"Perry Mason" The Case of the Melancholy Marksman (TV Episode 1962) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Mason's Client Visits a Zone
DKosty1237 December 2010
Warning: Spoilers
William Schallert (Patty Duke's Dad) & Jesse White (The Maytag Repairman) head a large guest cast for this episode. Written by Robb White (no relation to Jesse) who wrote the House on Haunted Hill, this episode is a little different than many.

Mason's client steals a rifle & tries to shoot his estranged wife who seems to have something on everybody including him & his family. He doesn't go through with it at but the episode seems to be borrowing background music from Rod Sterling's Twilight Zone making the episode feel different as it goes along.

Eventually his wife is shot but it is not as straight forward as it appears as like Haunted Hill, the murder happens during a loud thunder storm. The murder bullet is damaged upon hitting a fireplace making ballistics an impossible task.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
One of Those Deals
darbski30 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** Yeah, you just can't feel sorry for Perry's client. As much as Perry's evidence of Radioactive Iodine (I-131), He comes across as a self pitying fool. The business with the rifle, however, is just too much. Where was the ballistics on the rifle at really? A scoped-up hunting rifle like that, in what was a medium caliber would have enough energy to blow right through the deceased (not that anyone would miss the vulture). The I-131 would have led him into brain damage and basic stupidity, but it would have damaged his mental capabilities across the board, not just in a select area. How could Irene have gotten so much of it, and how would she have known how to use it? Vitamins? Please.

Where WAS the murder gun? Now, as usual there is a real tight timeline, and, well, like I said, it's just too much. Too MANY things that are coincidental. See, that's one problem that all of us loyal fans have is the fact that NO good investigator believes in any more than ONE coincident event. The killer probably would get manslaughter.

I wonder if beautiful Barbara was feeling well in this production. She looked uncomfortable at the defense table, and at one point, bowed her head forward, and rested in her hands.

Not one of the best, in spite of the capable acting talent.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
There's your missing powder residue, Mr. Burger
XweAponX30 August 2020
...every single bit of it.

You have to realize the level of manipulation that this woman had been involved with.

Of course she is not going to give her husband "the vitamins" at home, he would not have taken them. The only way to get them into Ted Chase's digestive system would be to have the manipulated bartender (Jesse White of "Harvey") slip Ted a Radiation-Mickey.

There are also other things to consider, a person in a thunderstorm would not necessarily close the windows, especially if it were humid outside like it would be during any thunderstorm in Southern California. I sometimes keep my windows open during thunderstorms. There was also an argument about some glass enclosing a balcony, but that would be no issue considering the angle of the proposed sniper-scope use.

Everybody knew this woman was bad and everybody hated her guts, even the children with her ill. My god what a horrible person, the rottenest person of any Perry Mason episode, ever.

This episode includes Ann Rutherford, far away from the Oregon Trail and Andy Hardy. And there was kind of a Shelley Winters clone, but it was actually an actress name Jeff Donnell. And of course William Schallert, far away from "deep space station K-7", "Deep Space 9", and any Quadro-triticale or Tribbles or Bajoran musical gadgets.

Actually I consider this one of the most clever Perry Mason episodes of all time, because you really don't know what had happened until the very last minute, and for once we didn't have a screaming or crying confession in the witness booth. sometimes those are too much. But, this was the second time this kind of reveal had been used in a Perry Mason episode, where an injury was revealed like this. The first time was in S02E15, "TCOT Foot-loose Doll" and it is Barton McLane from treasure of the Sierra Madre who was Perry's victim that time.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
OFFBEAT, CAMPY PERRY MASON EPISODE
tcchelsey19 May 2023
Having grown up on PERRY MASON who, by this time, is now a family friend (if not long lost relative), the episodes are addictive, even in black and white, which actually gives it a noirish feel every now and then. The great Robb White, master of the macabre, is the author. White is best known for teaming with William Castle for such hits as THE HOUSE ON HAUNTED HILL. By the way.... listen to the ominous music in the background, and you know White was pulling the sheet music too! This is a very, very entertaining whodunit. Popular character actor Paul Richards plays a desperate man who wants to kill his nasty wife (well played by Mari Blanchard), BUT he just can't do it. Good for him, bad for him. He tosses the rifle and it gets into somebody else's hands --Do the math. This episode, interestingly, gets into forensics in order to clear Perry's client and expose the guilty party, which is a clever change of pace. Also, look at the marvelous supporting cast, including Jeff Donnell (as Sylvia) and Ann Rutherford playing Ellen. Comedian Jesse White makes an appearance as Cecil. One goof though; according to notes the ballistics technician is wearing glasses with no glass!! OMG. Watch carefully. Still 10 Stars. Recommended for us armchair lawyers. SEASON 5 EPISODE 24 CBS dvd box set.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Weird
CherCee20 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
One thing I found strange about this episode was that the dead woman had given her husband's bartender the hubby's (radioactive!) vitamins because he wouldn't take them at home *and he gave them to him*?! Who would give a customer some pills that someone else gave him?!
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Hard to feel good for anyone in this episode
kfo949422 August 2012
If you are looking for a feel-good show then pass on this episode. This involves a relationship that is uncomfortable even to the viewer.

It begins when a husband, Ted Chase, steals a rifle from a sporting goods store because he had thoughts of killing his wife. His wife, Irene Chase, is a vamp that seems to have a relationship with every other man in the cast.

As much as we want to feel remorse for the situation that Ted Chase is living- it turns sour when he has his wife in the cross-hairs of the rifle for killing. Even though Mr Chase does not pull the trigger, it will be hard to feel sorry for him as the show continues.

After Mr Chase cannot kill his wife, he throws the rifle down am air vent. Later on the radio, we learn that Irene Chase had been killed and the police is looking for Ted Chase.

Perry will have his hands full as he tries to defend an not-so-innocent man on charges of murder. But through the testimony of witnesses, it becomes apparent that someone wanted Ted Chase in serious trouble.

This is a crowded cast that at times is difficult to follow. Much time is seemed spent on stocks, stock bonds and stock certificates - so I was trying to keep those separate as we progress to the court hearing. But by the end of the show, anything with stocks was just a red herring.

Perhaps after many really good shows, this mystery seemed almost dull. But there is good courtroom activity that will please the most novice Mason fan and lead the case to an acceptable ending.
14 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Much Ado
Squashpants15 March 2011
Warning: Spoilers
There is a lot made of the conjecture by Perry that the bullet that killed the wife had to have come from inside the high-rise apartment.

And the prosecution based its case against Perry's defendant on the assumption that he had killed his wife with a rifle from the top of a building adjacent to the high-rise.

As far as I could tell, there was a glass balcony door and floor-length picture windows on the exposed side of the apartment, and because a storm was in progress, surely these would all be closed.

A bullet coming from outside the apartment would have had to pass through one of those glassed-in apertures, and would have either shattered it or left a hole in it.

Yet, it seems the episode direction went to a lot of trouble to not film that side of the apartment after the moment in which the wife was discovered dead.

WTF?
6 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Forensics Challenged
bkoganbing11 December 2012
Paul Richards is the client of Raymond Burr in this Perry Mason episode in which he plays a poor schnook of a socialite whose two timing scheming wife is taking away his company and whatever assets with her machinations. Of course with California being a community property state she'll do it anyway in a divorce. A couple of times Richards is shown on a rooftop ready to do her in with a sniper's rifle, but can't quite pull the trigger.

Someone does it to Mari Blanchard whom the writers make to be almost a caricature of a wicked Barbara Stanwyck part. Perhaps Stanwyck was the only actress who could have pulled off this particular wicked woman. There are sure any number of alternate theories and suspects for this woman.

What blows up William Talman's case is forensics. Burr challenges them quite successfully and in doing so unmasks the real killer on the stand.

Not the best of Mason episodes, but all right.
8 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
When the left hand doesn't quite know what the right hand is doing
kapelusznik182 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
****SPOILERS**** Mindless "Perry Mason", Raymond Burr, episode that boils down to not just who shot the scheming Irene Chase, Mari Blanchard,but just how close he was when he shot her. It's Irene's long suffering husband the almost brain dead-due to radioactive poisoning-husband Ted Chase, Paul Richards, who's charged in her murder who up until then tried a number of times to plug or shoot Irene but chickened out at the very last moment. As usual Perry plays it cool in finding the actual killer with a little arm twisting not cross-examination that has him not only admit his crime but also cry uncle. That all without the prosecutor in the case Hamilton "Ham" Burger, William Talman, not once raising an objection to Perry's brutal tactics!

Difficult to follow and much harder to explain "Perry Mason" episode involving the usual murder as well as blackmail and suicide added in that only Perry, with the help of the script writers, can navigate us through. As for Perry's client he got himself into a pickle when he married Irene after his 1st wife's sudden death not for a moment realizing that Irene or someone close to her may have had something to do with It! Who provided herself with an air-tight alibi in being some 200 miles away when the murder was committed.

****SPOILERS**** As it turned out this all resulted in a falling out, in getting their hands on the $100,000.00 in stock options in Ted's name, between Irene and her partner in crime that blew the entire case wide open. What sealed the deal for Perry was the strongest evidence in his client-Ted Chase-favor that totally exonerated Ted in Irene's murder. In just how far he was from her when he supposedly pulled the trigger from at least 30 feet away compared to the short distance within six to ten inches distance of the person who shot her!
3 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed