"Gilligan's Island" The Secret of Gilligan's Island (TV Episode 1967) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
What a big goof that stone tablet was !
mick987g4 July 2021
Just thinking how the Professor says something like Oh no the tablet us how to get on the island not off it!

Well who ever wrote that didn't stope to think. If it shows ou how to get on the island who not reverse the process!

And as they say he could fix a radio but couldn't find a way to get off the island. GEEZ!
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Gilligan is all about time.
Ralphkram12 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Another Sherwood Schwartz produced series with a catchy theme song, It's About Time, serves as the basis for this entry. The series runs during the third season of GI before CBS cancels it after one season due to poor ratings. It is about a pair of astronauts who travel back in time to the prehistoric age and befriend cave dwellers. In a bid to save money, GI borrows the set, props, and wardrobe from the failed series and builds an episode around it. The episode is mainly interesting as a curiosity, with pretty good production design, a strange dream sequence, and hit-or-miss humor.

In the cold open, we have the trope of Gilligan discovering something of value. He stumbles upon a prehistoric tablet in one of the isle's 'unexplored' caves, which looks strangely identical to the all-purpose cave used every week. The tablet contains hieroglyphic markings. The Professor believes they show a way to get off the island, but the tablet is only a piece to a larger tablet, and the castaways need to collect all the other pieces to find the answer.

The first act then is a scavenger hunt where the group finds the pieces to their prehistoric puzzle in mostly uninspired ways. Nothing of interest happens, outside of Gilligan mistaking acid for soup and nearly giving himself permanent indigestion.

A fairly funny scene does happen. The castaways are short one piece; our lead just happens to be using it as a serving tray. The Professor doesn't make the connection right away even though it's right in front of his eyes. Once he does, Gilligan drops it, of course, and it crumbles to pieces.

But wait! The pieces are easily restored in the second act and the puzzle is completed. Based on the tablet's markings, Gilligan and the Skipper are tapped to make another raft trip to Hawaii.

With that plot point wrapped up, writer Bruce Howard has time for a random segue into the dream sequence. Gilligan starts obsessing over cave people and drifts off in the middle of his chatter. In his dream, he is an artist and unlikely leader of an idealist group who wants to explore the scary 'other side of the hill.' The Howells are his loin-clothed, long-haired chieftains who forbid independent thinking. The Professor, in a predictably good gag, is the inventor of the wheel. The others are in the same supporting roles they are in when our lead is awake and do much the same things.

Chief Howell imprisons Gilligan and the Skip for their idealism. They are freed in no time, however, by Ginger's funny and successful seduction attempt. Mrs. Howell clubs her hubby and drags him by the hair in a bit done on It's About Time. However, in the next scene, the group is all together on their way to the other side. They encounter a pretty good stop-motion dinosaur and flee.

Shortly after the dream ends, so does the castaways plan to flee the island. The Professor doesn't know hieroglyphics as well as he thinks he does and makes a rare Gilligan-sized error.

That's the way the tablet crumbles.

COCONOTES:

Writer Bruce Howard won an Emmy for his work on The Red Skelton Show. He later was a staff writer for The Dukes of Hazzard, another CBS series.

Minor plot hole: So Gilligan has been using a piece of the tablet 'for months' and has never once noticed the unusual markings?

Minor blooper: The restored pieces of the tablet clearly don't resemble the crumbled pieces.

In her long, dark wig, Mrs. Howell is a stand-in for Imogene Coca of It's About Time.

Ending scene is sweet and thoughtful.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The castaways as prehistoric cave people
kevinolzak19 June 2016
"The Secret of Gilligan's Island" opens in a cave where the Professor identifies a prehistoric tablet of hieroglyphics created by long extinct cave people. There's some fun with a pot of acid meant to clean up the tablet, as Gilligan's attempts to sample the 'soup' are doomed to fail. More pieces are found until the Professor is close to deciphering the message contained by the entire grouping. Gilligan dreams all the castaways are cave people, Mr. Howell the fearsome but still henpecked chief who refuses to allow any of his people to escape to freedom on other side of hill. Ginger know how to persuade him, though he objects to being called Chiefy Weefy: "Chiefy Weefy Wifey get mad!" A stop motion dinosaur caps the sequence, and pretty much the whole episode.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
ACTUALLY SHOULD HAVE BEEN THE LAST EPISODE!
tcchelsey7 January 2024
It another secret cave exploration --which are always fun -- this time where a stone tablet, dating back to prehistoric times is discovered! The tablet, according to the professor, contains hieroglyphics, and when pieced together with other loose tablets, may show a way off the island. Now that's a first.

The only catch here is that unless it leads to an underground tunnel to Hawaii, how the heck are the casataways going to cross the Pacific ocean??? You still need transportation! That said, this should have been the last episode because it all makes sense, in a goofy sort of way.

I agree with the last reviewer, this episode was an obvious promo for producer Sherwood Schwartz's newest sitcom, ITS ABOUT TIME, which was sort of a takeoff on Gilligan's island, but with kooky cave people instead. Bruce Howard wrote this campy episode, who at the time was also writing for RED SKELTON and THE BEATLES cartoon series.

Accordingly.... Gilligan has another imaginative dream sequence and the gang become the cave dwellers? Mr. Howell is naturally the overbearing chieftain whose word is the law! Apparently, the production crew borrowed the plastic and cardboard "rock sets" from the new series for this episode, however, the award goes to the costume department, particularly Ginger's revealing cave girl outfit. You know that had to be included in the package, right?

See to believe. 10 Stars.

Imaginative, outrageous stuff near the end of the series. SEASON 3 EPISODE 25 remastered CBS dvd box set.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
It's About Time ... to cross-promote
jivers0112 January 2014
This March '67 episode centers around an extended fantasy dream sequence with the castaways as prehistoric cave people. This recycles the sets, props, and dinosaur footage from Schwartz's other series, "It's About Time". This was either an attempt to cross-promote "Time" or simply save money by reusing stuff from an already doomed sitcom (that went off the air in April).

Either way, it's fun to see Ginger and Mary Ann in long dark wigs and animal-print outfits. Of course, Ginger looks pretty hot in her zebra-stripe fur and does one of her trademark seduction scenes. Mrs. Howell seems to be playing the feisty Imogene Coca role from "It's About Time".
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed