Review of Never a Dull Moment

By-the-numbers romantic comedy via Kay Swift's semi-autobiographical book (the uncredited "Who Could Ask For Anything More") about a songstress from New York City (Irene Dunne) who has a whirlwind courtship and marriage to a widower cowboy (Fred MacMurray). You know you're in for it when you hear the nicknames: she calls herself "The Bride of the Cattle King" while hubby condescendingly refers to her as "Buckshot". Dunne's self-sacrificing Kay has to learn to love life down on the (dilapidated) ranch, while MacMurray's cowboy Chris (!) spends his time mending fences and hunting cougars, and his two young daughters test their new stepmother out. Screenwriters Lou Breslow and Doris Anderson thankfully don't attempt to score points against Dunne (she's a smart cookie who suffers through a few entanglements before they're neatly ironed out); however, the union of Kay and the slightly-malevolent Chris is never convincing--and when he speaks to her, it's always as if he'd just inherited another daughter. Swift wrote the simple, singalong tunes, Gigi Perreau and Natalie Wood are adorable as the youngsters, but the script never resolves the heroine's out-of-her-element predicament. Thus, the rosy ending doesn't quite wash. ** from ****