"Gunsmoke" Trip West (TV Episode 1964) Poster

(TV Series)

(1964)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Another Existential Crisis
wdavidreynolds7 December 2020
Elwood James Hardacre is another of the Season 9 men facing some existential dilemma (see also: "Caleb" and "The Promoter.") In this case, Hardacre visits a traveling charlatan selling a useless elixir. This fraudulent "doctor" informs Hardacre that he only has about three months to live due to an illness he calls "calcification of the liver." Of course, the only remedy for the affliction is to take the elixir several times per day. Unfortunately, the North Fork sheriff runs the phony medicine man out of town, and Hardacre's only bottle of elixir is broken.

In the town of North Fork where he lives, Hardacre has surrounded himself with people who bully him. The woman that runs the boarding house where he lives chastises him constantly for one thing or another. His supervisor at the bank where he works -- a cantankerous Scrooge-like man named Arbuckle (his subordinates call him "Warthog") -- despises him and complains about his work effort, or lack thereof. Even the children in the town speak abusively toward Hardacre.

Upon learning of his terminal illness, Hardacre decides he will withdraw all of his money from the bank and go to California. When he boards the stagecoach, he sees a woman named Annie Gilroy who he had met at a saloon in North Fork. Annie was kind to Hardacre, and the man is smitten with her.

Annie is on her way to Dodge City because she wants to get away from an abusive relationship with a tyrant named Meade Agate. She is hoping to get a job working for Miss Kitty at the Long Branch Saloon.

On the trip to Dodge, Hardacre and Annie become better acquainted. Hardacre decides he will stop in Dodge for a few days, primarily thanks to Annie's presence there.

In Dodge, Hardacre is a much different man than he was in North Fork. He is friendly and outgoing. People like him, although as a stranger in town, people are curious about him.

Problems arise when Agate follows Annie to Dodge. Agate is extremely jealous, but his interest in Miss Gilroy is about possession and control, not love. Hardacre wants to protect Annie from Agate, and since he thinks he has nothing to lose, he is more bold than he might be otherwise.

Herbert Anderson, who had played Henry Mitchell in the series Dennis the Menace just prior to appearing in this episode, fills the role of Hardacre well. It is interesting how he does not really begin to live until he thinks he has nothing to lose. This is Anderson's only appearance in a Gunsmoke episode.

Sharon Farrell is her usual lovely self in the part of Annie. This is her last appearance on Gunsmoke. Her previous two appearances had occurred late in Season 8's excellent "With A Smile" and earlier in Season 9's "Quint's Trail."

H.M. Wyant often played heavies, as he does here in the Meade Agate role. It is nice to see Percy Helton in the role of Arbuckle. Helton had a long career in television and films from the mid 1940s well into the 1970s.

Although there is a bit of gunplay in this story, it is uncharacteristically gentle by typical Gunsmoke standards. This script was written by John Dunkel, who contributed a number of stories, some of them mild in nature, to both the radio and television versions of Gunsmoke. One can only imagine how this story would have received different treatment if it had been written by John Meston.
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A+ to Herbert Anderson!
shannonlee195611 December 2020
I will spare you the episode summery and just give my thoughts on it. This is a lighter episode and refreshingly so! In spite of one reviewer's opinion I was delighted to see the terribly underrated actor Herbert Anderson in such a large role since Dennis the Menace.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A man finds himself
LukeCoolHand8 December 2020
To me this was a good episode. Not the best but far from the worst. It was a little different from the usual fare. Herbert Anderson was a perfect choice to play the part of the forlorn milque toast, Elwood. I guess I sort of identified with him and that's why I liked the episode. I have found out something about Gunsmoke. I seem to enjoy some episodes on 2nd viewing more than the 1st, as I did with this one. The ending was very touching when a man finally finds himself.
13 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Sweet story, nicely told
lrrap11 November 2022
Another "little man/loser comes to Dodge to improve his life" plot that provides a substantial role for the main guest star, in this case Herbert Anderson, who does a great job---especially since he resists the temptation to overdo the "sad-sack" quality that's an essential part of his character (director Harris was helpful in this regard, I'm sure).

A touching message in the final scenes, well written, acted, and directed.

I would very much like to end my comments here, because I don't have anything else to say that would warrant the space..but IMDB now REQUIRES that "reviews" must be of a certain length, which I think is odd...especially since, IMO, so much of the space taken up by viewer comments is not especially insightful. Take, for instance, the insistence on commentators to write detailed plot synopses, reciting nearly the entire plot, much like a book report.

For readers who haven't seen the show, a recitation of the plot in detail kinda' defeats the fun of watching it and experiencing the drama for themselves; why sit through the whole thing when you know practically every detail of the plot in advance? On the other hand, for viewers who've already watched the episode, why re-live it in written form here?

Makes no sense.

Again, just my opinion. LR.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Story was lacking in action but was a nice watch
kfo949411 January 2013
This story actually begins in North Fork where a cowardly bank employee named Elwood Hardarce is being medically examined by a traveling medical con-artist named Professor Ramsey. Ramsey is a man that sells this useless elixir that he tells is a cure all for every ailment. Ramsey has already been ran out of Dodge by Marshal Dillon and set up shop in North Fork. Professor Ramsey tells Elwood that he has calcification of the liver and only has three weeks to live. That is of course, unless he buys 12 bottles of his elixir. Elwood only has the money to buy one bottle but will get the money the next day for the others.

The next morning Ramsey has been told to leave by the Sheriff and Elwood is in distress about his life. At the local saloon he takes his first ever whiskey drink and is smitten by a girl named Annie Gilroy. However Annie is trying to escape from a boyfriend named Meade Agate who is a known rough in the area. Elwood with only weeks to live wants to see California so he quits his job takes out all his money and rides to Dodge by coach. Just so happens Annie is on the same stagecoach trying to flee Agate.

When they get to Dodge, Annie gets a job at the Long Branch and Elwood walks around town taking in all the sights and spending his money. That is until Agate comes to Dodge.

Meade Agate is after Annie and will leave dodge without her. Annie tells Elwood to leave her alone and leave town for his safety but all that does is cause Elwood to think about his months to live. He confronts Agate and tells him to leave town. Agate tells Elwood he better get a gun. With Elwood believing his time on earth is short, he takes a brave face to the threat.

A sweet script that was a pleasure to watch. Even though the show was entertaining, it did not have the flare that the previous episodes have possessed. Perhaps it was the mild manner that this show was taking- but it felt dragged out till reaching the outcome. With that said- it had a nice story with good actors which produced a good watch for viewers.
13 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Dennis The Menace's Dad Escapes
cduffynyc20 February 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Kind of anyway! A nice enough episode but I quickly grew weary of Elwood and his naïveté - and not sure if others had this problem but I simply couldn't get his Dennis the Menace character out of my head. Perhaps they should have recruited Jay North to be a part of the opening where even kids abused poor Elwood. (I think I'll watch the opening again just to make sure he isn't in it. Anyway, he's a tough guy to feel too sorry for (believing an Elixer hawker that he's on death row - even if he is the General from I Dream of Jeannie), thinking a gal so out of his league is gonna go to California with him; and harassing a gun slinger (who more likely should have just beat him to a pulp for calling him out on the street). Quick correction to one subscriber - the gal never went back to her ex boss out of love to him, it was to try and save Elwood. Also noticed how often when a guest star takes over an episode, how little Festus gets in air time....in this one, more Festus please.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Beware the world's nicest man
gary-6465928 May 2019
This episode was one of a spate of stories on "Gunsmoke" centred around an everyman dissatisfied with his life who transforms his personality literally overnight after a lifetime of failure in the Kansas outback and takes off for greener pastures (Dodge City) for a new life as a wannabe hero. And this was the least believable of them. Herbert Anderson is an actor so bland and lacking in interest it is hard to quantify. For years he was the inoffensive, put-upon dad of Dennis the Menace in the early sixties and was barely a face popping elsewhere, never a name. When I watched this 1964 entry in Gunsmoke this morning I watched for his name in the closing credits and didn't recognise it when I saw it -- and I am an incorrigible name collector from classic tv. The partially redeeming feature of his performance is he portrays perfectly (but with the suspicion it comes naturally) the nightmare of all male introverts going through puberty who fear they are destined to be ignored by women and only remembered if at all as a nuisance who doesn't get it. And this one comes to fancy himself as a mate of ultra-sexy Sharon Farrell, though a generation older and looking it (even with his milksop characterless face and manner). It is no surprise, faced by this really annoying nice-but-icky man, she opts to go back to brutal boyfriend H. M. Wynant whom she was originally trying to escape, and learning the harsh lesson "Be careful what you wish for."
3 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed