"Quincy M.E." Who's Who in Neverland (TV Episode 1976) Poster

(TV Series)

(1976)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Good follow up to the premiere episode
rayoflite2425 July 2015
Who's Who in Neverland opens with socialite Margo Bentley (Joanna Barnes) speaking on the phone with her agent about a thinly veiled tell-all book she is writing about her experiences with the Hollywood elite. She decides to secretly check into a motel for privacy in order to write additional chapters, and it is there that she is murdered. Through a series of blunders by the police, funeral home and Dr. Asten (John S. Ragin) of the coroner's office, the victim is mistakenly identified as a prostitute and her body is released and cremated. Quincy (Jack Klugman) suspects that everyone has drawn the wrong conclusion in this case and does not believe that she died of cirrhosis of the liver which leads him to investigate further and find a strange microorganism in her blood which cannot be explained.

This second episode of Quincy is another good one following the premiere and well worth watching. While we do see who the killer is in the beginning, we do not know specifically why he wanted to silence the victim or who else might be involved. This is another episode from which several scenes were used for the opening theme sequence which was eventually used in Season 2.

One thing I've found to be consistent throughout this series and immediately evident in these early episodes is that Lt. Monahan (Garry Walberg) could be the most incompetent, annoying and tactless character that has ever existed in a mystery series. Right from the beginning, he's a loudmouth with a one track mind that is on the wrong track 99.9% percent of the time. I realize that the character was written this way so he and Quincy would often go toe to toe which helped set up conflict, but does he have to be such an insufferable curmudgeon all of the time??
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The 44 minute edited for TV version...
poolandrews21 September 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: Who's Who in Neverland starts as Margo Bentley (Joanna Barnes) decides to take a break from the stresses & strains of writing a fictional account of her life & check into the cheap Sunset Motel under the name Barbara Miller for a while, unfortunately for her it's the last thing she ever does as she is murdered there soon afterwards. Lt. Monahan (Garry Walberg) of the LAPD decides she's a prostitute & that she died of alcohol poisoning, however LA county coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) has his suspicions & decides to investigate. He soon discovers that Margot's publisher Arthur Ellis has also recently died from apparent alcohol abuse & becomes convinced he has a double murder on his hands but Quincy finds it hard to convince the people that matter...

Episode 2 from season 1 this Quincy story was directed by Steven H. Stern & is a good solid murder mystery that set the tone for many that followed it. At this point I should say that Who's Who in Neverland was one of several 90 minute long Quincy feature films made for TV before it settled down into a 60 minute time slot for it's own series, now somewhere along the line this has been edited down to a 44 minute (minus commercials) version to presumably fit in with subsequent Quincy episodes during re-runs & maybe foreign sales as I can't think of another reason. Anyway, I will be basing my comments on the shorter 44 minute version. This being only the second ever Quincy episode the character's relationships are still raw & still being developed but even at this early stage you can see the humour between the character's, the fact that Dr. Asten is a pencil pusher while Quincy conversely stands up against bureaucracy at every opportunity, he makes impassioned speeches which would become a character trademark & his eye for detail & his meticulous attention to his work that would later uncover & solve all sorts of crimes is here to see from the very beginning. This starts out like a Columbo mystery as we know who the killer is straight away & it's just whether Quincy can use his medical knowhow & expertise to track them down & catch them. I'm not sure how this played as a 73 minute (minus commercials that was the original length) long episode but at 44 minutes it moves along at a nice pace, it seems to retain all the key plot elements & still makes sense so I really have no idea what ended up on the cutting room floor.

This one looks alright & contains several of the clips used in the iconic opening sequence used throughout the rest of the show's run. The acting is decent enough & Klugman looks like he was born to play the role of Quincy.

Who's Who in Neverland is a good solid early Quincy murder mystery, having said that I'm basing my comments on the edited version so bear that in mind. A must for fans of the show.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Wow...Astin is a real idiot in this one!
planktonrules2 March 2013
Sometimes on "Quincy" you had to feel sorry for Quincy's boss, Astin. However, in this one he really blows it and never really seems to realize what a HUGE blunder he's made. The show begins with a woman dying--and the medical examiner's office has no idea who she is. They ASSUME she's a prostitute who died from the effects of alcohol, but the work gets sloppy. When a local funeral home calls to say they know who the victim was and pick up the body, Astin signs off on the autopsy--even though Quincy isn't finished. They soon learn that the papers given to the funeral home were fake--and the body has been cremated! Oops! Clearly, it points to a cover-up--but WHO and WHY would they do this? And, when another body turns up on the East Coast, Quincy springs into action.

This second episode of "Quincy" is a very good one. Of course, the crime is VERY fanciful (something common on the show but not in real life) but Quincy, though pushy, comes off as very reasonable (something not always common on the show!). All in all, a fascinating episode--one that is well worth seeing.

By the way, the closing music in the early episodes was different--and the show was not yet a weekly series. Additionally, another reviewer said he saw a 44 minute version--this one I saw was on DVD and was the full 48 minute one.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An intriguing episode of Quincy...
AlsExGal27 January 2024
... especially after circling back to the beginning after watching the final and dismal season eight of this show.

A woman is seen talking to her publisher about a tell-all book she is writing about Hollywood celebrities. She says she feels unsafe in her home and that she is checking into the Sunset Motel for a few days to finish her book. You see a man listening in - Her house is obviously bugged.

Next we see the police investigating at the motel. The woman's body is wrapped in a towel - she was taking a shower - and an empty liquor bottle is near the body. There were only a couple of outfits in the closet, no ID. The police determine she is a probably a prostitute working out of the hotel. The initial blood and tissue samples from the autopsy point to liver cirrhosis as cause of death, and in Quincy's absence, a rushed Dr. Astin, Quincy's boss, signs off the death as being due to natural causes. The same man we saw listening in on the author's conversation shows up at a mortuary claiming to be the family's attorney and asks that the body be sent there and cremated.

Quincy was suspicious of the woman's death to begin with, but when he returns to the coroner's office the body is not only gone, but cremated! Starting with the woman having no ID and having just a few tissue and blood samples, Quincy works backwards to determine who the victim really is and the cause of death without a body.

This was only the second episode, but it establishes Quincy as clever and with an eye for detail whose hot temper could get the best of him, especially when dealing with people he considers incompetent or stonewalling bureaucrats.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Who's Who in Neverland
Prismark1018 July 2019
The second episode of Quincy. The dedicated and passionate pathologist need to dig his boss, Dr Asten out of trouble.

Socialite Margo Bentley was writing an expose of Hollywood lives. She checked into a low rent hotel to write more material. She ended up dead, it looks like liver poisoning through long term alcoholism.

The police think she was an unknown prostitute who drank herself to death. Dr Astin thinks the same and releases the body for cremation.

However Quincy is worried about Bentley's demeanour. Her all over tan, expertly done fingernails. The fact that someone claimed the body wanted it cremated should had rung alarm bells.

It later emerges that Bentley's publisher has died in the east coast. Again it seems of the long term effects of alcohol.

Quincy needs to get there fast and do an autopsy even if it means using subterfuge.

It certainly seems the case that Bentley found out stuff about some powerful people and they wanted to silence her even it it meant germ warfare.

The characters are being established in the early episodes. Some nice interplay between Sam and Quincy. Dr Asten is more like a bureaucrat and an incompetent pathologist. Lt Monahan seems out of his depth as a detective if he thinks a lone woman in a hotel must be a drunk prostitute.

There is a lot of humour and danger although the episode ended a little too neatly and glibly given the danger Quincy was in.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed