"Perry Mason" The Case of the Sulky Girl (TV Episode 1957) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
The viewer has to be alert in this entertaining case
kfo949421 February 2013
This is one where it looks likes Perry's client is in dire straits. But with careful cross examination Perry is able to get to the truth of a murder even though all the evidence points to conviction.

The story starts off when a young woman, Fran Celane, is in a argument with her Uncle Edward Norton over his control of her trust-fund. Uncle Edward refuses to release the fund's money to Fran until she turns 25 years of age. And being a young woman in love she dislikes her Uncle.

But what the Uncle does not know is that Fran has already got married to a young man named Ron Gleason. And when Ron goes over to talk with Uncle Edward, he is seen by Edward's secretary, Donald Graves, inside Edward's room. When he goes back to the room, Edward is dead. Ron Gleason is accused of murder and Perry will defend him in court.

But there is more to this little homicide than meets the eye. The viewer has to be alert as Perry examines the testimony of each witness and finally gets a break in the case. When the pressure gets too great for one person, he cracks and tells the entire story. But not until we as the viewer have been entertained to the fullest.

Raymond Burr is excellent in this episode as he seems more into the character than usual. Ray Collins does his regular nice performance when he is shooting rubber-bands at a picture of Mason. A Good watch for all.

Note- Most TV station now cut out a nice part of the show. The part cut is when Hamilton Burger, in a fedora hat, and Lt Tragg at at Edward's house recreating the crime scene. A good scene that was cut but still seen in the DVD collection.
42 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Ah, impetuous youth
Paularoc13 April 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Fran Celane's father left her a substantial trust fund. However, fearing she was a too immature young woman to handle such a large fortune, he made her uncle the trustee of the fund until she turned 25. The uncle is a controlling and rather nasty man and refuses Fran any access to the fund before her 25th birthday which is 18 months away. She goes to Mason asking him to break the trust age requirement. Upon investigating, Mason quickly discovers Fran is married and is expecting a baby. When the uncle is found murdered, Fran's husband is arrested for the murder. Mason's unraveling of the crime is really a nifty bit of detective work - the culprit was clever but not clever enough. As often happens in the early episodes, Lt. Tragg gets some of the best lines. Tragg tells Drake that he may be called as a witness for the prosecution, a possibility that understandably upsets Paul. Tragg then tells Paul "If I were you I'd get me some good legal advice." And then with an impish grin he adds "Would you like me to recommend a good lawyer?" There are a couple of interesting things about this episode. One is when Mason and Drake meet in Drake's office. There prominently displayed on Drake's desk is a framed Dick Tracy comic strip panel. Wonder what the story behind that is. Also, this is the first of 17 episodes in which Connie Cezon appears as Mason's reception, Gertie. Lillian Bronson does a nice job playing the housekeeper who raised Fran. Bronson later frequently appeared as a judge in the series. Another solid episode.
17 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Free from trust tyranny
bkoganbing26 August 2019
A very spirited and demanding Olive Sturgess bursts in on Perry Mason and wants his services. She's 23 and has to wait until 25 to get her considerable fortune held in trust by her tyrannical uncle. The uncle Raymond Greenleaf is an old tyrant, but she is a handful.

She wants to move out and start living with Brian Hutton whom she was secretly married to.

But Greenleaf who by his nature would have lots of enemies gets murdered and Hutton happened to sneak on the premises. He becomes Raymond Burr's client.

I have to say that I had this half figured out from the beginning. Only half mind you.

You'll like what Sturgess does in her performance here. And William Hopper nearly becomes a prosecution witness.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Speculation, your honor
darbski3 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** I liked this episode, but a couple of things make me think. One is the reason why the uncle was so mean to his niece; what's the point? Also, did she forget the rules of her inheritance? This is one of several shows where a young girl is "in love" and just can't possibly wait any longer for a guardian (or future dead guy's), permission to move forward with her life.

Later, Hamilton and Tragg were staging the experiment to find out if Graves could I.D. the person silhouetted behind the drawn shade. This is ridiculous. The whole thing would have been thrown out of court for being inconclusive. As for the "Voice Experiment" that Perry had Graves unwillingly participate in; it was equally unproductive. Any good opposing lawyer could cast doubt on either result. Perry, however, pressured Graves into admitting (on the stand, under oath), that he had participated in the murder as an accessory.

Crinston neither said or agreed to being called a murderer; he just wiped his face with his hand. For purposes of the episode, however, enough doubt had been cast on the prosecution's case to call for a dismissal for lack of real evidence. If he later denied what Graves had said - and with an attorney's advice, who wouldn't? - Graves would probably have been the most likely suspect. The protective old gal was of no real use with her "God is on my side" baloney, and inconveniently being in the pantry for a cup of tea when crucial observation was important.

When Burger and Tragg were doing their shade experiment, Hamilton drove off in a tacky looking Ford Fairlane with fender skirts (try changing a flat with them on), while Paul had a sweet '57 T-Bird. After the situation was well in hand, they are meeting in Gleason's studio. Gleason is doing what looks like a charcoal sketch of Della. Why the result wasn't shown is another mystery. Barbara Hale had the looks that artists loved (the rest of us, too). She had been a model before in her life, and she would have been a perfect subject. I'm reviewing this off METV, I'll probably pull it out of my collection, and watch the whole episode again, to be sure. Right now, though, I like where it sits.
14 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
good with one confusing scene
Castrily23 May 2020
When the judge arrives at the house at 11:00 p.m., the background scenes are all in broad daylight, from the time he arrives through the exit ride in the car with the secretary Graves. Next scene, Perry in his office, several moments later at midnight, and it's dark out, as the whole scene should have been. I wish they would stay true to surrounding circumstances. Frustrating. And yes, I'm nitpicking.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Perry still a work in progress in Episode 5 of season 1
ebertip3 October 2020
Perry in this seaon one episode shows signs of self-doubt, at one point banging a chair and at another displaying concern to Paul. Also, he gives dictation to a sleeping Della. Definitely not the more polished in control Perry of later years. As to his work, he states litigator, and he takes this case as a spendthrift trust fund litigation for the niece. In later episodes, there are references to Perry litigating non-murder cases, including a patent case. Here, the murder case intervenes, and we are not sure how the trust case ends, tho with the uncle dead, may be favorably. Name dropping occurs with a brief flash of a Walter Winchell column. There is the Dick Tracey reference. As to the murder, one is unsure of how on-top Perry is. One key is the phone call to the police. Another key is that Perry defends innocent clients and anything that directly contradicts this premise is a red flag, which gets you half-way. A curious touch is that a judge is a key witness, on the basis of his audio skills.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Few Things About This Episode
CherCee19 October 2021
1. William Schallert's character was not Uncle Edward's butler as a previous poster wrote, he was his secretary.

2. Perry littered in the courthouse! He was talking with Paul. They were frustrated, and Perry just flicked his burning cigarette away.

3. The clock on Paul's desk is very cool!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Case of the Sulky Girl
Prismark1028 February 2021
Fran Celane is the sulky girl. She is upset at her controlling uncle Edward Norton who deals with her trust fund until she is 25 years old.

Until then Fran has to put up with her uncle telling her what to do. This includes not approving her choice of man to marry until she is 25.

Not wanting to wait for a few more years. Fran goes to see Perry Mason.

It does not take Perry long to find out that Fran has already secretly got married to an artist called Ron.

Pretty soon Ron is arrested for murdering uncle Edward. There is a witness who claims he saw Ron inside the house with Edward.

It looks like a tough case for Perry Mason. Worse Paul Drake might be called in as a prosecution witness.

It takes Perry a lot of guile, cunning and a witness to panic and confess everything.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The saulky girl
bdosher-5665213 October 2020
This is actually a pretty good story, the 1957 shows seem to be figuring out the interaction between the characters in the show, by the winter of 1958 they seem to have this all together. The story's from from the start to the early 60s seem to be best, somewhere in the mid 60s they stopped using a novel for a story, and started using ideas from several and putting them together plus the last couple years, I read the director who was in charge didn't do great job, and it shows Watch this one closely, the story moves along well.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
There was nothing that I could have done. Whatever was going to happen was in more divine hands then mine.
sol12189 June 2013
Warning: Spoilers
***SPOILERS**** It's when spoiled rambunctious and out of control youth Fran Celane's', Olive Sturgess, nasty and greedy uncle Edward Norton, no not that guy who works for the NYC Department of Sewers, played by Raymond Greenleaf gets his skull bashed in with an ashtray that Fran's boyfriend, who turned out to be secretly married to her, Rod Gleason, no relations to the "Great One" himself as far as I could tell, is arrested for Uncle Ed's murder. Rod was seen snooping around the house by housemaid Clara Mayfield, Lillian Bronson, just before Uncle Ed got his brains bashed in who reluctantly, in her having no use for Uncle Ed herself, testified to that in court. But as we and Perry Mason, Raymond Burr, Rod's attorney soon found out there was a lot more to Uncle Ed's murder then what meets both the eye as well as ear!

It was Uncle Ed himself who called the police just moments before he was murdered saying that his niece Fran was out to get or kill him. As it later turned out it wasn't Fran who did the guy in but, in him being the #1 suspect in Uncle Ed's murder, it was her husband that out of work T-shirt clad and beatnik-like artist Rod Gleason who was arrested for Uncel Ed's murder!

***MAJOR SPOILER***It was in fact the butler Donald Graves, William Schallert, who claimed that he in fact saw, Uncle Ed's murder, the whole thing just as it happened live and in living color. But as Perry later proved that Graves was really full of it and not only that he not Uncle Ed was the one who screamed bloody murder when Uncle Ed got it. What really came out in the wash or cross-examination is what were the true reasons behind Uncle Ed's murder and It had really nothing to do with his niece Fran and her husband Rod Gleason. It had to do with money that was being embezzled from Uncle Ed's stock market portfolios by someone dear and near to him. About to call the police Uncle Ed got brained by his attacker who had Rod, who at he time was in the kitchen looking for a free meal,take the rap for it!

***MORE MAJOR SPOILERS****As for the wimpy and scared of his own shadow butler of the house Donald Graves he got himself sucked into the crime in him being promised of getting a piece of the action or money from Uncle Ed's stock portfolios by looking the other way and imitating Uncle Ed's voice after Uncle Ed was already dead! It was when Perry forced Graves to do the same thing, using his real voice, that in the end tripped him up. And at the same time had Graves, not wanting to be the fall guy in a crime that the didn't commit, finger Uncle Ed's murderer!
7 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
That Voice
Hitchcoc6 November 2021
This was a garden variety Mason show. There were some things that bothered me. While the crime was interesting, I found the young woman to be every bit as obnoxious as she was thought to be. Unfortunately, I was able to recognize the voice in question, so it was easy to figure it out for the most part. Once again, Tragg overstepped his knowledge and made threats. Simple plotting to say the least. One thing. There was certainly a lot of smoking in these episodes.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Burr was not a great actor
pmike-1131221 June 2022
Boy, these early episodes (in particular) really show what a mediocre actor Burr was. Such over-acting!

But, I guess it's not ALL his fault - the writing and directing did him no favors. "Mason's" courtroom behavior would never be allowed before a real judge, even way back then.
2 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed