(2004 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Funny
VanMovieBuff4 April 2005
A kooky, but funny bit of diversion. You kind of have to see it from the beginning to follow what's happening, but each report to earth has it's own little joke. Pretty good special effects for a very low budget sci-fi t.v. show. It's fun to watch. Sort of in the vein of Red Dwarf, but even more low budget. For someone who's just coming in in the middle of one of the episodes, what you have to realize is that these guys are all incompetent, because they've been moved up the ladder of command, because the other officers died. Also, the main guys are from the laundry corps, which is why they have laundry in everything. If you like Red Dwarf, you'll probably like this. Slightly different t.v. concept, in that all you see is the Commander's report each day.

It would be better if this were explained more, not just in the very beginning of the first episode, but then it was pretty hard to figure out what had happened in Red Dwarf too, if you hadn't been told.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Decent Bit of Off-kilter Fun
kevinh-1523 December 2006
Warning: Spoilers
After the death of all senior officers, Commander Craig-Scott, of the Laundry and Morale Corps, finds himself promoted to command of an intergalactic spaceship owned by Starcups Corporation. Its chief mission is to search for inhabitable planets and, of course, long-term coffee markets.

Craig-Scott and his second in command, Chief Blather, find themselves ill-prepared for command, except insofar as they are fully able to keep the crew's undies clean--which is not to diminish the importance of clean undies, especially when incompetent commanders cause those same undies to be, well, soiled on a regular basis.

The episodes are presented as a series of short, 2-3 minutes reports by the Commander to Earth. The humor is a mix of wry deadpan and outrageous physical comedy. Think Yes Minister meets Red Dwarf, but on a shoe-string budget. All the usual plot devices of sci-fi are here--aliens, nuclear weapons, computer malfunctions--but each is improved by the fresh lemony scent of high-grade laundry detergent.

Commander's Log is definitely low-budget, but the somewhat cheesy effects and props fit the absurd premise of the show. Remember those hilarious hockey helmets they wore on the old Battlestar Galactica? With the "Jofa" brand-name still visible? Okay, there's a lot of that in Commander's Log, but it's cute.

Commander's Log ain't high-art, but that's not what it's trying to be. It's just a little bit of off-kilter fun. It does a good job of being that.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
We want more!
grga-323 December 2006
I first heard about Commander's Log when I was on the concom for the local science fiction convention. Craig Bowlsby, Linden Banks, Sophie Banks, and Brian Oberquell came out to show the video and give a couple of panels on making TV on a shoestring budget. I have to say that I was very pleased when I finally had the chance to see the show. Comparisons with Red Dwarf are inevitable, since the first seasons of Red Dwarf were also shot on a low budget (although Commander's Log has to set some kind of record for the least amount of money spent per minute of air time), and thus have to make up for the lack of "eye candy" with good writing and acting. Linden Banks, who plays Chief Petty Officer Blather, does a particularly good job of presenting an earnest but clueless persona.

Bowlsby's original idea was for the story to be told in two minute "interstitials", shown in between other shows over the course of an evening, although for some reason, Space didn't get how cool an idea this would have been, and so the interstitials were all rolled up into a one-hour show, which Space normally showed in two half-hour episodes. The existing DVD doesn't include episode 3 (which premiered at Cascadia-Con in Seattle in 2005) or episode 4 (which was previewed at VCON in Vancouver in 2006), but if you're in touch with your local fannish community, you may catch news of a showing somewhere near you.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very, very funny.
efrat554 April 2005
Warning: Spoilers
It's great when an entertaining story can be effectively told in one location and with a small cast. Commander's log manages to poke fun at may science fiction clichés without becoming a cliché itself. A very creative piece.

The film is a series of video "logs" created by the commander - much like in Star Trek - so we never see what is happening except for when the video log is active. This creates an interesting pacing throughout the film - especially when the "log video" is left on by accident. Surprisingly, this device never becomes tiring - this being a result of very good performances on the part of the cast.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Future Cult Classic
burbleshabe1 January 2007
I recently saw Episodes 1-4, and now I can't wait for 5 & 6 to be available! (I've heard they are coming soon.) Commander's Log seems destined to become a cult hit among the university crowd and all others with a taste for quirky comedy. It's obvious that the budget was small, but the care taken in crafting the script is quite evident. In fact, the simplicity of the show allowed me appreciate the writing and the acting more. Bowlsby is a master of the put-down... I just wish I could remember all the best ones for later use on unsuspecting co-workers! Let's just say that if you don't like Commander's Log, I'll personally see to it that your undies get extra starch!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Review from Neo-opsis Science Fiction Magazine
karl-johanson13 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
The year is 2052 and the global ship, Sarcups, has just experienced a change in command. Thrust into the position of commanding the vessel after a mysterious loss of its high-ranking officers, Commander Craig Scott of the Laundry Corps struggles to maintain order and routine. Scott is challenged by a less-than-competent crew of fellow laundry staff obsessed with cleanliness and good coffee, a short cranky alien who can't speak English, and Scott's own myopic view of what it takes to run a space vessel and its crew. When I was first introduced to this Vancouver produced science fiction comedy by Cyrano Productions, I braced for something less than stellar. I was delightfully surprised. And I have seldom laughed so hard. It might have been my initial low expectation; I don't think so.

First of all, there is the unique and charmingly wacky premise of 'incompetents' from the laundry corps suddenly charged with running a space ship in its discovery mission. Premise is followed by innovative and original material, well and convincingly delivered. Add to that a cast of eccentric characters competently played by accomplished actors dispensing witty dialogue and hilarious use of metaphor, and you have a show worth watching.

The metaphoric theme of laundry runs throughout the show as the newly instated commander begins his report to home base. Commander Scott (Craig Bowlsby) explains that he now has command due to a succession of previous commanders having each succumbed to the "Stimulator" at maximum setting. As Scott reassures home base that the mission to "seek out habitable planets...and, of course, long term coffee markets" is not compromised, he openly wonders why each previous commander would have willingly ended his life in the "Stimulator." But we soon realize from the current commander's own behaviour and those of crew members we are introduced to, that there may be good reason for such desperation.

Consider, for instance, Scott's newly appointed second-in-command, Chief Petty Officer Blather (played by Vancouver actor Linden Banks), whose answer to everything is soap. When instructed by Scott to monitor life support and engine functions for abnormalities then clean up any problems causing electrical shorts, Blather's answer is industrial solvent 24B-with devastating consequences. Scott is not far behind. His strategy for achieving crew moral is laundry: "...as laundry goes, so goes moral. So much can be dependent on a few grams of extra soft...or crisp. It's all in the balance. All ninety-seven members of the crew have a medium level of moral and a 90% clean garment efficiency rate," he blithely announces. When the nameless alien (called simply the Albanian) sabotages the ship, this precipitates the feared services of the fierce gun-toting "Exterminator" (played by Tiffany Timms), who we discover is actually the ship's librarian. She's taken on a personal mission to hunt down "bugs" in the system by indiscriminately blasting circuitry. One begins to appreciate the desperation with which the previous commanders of the Starcops took solace in the "Stimulator". And, if that isn't enough, we also learn that Starcops Coffee, purportedly the very best in the galaxy, (touted as the "blend that's out of this world") tastes like mud. Despite this comedy of errors, which includes the disappearance and accidental detonation of a nuclear bomb, the crew manage well enough; in several cases, ironically, due to their expertise with laundry and soap.

The idea for Commander's Log was originally conceived by actor/writer/producer Craig Bowlsby as a show for the internet but it soon became more ambitious and developed into its current eight half-hour episodes. The majority of Commander's Log takes place in the command centre of the ship, and mostly in the form of daily reports made by Commander Scott. While this was obviously a way to curb production cost (use of a single set, resembling a one-act play), the strategy worked effectively for Bowlsby, who took the challenge and channelled it into an effective platform for his unique humour.

Commander's Log mixes intelligent satire with gut slapstick and bathroom humour into a delightfully palatable cocktail. It is a charming blend of wit, nerve and silliness that soars on wings of fanciful absurdity. Sometimes a little too cute, (e.g., with names of main characters like Laundry Chief Blather, and Lieutenant Commander Bastaard, played by Greg Anderson of Stargate), the show nevertheless delivers good entertainment. Bowlsby, the show's creator and lead actor describes the show's humour as "multi-layered" from the obvious joke, to wry and subtle sub-text, often making clever use of cliché to achieve yet another often surprising layer. If there is a negative in all this, it would be that the humour tends to be too clever and erudite at times; perhaps a Canadian trait. The audience may also perceive the set and milieu as rather quaint and unsophisticated by current SF TV show standards; yet it has its own charm. Bowlsby reserves his production costs for quality acting and delivering a good script and story. Bowlsby shared script-writing with Catherine Girczyc (The Collector, Dead Man's Gun). And in several episodes we are treated to some dazzling moments care of NorthWest Imaging, the creators of the award winning effects of Andromeda.

The tag line for the DVD of the Premiere episode of Commander's Log runs: "In space, no one can hear you do the laundry." The clever play on words is also, unfortunately an apt metaphor to the legacy of the show on Space Channel (pardon the awful pun). Commander's Log sporadically aired on the Canadian Space Channel in 2005 and not at any specific time or in any particular order. Running Commander's Log out of sequence was potentially devastating to its success and certainly increased "the weirdness factor" according to Bowlsby. Imagine your favourite comedy movie where the last scene with the punch line is shown before its set up scene. Any chance of gaining genuine interest from a TV audience accustomed to routine and being told when to laugh would be slim indeed under such circumstances.

Despite its shortcomings, Commander's Log charms, evokes bouts of belly-laughs, and entertains. It deserves a proper run on network television for providing something genuinely new, refreshing and quirky. If Commander's Log makes it to your local SF network, check it out, but chances are it will be shown out of order or not in its entirety. You may be better off purchasing the DVD set. Review by Nina Munteanu.

Original review in Neo-opsis Science Fiction Magazine Issue # 12. Posted here by Karl Johanson, Neo-opsis' editor.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Amateurish filler
Corvus-920 February 2005
This program was shown in an early morning time slot on SPACE, a cable sci-fi station. I am amazed that anyone would pay for this or broadcast it; it is incredibly amateurish.

The entire show is a sequence of short monologues or scenes performed on a set that looks like a closet with a bunch of circuit boards taped to the wall. There is very little continuity between scenes, and no plot. A typical scene revolves around some lame joke or special effect and is only a minute or so long. The dialog makes little sense and the special effects look like Photoshop filters. The actors are all adults, but I have literally seen high-school plays with better writing and sets. This program is an embarrassment.

Perhaps each scene would work as an interstitial; a filler between shows instead of commercials. Stringing all the scenes together makes the limitations of the material extremely obvious.
1 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Calling It Low Budget Is An Insult To All Low Budget Projects...
Axelinger25 November 2006
Let's be realistic here. The only reasons anyone would give Commander's Log a positive review would be if they stood to gain financially; were blindly sucking up to a friend or relative associated with the project, or are easily impressed by amateurish drivel. Severe mental illness could also be accepted as a reason for praising such claptrap in a pinch. I, too, sat through this poop on the Space Network, but only because a relative happens to be one of the "stars", but I refuse to respond positively to garbage to appease family. The network ran it straight without commercials for its entire painful 22 minutes - undoubtedly because they could find no sponsor foolhardy enough to waste their advertising dollar on this crackpot venture. The project was undeniably self-produced for the simple reason that no studio would look at the asinine script without reaching for the shredder. Made on a shoestring budget (and it looks like that shoestring snapped partway through production), it gives the word amateur a whole new meaning. I saw better material improvised in high school Drama classes 20 years ago. Commander's Log? It's a "log" all right. Somebody flush it.
0 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed