Review of Nob Hill

Joan Bennett was certainly correct when she said that the studio promoted Peggy Ann Garner and Vivian Blaine at the expense of George Raft and herself in this film. Peggy Ann should have been there just to introduce the Raft character of Tony Angel and show that he was a nice guy. Instead, the first fifteen minutes of the film and the last fifteen minutes are devoted to Peggy Ann adopting her new American family. It was a wise decision. She's terrific. In the main story, Wealthy Joan Bennett battles showgirl Vivian Blaine for the love of enterprising and well liked saloon owner George Raft. Blaine gets to sing and dance in four numbers. She does well, but it is a little unfair to Bennett, who only has her acting to rely on. Fortunately, she's a great actress, so she makes a good rival for Blaine. Raft apparently walked off the set at some point, because he didn't like his role. It is easy to see why. He plays it a little too dramatic for this light comedy and he takes himself too seriously. In the beginning, he beats up a cheating employee, but he does it in an unnecessarily brutal manner. It shows him to be a tough guy, but it is a little disturbing to the tone of the film. Certainly, someone with a softer comical touch like Jimmy Stewart, Joel McCrea or Cary Grant would have been a much better choice for the part. The Technicolor is beautiful and so are the sets and costumes. Director Henry Hathaway moves the camera and cuts the film in a smooth and seamless style. It is pretty much a pleasure to watch all the way through. See it for Peggy Ann Garner's wonderful performance, some good singing and dancing by Vivian Blaine and nice acting by Joan Bennett.