I'd guess that the commentators here who criticize the acting of the guest stars as overdone and unrealistic are young...TOO young to have perspective on real people of the past and what they were like.
I say this because the Peaveys ring true, so much so that I was really intrigued by their scene together in the cabin. My grandparents and other people who were born in the late 19th-century spoke and related to each other VERY much like the Peaveys do; not quite that harsh, thankfully, but I clearly remember older folks from that same generation and social standing behaving in a similar way. Florenz Ames and Ann O'Neal TOTALLY capture those characteristics in a very authentic way....since both were OF THAT SAME GENERATION.
So listen up, youngsters: what may seem overblown and unrealistic to you may, in fact, be exactly the opposite, the type of reality that the actors, writers, and director captured precisely for the viewing audience of the day (which included my grandparents).
Thus, a TV film like this serves as a "window" to America's past, and the way people thought, spoke and acted. "Gunsmoke" often betrayed that type of authenticity with the young babes in the cast (with their 50's-60's hairdos, make-up and huge eye-lashes), but with the OLD FOLKS they cast, they were usually spot-on.
Add to this the fact that the 2 older actors in question represent a FABULOUS history of theatrical experience and know-how. Check out Florenz Ames, who had a remarkable stage career: vaudeville, Gilbert & Sullivan, Gershwin, Rodgers and Hart, Rodgers and Hammerstein, etc, prior to his late-life TV roles. Now, I will be the first to acknowledge the differences between the big, broad, presentational style of the theater and the much more intimate, restrained technique of TV acting, but I was struck by Mr. Ames' control of what is essentially a very colorful, flamboyant part; I thought he really nailed it.
And Anne O'Neal was absolutely wonderful: very realistic and understated. Again, I've known several older people in my youth who acted and spoke exactly in this manner, and she immediately grabbed my attention and won my sympathy. A particularly true-to-life detail was her continual reference to the Marshall as "Dillon" in the final scene.
And let's not forget Anne O'Neal's special place in the pantheon of supporting players with the 3 Stooges ("TELEPHONE FOR THE THREE STOOGES!" in "Pain in the Pullman" and the fox hunt lady in "Ants in the Pantry"), as well her final appearance as one of the nursing home patients in The Twilight Zone's fondly remembered "Kick the Can".
I know everyone is entitled to their own opinion but, while you're forming that opinion and putting it on public display here on IMDB, just realize that there's a HELL of a lot of history, experience and insight in some of the shows you are slamming. LR.
11 out of 12 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink