is very much secondary to the story of his owner, Penny Chenery (Lane).

Chenery's story as written on the film version page, is a worthy one to tell, for sure. After suffering family bereavements, she stood firm after winning the horse on a coin toss to guide the horse to the greatest of American horse racing triumphs. This in a male dominated sport dominated by chauvinists. Further more, Chenery had to hold her own family together whilst running the Chenery ranch. Inspirational woman for sure, and Lane is naturally steely in the role, but there just isn't great human interest drama crafted by director Wallace to warrant the film being primarily about the good lady.

Naturally, when the horse racing takes centre stage it's gripping and exciting, the race segments very well filmed, but we already knew that Secretariat was an awesome horse, how he got to be that way isn't known to us. Malkovich plays trainer Lucien Laurin with moody flamboyance, but we see next to nothing of his training of the horse! It's one of the many oversights that stop the film competing with Seabiscuit. It may seem unfair to compare the two, but the makers of Seabiscuit got the blend right whilst cleaving close to the facts to tell their story.

There's also the controversy factor, the fudging of the facts to suit the makers ends, where some characterisations have been pointedly argued to be incorrect and a deviation from truths to the point we don't have the real story of what made Secretariat so great. Whilst it spins a rags to riches story when in reality it wasn't, Riva Ridge anyone? Where's the Preakness clocking controversy? These facts would have boosted the film no end, but I guess this is the price we pay for having Disney funding the film supposedly about the magnificent beast in the title.

Come the home straight the music does swirl and the cheers go loud, and undeniably the uplift factor takes a hand, but there's too much wrong all told to make this a great picture. I have to say it, go watch Seabiscuit instead. 6.5/10
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wonderful movie
victorysongster2 December 2010
Secretariat is not only the first film in many years where both old and young can share the same theater; it contains the elements that make you both laugh and cry as most good movies should. From peaceful mornings at sunrise we experience exhilarating horse racing that brings pensive waiting for results of a race already in the history books.

I agree with the Movieguide comments: "SECRETARIAT is a very uplifting, inspiring, exciting movie about a true story, the story of a determined woman who raises one of the most successful, dynamic racehorses of all time. SECRETARIAT is stirring and joyful, with many references to God, Jesus Christ and the Bible and a pro-capitalist message celebrating American values…" Now, what's wrong with this picture? It is refreshingly entertaining.
45 out of 62 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Maybe Next Time They'll Make a Movie About Secretariat
BenLapke2 October 2010
The movie is great for families, as there were a number of children in the theater who really enjoyed the film. There isn't any off-color language or scenes, and it is well acted and well made. My main complaint is that it really seemed to be the Penny Tweedy story, and not that much about Secretariat. If you want to take your children to a well made movie with horses, this is a good film. If you want to learn about the greatest racehorse of the 20th century, go to you tube and watch old clips of the actual horse itself. If you're looking for a good movie about a horse, buy or rent Seabiscuit. That movie tells much more of the story about the horse.
54 out of 92 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best sports movies EVER! And a fine movie in general.
McCormack77 October 2010
SECRETARIAT is not just a great great sports movie it is just a great movie full-stop. EVery about this film is spot on. The story is wonderfully crafted and well told. The photography is beautiful and classy. The acting is phenomenal. DIANE LANE is in Oscar form as Penny Chenery the owner of Secretariat. She owns the film and gives a very powerful and realistic portrayal. JOHN MALKOVICH is also superb in support. The racing scenes are simply stunning. You are there in the race. It is very well done (and doesn't resort to cheap "shaky-cam" stuff. A very moving and enjoyable movie. It's one of the best sports related movies EVER and comes very highly recommended!
56 out of 91 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Penny's story more than Secretariat's story
MosHr7 September 2010
Warning: Spoilers
If you've watched the trailer then you know the entire storyline. What can the film offer when you know what is going to happen? Disappointingly, at least to me, nothing much about horses or the world of racing except bits and pieces to drive the story forward. Nothing really about the horse is shown, it's told to us. Except for the final half an hour or so, it feels like a theater play rather than a movie.

The focus of the movie is squarely on Penny, played by Diane Lane, and perhaps in some ways only about her while the rest of the cast and the horse fill up her world. The first half of the movie about Penny and her story about being a strong woman, and the second half of the movie is the races, edited with a billion reaction shots in it. It constantly switches over every few seconds to show reactions of the actors, spoon feeding us reactions rather than the race show itself.

The movie is very well acted and told, and is solid in every aspect. It has the period drama sheen and Penny's story as the main focus takes it more into women's movie territory. Overall, it's a good movie but nothing we haven't seen before quite a few times.
12 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Run, Fat Horse, Run
estebangonzalez1029 March 2011
¨This is not about going back. This is about life being ahead of you and you run at it. Because you never know how far you can run unless you run.¨

Secretariat is one of those rare sports movies that manages to hook your attention and maintain the suspense despite knowing how it will turn out at the end. It's impossible not to fall in love with this horse and his story. Disney was the right choice for the production of this film considering their success with other family friendly sport films like Remember the Titans. Secretariat was voted as one of the best athletes of the century (number one on the list if we don't count human performances), and several of his records still stand to this very day nearly 40 years later. His story had to be told in film as Secretariat is considered to be the best racehorse of all time. The story involving his owner, Penny Chenery, and how she saved her ailing father's stable risking everything (including her marriage) and betting it on the horse just adds to the overall dramatic effect of the plot. Secretariat reminded me a lot of another good racehorse film: Seabiscuit. I wouldn't say this is a better movie, it's different, but I can say that Secretariat was a better racehorse that won the most important races, including the Triple Crown in 1973 (a feat that hadn't been accomplished in 25 years). Randall Wallace (writer of Braveheart and director of We Were Soldiers) did a good job with the direction of this film, despite being better known as a screenplay writer. The screenplay for Secretariat was written by Mike Rick, which was adapted from William Nack's book about the large chestnut colt nicknamed ¨Big Red.¨

Diane Lane is Penny Chenery, a mother of four and housewife who's life changes after her mother's death and a visit to their stable based in Virginia. Penny's father used to be the brains of the entire operation in Meadow Stables, but with the death of his wife and his illness things are going downhill at the stable. Penny decides to change things around in order to save the stable and begins by firing their trainer who seems to be making some unfavorable deals with other owners by trying to sell their horses at a much lower value. Penny with the help of the family's trustworthy secretary, Miss Ham (played humorously by Margo Martindale) begins managing the place. The first smart move she makes is breeding one of her horses: Somethingroyal with a famous Thoroughbred racehorse named Bold Ruler. The result was the birth of the large chestnut colt nicknamed ¨Big Red¨, but better known in the horse-racing world as Secretariat. Penny hires Lucien Laurin (John Malkovich) as the trainer and Ron Turcotte (Otto Thorwarth) as the jockey, and along with the groom, Eddie Sweet (Nelsan Ellis) together they form a great team and foster the first Triple Crown winner in 25 years. Of course the movie can't be successful if it doesn't have some drama in it, and so some problems surface back home with Penny's husband, Jack Tweedy (Dylan Walsh), because running a stable back in Virginia has affected Penny with her housewife duties. Somehow Penny has to manage saving the stable in a macho dominated society and maintain her family together, while risking everything on one horse: Secretariat.

Secretariat succeeds as a film because the story is just so powerful and uplifting. The movie deals with overcoming difficult odds and following one's dream. Penny had a good life as a housewife, but all this had led her far away from her early goal of following her father's footsteps and managing the Meadow Stables. Once the opportunity presents itself to her she quickly takes on the difficult task and decides to follow her long life dream. Secretariat teaches us that it's never too late to follow one's dreams and overcome difficult situations. Disney has always been good at reminding us how important it is to fight for our dreams. Life is a race and if we don't wake up in time our dreams and goals might just end in that: only dreams and we will never achieve anything if we don't take risks in order to live out our dreams. Penny took the risk and bet it all on Secretariat who didn't fail her. The story of this colt is just amazing and inspiring. The final scene where he is racing at the Belmont Stakes is just mesmerizing and left me full of goose bumps. Secretariat was such an amazing horse, and his story is done justice in this family friendly film. It is a strong, memorable movie that teaches us some important lessons while at the same time never ceases to entertain it's audience. The performances in this movie are also great. Diane Lane as Penny and John Malkovich as Lucien give memorable and fun performances. Secretariat is a movie for the entire family to enjoy.

http://estebueno10.blogspot.com/
12 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Horse Movies: and other enjoyable clichés
blackfirepro15 November 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Horse racing (and horses in general) has never really interested me. Really, when a horse and Disney come together, we can be sure we're in for a feel good, slightly clichéd film with lots of "life lessons" along the way. Now this may sound cynical (which I suppose it is), but you can't say that I'm wrong. There's nothing intrinsically wrong about the use of clichés and riddling a film with life lessons, but it can be sticky. There have also been a lot, and I mean a lot! of horse racing movies involving the unbelievable odds against the horse and the unshaken perseverance of the owner. Now for some reason, these horse movies usually turn out as enjoyable, fun (if not new) experiences. Can Secretariat bring anything new whatsoever to the dusty, yet still well-varnished table of horse racing movies? No. Does Secretariat fall into unfortunate horse racing clichés such as slow motion, intrusive music, anthropomorphic animals, and dumb "wise sayings" for the main character? Yes. It does all of these things. However, like its tired old predecessors, Secretariat succeeds for the most part in being a shallow yet enjoyable and cute movie.

We all know the story. After Penny Tweedy's father dies, she takes over his farm and raises a horse named Big Red, who goes on to become "the greatest racing horse that ever lived", so we don't need to get into that. Diane Lane plays the aforementioned Mrs. Tweedy, and her performance is acceptable if not a little contrived. John Malkovich plays Lucien Laurin, the horse's trainer. Laurin wears bright and tactless colors along with unfashionable hats. His whole demeanor celebrates the eccentric. Malkovich was probably the only actor who could have done this role with such zaniness and subtlety. The first shots of Malkovich feature him attempting to hit golf balls on the driving range. His swing teeters on the edge of hopelessness and we can tell immediately that he has no business in "retirement". This man should be out training horses. Penny comes to him offering a job, and Laurin has no business saying "No", but of course he does. After much deliberation on his part, he finally agrees to take the job and the so the story begins. Malkovich is as wonderful as ever, and the film wouldn't be nearly as entertaining without him. John Malkovich is a treasured performer.

Now this is a perfectly harmless film that is meant for escapism purposes only. The film never gets to deep, and doesn't explore in depth the dynamics of horse racing or the psyche of our main character, Mrs. Tweedy, and what motivates her. The film strives to be nothing but a fell good movie and it accomplishes just that. While we're watching it, we fell good for the most part. This movie makes no boasts about being deep or intellectual or thought provoking. Secretariat lives to entertain its audience and for the most part it does. I was entertained. People in the theater around me seemed entertained. Truth be told, it is not a great movie, nor can we expect it to be. Sometimes pure feel good movies do become great movies, but for the most part they ignite the shallowest of human emotions such as love, hate, and sorrow. All of these thrive in Secretariat as they should. It tells a sweet and gentle, typically Disney story that just keeps us lightly amused and entertained throughout its two hours and three minutes. I think this generic formula works pretty well. So, is the movie good? Yes. Is it original? Big fat NO!

My main problems with the movie are more technical. I hated the musical score. I just wish that for once Hollywood would cut out the dramatic, intrusive, invasive music at climax points and stop telling us how to feel! We shouldn't have to be told how to feel by big booming and thunderous musical notes. If a movie can't do this without such a pretentious score then it is not succeeding. The incidental musical score was also a big problem for me in this years Inception, a film I liked very much except for this small point. I also can't stand slow motion. Every film since Chariots of Fire has insisted on slowing down the final moments of a race to show the winner run like molasses threw the finish line. This has become a ridiculously overused cliché in film making and it must be stopped NOW! The next slow runner I see on screen will cause convulsion to seize my body. I am so sick and tired of slow motion in racing movies. Haven't we had enough? End rant . . . Other flaws in the film include the anthropomorphism of the horse. Look, the horse doesn't know what's really going on, and horses don't pose, and their owner can't peer deep into their "souls" by looking quietly into their eyes. This is another horse movie cliché that unfortunately Secretariat revels in. I assure all of you animists out there that no horse has ever had a reasonable thought, and it certainly has no soul. That's just a fact of life. Why Hollywood (and Disney in particular) insists on making these animals as human as possible baffles me. I have not ever, do not now, and will not ever understand this folly of animal movies. Maybe it's to get the audience to cry!

Anyway, despite its many flaws, Secretariat wants to entertain us and succeeds most of the time. A few clichés could have been avoided along with some technical errors, and perhaps the film takes a little too long to finish, but for the most part I liked the movie. I think most people will like the movie unless they're really, really curmudgeons. And a note to Randall Wallace: you are a talented man who makes good, wholesome, well-meaning, spiritual movies. Yes, I include Braveheart here as well.

www.colewebbharter.com
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Audaciously and Obviously Calculating Fantasyland Stuff
jzappa1 November 2010
Secretariat isn't about a horse. Or a jockey. Or a trainer. It's about a horse owner, an upper-class housewife, with only her father's farm to lose. There's not much in jeopardy even if the film will relentlessly strive to assure you everything is under threat. Any number of animated Disney films do better at paying tribute to the animal. And Babe, Seabiscuit, My Dog Skip. This one venerates the person who owned it. Secretariat was a Time cover story. You don't sense that watching this. Rather than showcasing the greatest racehorse ever, they opted the rich owner could be the underdog. Merely a handful of times did it appear the filmmakers were truly fascinating by the beauty or nobility of the animal.

Instead, the entire film's overflowing with Diane Lane giving campaign speeches, beginning with her voice-over quoting the Bible. It continues with lines like, "You never know how far you can go unless you run!" She believes in Secretariat. Why? Because. I'm not saying belief's a bad thing, but there's insufficient elucidation for her determination.

An extraordinarily successful racehorse has been Disney-fied for escapist distraction. It's when reality's substituted and in its place the writer of Pearl Harbor and that of Radio and The Nativity Story exceed the boundary, enter melodrama. The imperious, domineering soundtrack distracts, oversweetens rather than keeping us absorbed or authentically uplifted. As near as I can distinguish there was no considerable tension between her and rival horseman Pancho Martin, owner of Secretariat's foremost challenger. He's a sexist blowhard. There's no background, so it just comes off as a performance. It'd seem it was felt the movie needed a bad guy.

The other non-white speaking role's Eddie, a black thoroughbred groom who's a member of a much more dangerous movie stereotype. He dances, sings, loves Jesus and that mighty ole horse. He's immediately deferential to "Miss Penny," induces soul and gospel music into her bothered life. The movie wants us to "believe" something? I believe that Eddie should've been the human character at the center. He spends more actual time, makes more physical contact with Secretariat than anyone else, knows him most deeply. If there's an underdog in this film at all, it's absolutely him. And he should've been given a three-dimensional characterization.

Like her horse, Penny's lucked out in life's sweepstakes. She's a wealthy Denver housewife with four children. After her mother dies, she returns to her parents' Virginia horsefarm to aid her senile father. Upon losing a toss with another owner, she wins the rights to the stable's least-valuable foal, the offspring of a stallion with speed but no stamina. Except in some way, Penny knows this massive, tenacious colt can turn into history's greatest racehorse. During the plodding exposition, the film jogs out a roll call of guest stars---James Cromwell, Dylan Baker…Fred Thompson…Jesus---to notify Penny of what she can and cannot do before she ignores them and prevails.

The script works hard to encumber her with some hardship to prevail over: The farm may have to be sold, leaving her with just her own manse back in Denver! She really misses her kids when she's out on the circuit! The country club doesn't allow women! Nevertheless the outcome's predetermined anyway, so what's the difference? The key to making that difference would've been focusing either on the horse or the human who had the closest relationship with the horse, not the human who wanted to make money off the horse.

Malkovich's presence single-handedly can make you find appeal in something otherwise unexciting. Then again, why don't we get to see his ordeal? This character's turned into a comic-relief second-banana. He's the trainer, though we seldom see that. There's one moment that illustrates him best, when we see he hoards the newspaper clippings from his defeats. Otherwise it's merely about looking at his loud wardrobe.

This is audaciously, obviously calculating fantasyland stuff, passing itself off as a "true story," when, in effect, it's what's called "fact-based." And that's not quite the same thing. Trouble can arise from the strength of such movies being taken at face value as fact. Secretariat disregards this inevitable verity. Yes, the characters—well, most of them—are drawn from real life, reinterpreted for highest effect. Yes, there certainly was a Secretariat who did these extraordinary things. But what's staged is not the special journey of those things, but a sugar-rich castle-in-the-sky of the American precedent as born-agains and traditionalists would like to envision, laden with slushy grandeur, washed spotless of social conflict or more than one ethnic culture.

In this film's world, self-sufficient, strong-minded women like Penny ensures that conforming to "lady-like" standards of behavior take precedence, liberal activism's a naive puppy period your kids experience until they discover the harsh realities of estate taxes, and all faultless Americans are unified in their worship of a miraculous object of vague optimistic abstractions like hope and fighting for this and that. The movie's portrayal of its late '60s, '70s era is a gilded utopia of all things, notwithstanding the truth that the year Secretariat evidently won was the year the Vietnam War ended and the Watergate hearings commenced. A movie so desperate for sources of drama in complete denial of the magnitude of drama in which it takes place?! You almost couldn't pick an era in 20th century America more overwhelmed by divide and broad-spectrum pandemonium. Busing desegregation, the Pentagon Papers, the Chicago Seven, the Weather Underground, Kent State, Stonewall. Regardless of finding ourselves in an infuriated, perilously divided culture, the film wants us to have faith that the real America has been here the whole time, and we can take it back. If we just believe in…a nonexistent past?
22 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Worst movie ever - but go see it anyway
KCarnage3 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
First off - know this, there is not a bigger racing fan than I am. And I truly looked forward to this movie, counting down the days, actually. But maybe because I am such a fan of racing and the great Secretariat in particular, I hated this movie. I went to see the sneak preview last night and it was awful! It was so nonfactual as to be ridiculous. There was no mention of the fact that Penny Chenery and Meadow Stables and Ron Turcotte had the Derby winner (Riva Ridge)the year before Secretariat. They wanted you to believe that Penny could get a phone call in Colorado in the middle of summer while poolside and make it to Virginia to be there for the birth of Secretariat in March with her trainer and the groom by her side. They gave Ron Turcotte a southern accent, I have met the man and he has a beautiful French-Canadian lilt to his voice. There was too much time wasted on the Marcia Brady like character of Penny's daughter and not enough racing scenes. The Preakness was shown on a small home TV for Heaven's sake!

And the worst was that they wanted you to believe that Keeneland race course was Belmont Park, Aqueduct and Saratoga. The music was terrible, I can't believe they played that dumb gospel song during the finale of Secretariat's heart-stopping Belmont triumph. And while they did have the best part of the greatest race call ever, ("Secretariat is moving like a tremendous machine") it was barely audible in the background. Why, oh why could they not just have let the race speak for itself. Please, people go watch the actual race on you tube. It will give you goose bumps. OK, so maybe as such a big fan I have over analyzed the details,but that being said, go see the movie anyway. If it brings the excitement of racing and the spirit of Big Red to just one viewer then I guess it will be worth it. For my part, I will just watch Seabiscuit, (a great racing movie) over again.
13 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Classic Disney - for better and worse
RickStarr1112 October 2010
The Disney brand lives on in "Secretariat", a come-from-behind almost-all-true story of the famous Triple Crown Winner. The two leads are great: Secretariat's owner and trainer Diane Lane and John Malkovich respectively; James Cromwell is decent and Nelsan Ellis and Otto Thorwarth credible as the stable boy and jockey, but the rest of them - particularly the family and friends - you can put in a tub and sail away.

The story, of course, is well known; Secretariat turns out to be the greatest race horse ever (he even makes ESPN's "Top 50 athletes of all time" the only non-human to do so.) The true-to-the-story twist is that Secretariat turns out to be the consolation prize of a lost bet, but still triumphs over all obstacles and odds.

Actually, the story is as much about Secretariat's owner, Penny Chenery (Diane Lane) and how she, well, triumphs over all obstacles and odds. Funny, that. While there are some empty moments while the actors are on screen (the anti-war protests are just dreadful), there aren't when the horses take over, and the POV filmography at the horses' hooves is pretty darn good. The festivities at the actual Kentucky Derby last a week and the race is over in two minutes. I wish there was more screen time for the horses here, but at least it's a better balance than that.

Disney stays true to Disney rather than conduct fealty to actual history, however the changes are not earth shattering, and you will come away with a fair semblance of the real story, if not a perfectly accurate one. A nice tear jerker, very typical for the House of the Mouse, but worth the afternoon if you have an interest in a great sports story, a horse flick, or just like seeing more of John Malkovich's quirky side in an otherwise straightforward role.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great movie
sohil87015 February 2022
The details, music, storyline, reality, everything is perfect. The movie is little slow sometimes but it was needful. Cinematography, music, storyline is perfect. Loved the movie.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Because comparisons to Sea Biscuit are inevitable ...
SkyPowers19 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
... the filmmakers had to be weary that they would be made. Their precaution may have actually hurt the film. "Sea Biscuit" was a masterpiece because of the way it got so inside the psyches of the horse and jockey, two great characters fused together. "Secretariat" does convey the steadfast resolve of the horse's owner played well by Diane Lane and it does capture the look and feel of the times and, most difficult, suspense ... when everyone knows the outcome (see "Titanic"). Sorry to say it's too bad writer-director Gary Ross wasn't at the helm. I happened to be sitting with the animal colorist of that film who cringed at the many different horses they used to play Secretariat but you don't have to be an expert to see they screwed up the most important part -- the horse's face -- sometimes with a large white diamond on the forehead, sometimes not. Sometimes a bold white line coming down from the diamond, sometimes a much thinner line. I saw a credit for horse continuity. Perhaps she didn't know about animal colorists. Or perhaps the filmmakers elected simply to focus on the human story of the owner, the horse itself, the very name of the film, more an afterthought. Nonetheless, I will recommend it as wholesome family entertainment that makes ya feel good.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"And I think tomorrow he'll be wearing wings."
classicsoncall7 April 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I don't care if you were around at the time or not, knowing how the story turns out doesn't make it any less exciting or inspirational. In 1972, the name Secretariat was every bit as ubiquitous as that of Muhammad Ali who's also mentioned by name in the picture. The only thing you weren't aware of back then, sports fan or not, was the story of owner Penny Chenery (Diane Lane), who's destiny rode on a coin toss and a dream. In a way, this one could have been called 'The Chenery Story' for it's emphasis on one person's devotion to a father's legacy and a determination to succeed in the face of adversity. With Disney Studios at the helm, you needn't worry about questionable language or suggestively explicit scenes. This is the story of a winner with a message - you never know how far you can go unless you run.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Pegasus
blanche-226 May 2011
I'm not a fan of horse racing, but you'd be hard put to find anyone who loved the horse Secretariat as much I did. "Big Red," as he was known, seemed to be able to fly, and when he was autopsied, it was learned that his heart was twice the size of normal horses. He was an amazing champion.

"Secretariat" isn't really the story of Secretariat as much as it is the story of his owner, Peggy Chenery Tweedy, very well played here by Diane Lane. I'm sure it's a somewhat romanticized version, but it's certainly true that Chenery loved and believed in Secretariat. John Malkovich plays his trainer, Lucien Laurin, and he's wonderful.

The film has an unnecessary good guy-bad guy set-up for the races, with an evil owner sure that Secretariat will lose. There's the sentimentality that goes along with a Disney story, and the idea of the little guy coming from behind.

I liked this movie, but I don't feel it does the great Secretariat justice. One of the races, the one shown on television, was an actual race. If you want to cry, check out Big Red's races on Youtube. In one of the races (I can't remember which one) the CBS clock said that Secretariat had broken a record, but the official clock did not. As Mrs. Tweedy said in an interview, the official clock time had to be used. I'm sure she feels (as I do) that Secretariat had indeed broken another record.

Secretariat died too young from laminitis, the same illness that killed Barbaro. He will always be one of the greatest horses in history. There is a wonderful documentary about him which I recommend, as well as the documentary "The First Saturday in May." Just think about Ron Turcotte, wondering why it was so quiet as he raced Big Red, why he couldn't hear the other horses. When he turned around to look, the other horses were way, way behind. That was Secretariat. A frontrunner. Pegasus.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
This movie puts you right in the saddle of one of the greatest racehorses of all time -- a movie the whole family can enjoy.
labeckley27 November 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I have little interest in movies and haven't been to a movie theater in years, but I did go to see Secretariat because that was such a big event for my horse-loving 13 year old self back in the 70's. I loved the cinematography of the movie – how it put you right into the race with one of the most phenomenal horses of the century. I particularly loved the close-ups while those passages from the Book of Job were being recited:

"He paweth in the valley, and rejoiceth in his strength: He goeth out to meet the armed men. He mocketh at fear, and is not dismayed Neither turneth he back from the sword The quiver rattleth against him, The flashing spear and the javelin He swalloweth the ground with fierceness and rage…"

It really captured the beauty and power of the racehorse—to me, the movie was worth going for those scenes alone.

The movie did contain inaccuracies and omissions (for example, I found it humorous that Pancho Martin, the trainer, was featured as if he were Sham's owner, trading barbs directly with Penny – where were Sham's owners? And that the movie made it appear that Sham won the Wood Memorial, when Angle Light was the victor, and that the coin toss over Secretariat was presented in a highly simplified manner. However, I do understand that Disney had to simplify the story line so as not to confuse the average viewer (especially after spending 20 minutes trying to explain to my husband the complexities of the way Secretariat was actually acquired in the famous coin toss.)

To me, it wasn't at all surprising that Disney developed the movie in the way they did. When I first noticed a movie was coming out about Secretariat, my immediate thought was – "What is there to say?" I wondered what there could be in the story with which a typical American movie goer could identify. This was no story of an underdog who came out of nowhere; if such an amazing horse was going to come in to being, it happened exactly in the way anyone would expect–a colt with the bloodlines of some of the best Thoroughbreds in the entire world, bred by wealthy people in Kentucky and Virginia. Secretariat was two year old Horse of the Year, and part of a racing stable that had the previous years Kentucky Derby and Preakness winner,Riva Ridge. No surprises in this story. It was clever to develop the story angle focusing on his owner, Penny Chenery, and her struggles against adversity as she brought Secretariat to the races.

I was initially no fan of Secretariat's while he was racing--I was rooting for Sham all through the triple crown races, and at the time, often felt like the only one who wanted Sham to win. I worked at a riding stable in Virginia at the time and it seemed everyone was a huge fan of Secretariat – there was so much hype and excitement over him. All you heard in the media was about the "big red machine" and how invincible he was. So for me, it was a breath of fresh air to hear about this horse from California named Sham who could be a worthy opponent for Secretariat. Secretariat seemed too beautiful and perfect, and I resented the fact that everyone was calling him by Man O' War's old nickname, "Big Red."

I admired Sham's tremendous spirit. (Perhaps I was also partial because "Sham" is the name of the Godolphin Arabian in Marguerite Henry's books-- after all, I was 13.) There's been much made in reviews of the movie over how Frank "Pancho" Martin came across as the "bad guy" because of all his boasting about Sham. It is true that he did boast about Sham, but for those of us who were fans of the horse and were weary of hearing all the time about "Big Red," it was absolutely delightful– I for one loved it.

The truth is, the real underdog in the Secretariat-Sham competition was Sham. I'm not at all surprised that Pancho's boasting was spun out of proportion in the movie to make him appear villainous, because the movie-makers had to jump through hoops to make the real underdogs appear like the villains. Let's face it – Sham's owners and trainers may not have had quite the wealth and connections of Secretariat's team – it's possible you could find a much more riveting "rags to riches" story in Pancho's background than in Penny Chenery's (she was an heiress, after all). Amidst the onslaught of publicity over the super-horse Secretariat, to me, Pancho stood like a David against Goliath passionately defending his own amazing horse.

In addition, Sham was racing on the West Coast when the very best racehorses supposedly raced on the East coast. Sham was not blessed with Secretariat's charisma or beauty – but he was a kind, extremely game horse. Though I will admit, even given all that, Sham was not a perfect underdog because he, too, just like Secretariat, was bred at Clairborne Farms in Kentucky.

Though I was and will always be a fan of Sham, when I saw Secretariat blow the rest of the field away in the Belmont Stakes, winning by 31 lengths, I was overcome with a sense of awe at having witnessed a once in a lifetime demonstration of searing power, speed, and beauty. And I fell under Secretariat's spell and became a fan of his, as well.

I'm glad Disney made this movie -- they did a nice job. It's one that the whole family can enjoy.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
High points and low points abound
witster1826 February 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This is a genre that I have enjoyed throughout the years. Seabiscut. The Black Stallion. Even the comedy 'Let if Ride' is a personal fave.

Secretariats' film will never live up to the real horse, and while that's unfair competition, this film still has some basic pitfalls that kept it from being great.

The first problem lies in the films' poor character development. Outside of the lead character, Penny(Diane Lane), we're left with very little structure for the other characters. Dylan Walsh(Jack), Margo Martindale(Miss Ham), Scott Glenn(Penny's Dying Father)and Nelson Ellis(Eddie Sweat) are characters I would have liked to have known.

At the end of the film we get an update on the characters that were featured in the movie. In that brief written update we learn more about the characters than we did in the previous hour and a half. That's my first gripe.

The second gripe is with a couple of really cheesy and unnecessary scenes. One in particular where the horse is being bathed by the cast comes off as a blend between the car wash scene in Cool Hand Luke and your average Old Spice commercial.

The horse is beautiful, and I think 'Big Red' gets a pretty good representation on film, physically, and with the horse action.

Fortunately, the film also has it's strong points. Malkovich is delightful as the French-Canadian trainer, and Diane Lane does just fine. The race segments are a blend of actual footage and incredibly exciting recreations. When you hear Secretariat breath it's almost as if the audience becomes the horse. The best moments of this film are when Big Red is the only one in the shot.

I wish the film had chose either direction. Go all horse and accolades, and make it even more beautiful in terms of cinematography, or give us more in terms of Penny's acquaintances. I felt like this was a good film with a well defined climax, but the lack of character development and the inclusion of certain scenes that should have been left on the editing floor kept this from library/review potential.

More on the quality level of 'Dreamer' or other just above average true stories like 'Tucker'. In other words; marginally recommended.

You'll like this if you liked: Dreamer, Something to Talk About, Tucker, or The Rookie.

61/100
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Wonderful
brett-762604 October 2020
I dont no why but I just love this movie. I dont follow racing let alone know much about the history. But this movie is so well written and directed its hard not to love it. Acting is perfect and for once Disney really did a great job from start to finish. If you haven't seen this, its one the entire family can enjoy. Such a good story...
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Whoosh! Yes that fast
karlcharlotte-14 October 2010
Secretariat / Rated PG for a couple of bad words and funny looking hats. Secretariat, the horse, is considered the greatest race horse of all time. He ran really, really fast. He lived from 1970 to 1989 and lives again in a new movie named in his honor. I love horsey movies. I hate spoilers in reviews. In case you don't know it I have to tell you something. Not exactly a secret. But, if you don't want to know then look away count to ten then continue reading. Secretariat won the Triple Crown. Okay that's it. It's safe to continue reading. Knowing this, there is not much suspense that can be portrayed as the Big Guy is foaled then begins to run. Really, really fast. The movie tells the story of Secretariat and his owner. The owner was Penny Chenery Tweedy and family. Diane Ladd plays the strong willed woman out to save her family finances and root the Big Guy to victory. She is excellent in the role. Along for the ride, so to speak, are John Malkovich as the trainer and funny hat wearer, and a group of fine character actors which include Scott Glenn, Fred Thompson and James Cromwell. Margo Martindale provides laughs and inspiration as the wise family secretary and horse namer. Secretariat was directed by Randall Wallace. He also helmed two fine films including "We Were Soldiers" (2002) and the first film I ever reviewed, the most excellent "Man in the Iron Mask" (1998). Nick Glennie-Smith provides a beautiful and evocative score. The horse race scenes are exciting and well filmed even if, for the most part, we know the results. Especially in the Triple Crown contests. In the Kentucky Derby he ran every quarter mile faster than the one preceding it and he was still accelerating when he crossed the finish line. Did I mention he ran really fast? The last of the three races, The Belmont Stakes, is an especially long and grueling contest which spells the end for most Triple Crown contenders. I remember watching this race live in 1973. Secretariat almost looked like he might lap the 4 other horses in the contest. That's how commanding his lead was. Disney has offered up good family fare. The personal financial issues sometimes get in the way of seeing the Big Guy run which is the core of the story. A story everyone, not just horsey film lovers, like me should see. A great story of a superior athlete. And he knew it. Watch and see. Rated 3.5 out of 4.0 lengths. Secretariat won by 31 lengths. Seabiscuit beware. Bamboo Harvester, who died in 1970, would have been proud if he had lived to see Secretariat run. And he would have spoke up about it. If you want to know how…..Google his name.
5 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Made with all the passion and realism of a "Mr. Ed" episode
gordonm8881 April 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This is a rare case of a Hollywood movie being far less exciting that the real events that comprise its storyline.

I saw each of Secretariat's triple crown races on TV when they happened. My wife is a former horse owner, and she was dieing to see this movie. And we both sat in front of the screen, stunned. To be fair, there was excellent acting by John Malkovich and good acting by Fred Thompson and the actor who plays jockey Ron Turcotte. But most of the other actors just stood around, looking embarrassed and uncertain of what to do with themselves as they recited clichéd lines. Most of the scenes involving Penny Chenery's family and professional problems had all the passion and realism of a "Mr. Ed" episode.

What happened? Well, the direction and screenplay/dialog of Secretariat are awful. Not just a normal sort of "awful." I mean historically, epicly awful. Some of the scenes in this movie are at the general level of "The Swarm" - one of the worst movies ever made.

First problem; Secretariat is not seen very often in this movie. His winning string of races as a two-year old that made him Horse of the Year are not shown- instead we hear a track announcer announcing the name of the winning horse "Secretariat! Secretariat!" over and over again. Hmmm, that must have helped with the movie budget.

Instead, we see many scenes with Penny's family. Penny has four children -an anti-war protester hippie daughter and three children that are not the hippie daughter. The hippie daughter looks and acts like a Brady Bunch daughter or a Hannah Montana character with absolutely no hint of drugs, sex, or dirty loose clothes. She and her hippie friends spray paint signs for protest rallies: the sign we can see says "Make Music,Not War"- ooh that's realistic. I guess "Make Love, Not War" was too edgy for the creative geniuses behind this historical epic.

I genuinely like Diane Lane but she is either miscast as the tough owner of Secretariat, or she received bad direction. She has no growl in her voice and very little iron in her demeanor. Her character makes a string of snap decisions each of which is portrayed as requiring an incredible leap of faith - and every decision is eventually revealed to have been absolutely correct and absolutely essential. For example, she makes one momentous decision by staring into Secretariat's eyes for about 10 seconds. Everyone of these scenes is acted and filmed in a way that comes across as unconvincing and contrived.

Whenever the script, over a four-year period, needs to have Penny interact with journalists, the same two actors playing reporters are always used -no matter whether the scene is in Virginia, Kentucky, NYC or upstate New York. I kept thinking of a grade school play where two kids are assigned the roles of "reporters" and keep exiting and entering the stage in different scenes.

The background music often detracts from the action, especially a totally jarring blast of black gospel music at the movies' climax. And African-Americans in the 1970s? They are depicted as characters out of Amos & Andy -like Buckwheat in Spanky & the Gang.

Many scenes appear to have been shot with only two cameras. In scenes with Penny's husband and brother, the actors look like they are nursing a hang-over as they deliver their lines and then stand around looking like they want to vomit.

And the plot takes significant liberties with the facts. In real life, Penny divorced her husband soon after Secretariat wins the triple crown. Too edgy for this script, I guess. And the plot centers on a fictionalized situation in which Penny struggles to sell "breeding shares" in Secretariat to literally 'save the farm" but in real life the breeding shares for Secretariat sold like hot-cakes and Penny played no role in selling them. Its a shame, because the movie fails to do justice to real-life events that were genuinely dramatic and moving - and then relies on fictionalized situations for its storyline.

If you enjoy Plan 9 from Outer Space and My Mother,the Car then I recommend this movie to you.
15 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed