6/10
Visually and story-wise a success
12 July 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"Onkel Toms Hütte" is a West German color film from 1965, so this one already had its 50th anniversary last year. It is the German-language take on the famous "Uncle Tom's Cabin" story by Harriet Beecher Stowe, probably nothing I would have ever thought that it existed, but it was a positive surprise for the most part. I found different numbers in terms of this film's runtime. IMDb says 2 hours 50 minutes, other sources say 1 hour 50 minutes, but the version I saw was something in between, namely slightly over 2 hours and 20 minutes. The director here is Géza von Radványi and he was pretty successful and prolific back in the day. This one here is still among his most known films I guess. The cast is solid too. O.W. Fischer, O.W. Fischer, Michael May (in her first performance) and Mylène Demongeot had star potential and the title character is played by John Kitzmiller in his final performance very briefly before his death. The latter is mostly known for his Bond film performance today. Overall, this is not a perfect work by any means and it has difficulties occasionally in terms of keeping focus. Then again, it is almost impossible to do so for a film with this runtime. There are moments when it drags and I feel it should have been 35-40 minutes shorter. But I would still say it's a success overall. Especially the first third of the film was pretty interesting to watch. I myself am not too interested in the era the film portrays, but people who care more for this time and the historic context may actually end up really loving this film. I personally would only say I liked it. Not a must-see, but I still give it a thumbs-up, even if it struggles with getting shades on characters beyond the black-and-white depiction (no pun intended!) and the message it sends is an honorable one. Worth seeing.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed