User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Tab Hunter deserves to be taken seriously
grahamclarke10 September 2006
When young Arthur Gelien agreed to having his name changed to Tab Hunter he effectively sealed any chance of ever being taken seriously as an actor. At the time he certainly had no reason to ask to be taken seriously as an actor. He was taken on by the studios for his golden boy looks which attracted a large teen audience, no matter what the quality of the film. For the studios he was simply bait, which for a number of years did the trick. When younger bait appeared in the form of Troy Donahue, Tab's time was up.

Looking over Tab Hunter's filmography there is scant reason to take him seriously as an actor. And yet, there was a time towards the end of the fifties, when Hunter really did aspire to be a serious actor. He was greatly frustrated by the studio's refusal to offer him decent roles, to the point where he bought out his contract for an exorbitant sum, just to attain his freedom. The fifties had been an amazing period for young male actors. Brando and Dean (in the wake of Montgomery Clift) had completely changed the perception of what screen acting could be for young male actors. Hunter desperately wanted to be like them.

It was not to be. After leaving the studios, he coasted on the celebrity of his name, through forgettable TV appearances, B grade European films and a career in dinner theater. Tab Hunter was not an exceptionally talented actor, but he did improve vastly from the incredibly amateur debut starring role in "Saturday Island". He responded extremely well to good directors but sadly very rarely enjoyed that privilege. Under Sidney Lumet he gave one of his best performances in "That Kind Of Woman" and years later an as yet unknown Curtis Hanson elicited a strong showing from him in "The Arousers". His best shot at being taken really seriously as an actor came when a young Arthur Penn chose him for the Playhouse 90 episode titled "Portrait of a Murderer". Being live television with no second takes, this was a huge challenge. All in all it's a challenge Tab Hunter met commendably. He may not be as riveting as a Brando or a Dean, or even a Paul Newman or a Ben Gazara, but he does turn in a strong performance and largely proves that he did have what it takes to be a fine actor. The fact that this never happened is a combination of factors beyond his control and the poor choices he made.

He is partnered beautifully by a young Geraldine Page. They share some truly touching moments together.

"Portrait of a Murderer" is a genuine curiosity item. While its satisfying to see Hunter doing his best, (although the problem is that he seems to be trying too hard), in retrospect it's a little sad to see how things panned out in his career.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Superb acting by Tab Hunter and cast
yonhope13 July 2018
This will seem slow to today's audiences. What makes this so great is it was live TV. No mistakes were edited out. Only two errors that I noticed but Tab and company fixed them quickly and moved on. In one scene a fire is supposed to start and be snuffed out quickly but it almost gets out of control. Tab puts in some quick thinking and fancy footwork and all goes well. In another scene one character calls another character by the wrong name. Again it is smoothly corrected and the play looks like it is something the cast worked on for years. Very impressive. Tab stretches from kind and handsome and soft hearted to bold and cruel and still believable. Tab probably could have handled any role given to him when he was young but the studios just wanted him to look good in the posters, which he did. This one brilliant drama shows us he was a really fine actor.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
I wonder how close this was to the real life Bashor...
planktonrules1 June 2020
This installment of "Playhouse 90" is a most unusual one in style and content. The story was taken from recent headlines and is a recounting of the life of Donald Bashor, a multiple murderer who was executed in 1957...the year before this show aired. The part of Bashor is played by Tab Hunter.

The story is unusual in that it begins with details of the case, the trial and execution. Then, the film goes back in time before his arrest and is an account of the man, his relationship with his fiancee and he odd and erratic behaviors.

I enjoyed the film and appreciated that it didn't exactly make the guy a saint nor sympathetic. I generally enjoyed Hunter's performance, but also wonder how close it was to the real Bashor...especially because a few times Hunter seemed to overact a bit when he was showing us what a tortured soul the man was. Still, a fascinating sort of film...truly unique and worth seeing.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed