"Gunsmoke" The Boy and the Sinner (TV Episode 1973) Poster

(TV Series)

(1973)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Heartwarming, Didactic Episode.
atomicis23 August 2021
If my hero Festus had put in an appearance I'd have probably rated it a ten. But rest assured my review is a REVIEW and not a plot summary, which the reviewer "kfo9494" seems to confuse.

The drunken Irishman (acceptable stereotype here) is learnt some thangs by the wholesome young lad, and we're all the better for it. I didn't find it "boring", but I can understand how some less-deep thinkers would. I really enjoyed this episode. The absence of the stars is remarkable, as they were at the height of their TV glory, and I can respect that!
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Man and a Boy Discover Hope and Purpose through Friendship
wdavidreynolds1 October 2021
Noah Beal is a man who spends most of his time either drinking or attempting to find some money to buy a drink. He mostly hangs around the streets of Dodge City carrying packages for people for small sums.

A shady businessman named Jess Bradman is looking to buy land from farmers around Dodge City, but he wants to drive the price down. His henchmen convince Beal to claim some land near Dodge that contains a water source. By damming the water source, the value of the surrounding farms can be reduced. They promise to pay Beal for the land, and they give him several cases of whiskey to keep him drunk.

Things do not go as Bradman plans, however. Beal meets a young boy named Colby Eaton. Colby lives with his father, Hugh, on a farm adjacent to the property Beal has claimed.

Actor Ron Moody makes his only Gunsmoke appearance as the Noah Beal character. Moody was most famous for his role as the character Fagin in the Broadway play and 1968 film Oliver! He was nominated for a Best Actor Oscar for the film. There is a lot of Fagin to be found in the Noah Beal character here.

Vincent Van Patten had previously appeared in the Season 18 "Bohannon" episode. He portrays Colby Eaton in this story, which is his only additional Gunsmoke role. Moody and Van Patten are great together.

Venerable character actor Ken Lynch plays the part of Jess Bradman. Anyone that watched television in the 1960s and 1970s is likely to recognize Lynch. He often played authority figures or villains in television dramas, but he did a surprising number of comedies, too. This performance is the last of twelve he did for Gunsmoke.

Warren Vanders also makes the last of twelve appearances in a Gunsmoke episode with this installment. He usually played villains, and he portrays one of Bradman's thugs in this story. Gunsmoke veteran Read Morgan plays the other tough guy in one of his ten Gunsmoke roles.

Actor John Crawford is another familiar face that appears in this story. Here he plays Hugh Eaton, Colby's father. Crawford has parts in fourteen episodes of the series. Hal Baylor and Florida Friebus each appear briefly. Victor Izay appears once again as Bull, the owner of the Bull's Head Saloon.

There is a definite heartwarming element to this story. Colby's persistent encouragement helps Beal redirect his life from living moment-to-moment for the next drink to a sober life with a meaningful relationship. Bradman intends to use Beal for his nefarious purposes, but it leads to Beal finding a reason for living. (Beal even acknowledges this fact to Matt Dillon.)

In Beal, Colby finds someone that shows him more compassion and respect than his own dour, dismissive father. Colby's father treats his son as an untrustworthy subordinate when there appears to be little reason to do so. Beal, on the other hand, considers Colby his "partner."

This is the fourth episode broadcast in Season 19, and there has yet to be an installment that prominently features any of the series regulars other than the Matt Dillon character. Such episodes are common, but to have this many shown sequentially is unusual. This episode is set in Dodge City, but there is otherwise nothing about it to make it unique to the series. Even the Matt Dillon character appears in only a few brief scenes.

Although the pacing of the episode is slower than some others, there is never a sense of merely filling time. The development of the relationship between Colby and Beal necessitates the measured approach.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Even with Ron Moody, this episode got boring quick..
kfo94949 August 2012
Warning: Spoilers
In another episode that features none of the regular cast members, we get a story that had potential but never lived up to expectations. Even with the great actor Ron Moody, the script and story could not be saved for almost a leftover thought from other 'Gunsmoke' episodes.

Ron Moody plays a drunk that carries packages for small change in order to get his next drink. Some roughs, working for a wealthy landowner, hires the drunk to squat on some vacant farm-land property so that the landowner can claim the property and then start buying other farmers property in the area.

When the drunk, Noah Beal (Ron Moody) gets to the property there is a young boy living in the area they will help Noah do something that he has never done- have self-respect for himself. The young boy played by Vince Van Patton (who looks more like the Dutch boy on cans of paint) helps Noah to start farming the land and begin a life away from booze.

But it may be short lived as the roughs come calling on Noah wanting the property. And all that Noah has worked for may be falling apart.

This episode might have worked well if there had been some other minor plot or side interest. However the writers chose to stick to a plot that seemed to be written for as thirty minute show and stretch it out for an hour. The viewers loses interest and any entertainment value the show when Noah has a five minute oral communication with the boy about worms. And that happens in the first fifteen minutes of the show.

Without any of the main characters, this show seem foreign to the viewer. This is the third episode I have seen from the 19 season, and yet to have seen a good one.
5 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Boring!
daveiulee1 October 2021
Season 19 3rd bad episode in a row. Where is the regular cast? Bad acting and a story that makes zero sense.
2 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed