7/10
Good, with distracting flaws.
28 March 2021
PROS:

  • Dramatisations are good for the most part
  • The brutality is not glossed over
  • Good visualisations of events
  • Subject matter is interesting and mostly maintains interest


CONS:

  • The series does suffer from over-dramatisation and repetition. Play a game of 'historian bingo' with me:


'It was the most decisive battle in Japanese history' - 10 points per mention 'This was the most bloody battle in the history of Japan' - 5 ppm 'It wasn't a battle, it was a MASSACRE' - 15 ppm 'There would have been battle cries and screams all around' - 5 ppm 'There was confusion among the fighting' - 10 ppm 'It would have been a brutal melee' - 5 ppm 'There were swords clashing in the fight' - 10ppm 'This would be the most important decision in all of Japanese history' - 10ppm

See how long it takes to beat 500 points...

  • While initially a minor nitpick, these interjections become increasingly distracting and waffly as the series 'fills time' in the middling episodes.


  • Music is nothing to write home about.


  • Visible 'budget shortcuts' every now and then.


  • Historians seem under-utilised as the series doesn't expore any topic in great detail, rather re-tells a storyline of events. How did these people live on a day-to-day basis? Can we see any of the sources/books/art on which these facts are based? How does the samurai armour protect them from attack? There is still so much I don't know about the samurai.


OVERALL: Good with some noticable flaws.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed