1/10
Sadly disappointing
3 July 2005
Bledel did a good job but Tamblyn's acting left much to be desired. Tamblyn's arrogant and conceit detracts from any role she is in. Casting a less arrogant actress in the role of Tobby would have made this movie far better. Thankfully Bledel added some color to the bleakness displayed by Tamblyn.

This movie is based on an excellent and heartwarming book but I found myself extremely disappointed by Tamblyn's performance. She's a young women who has let her fame go to her head.

I certainly hope that if more movies are based on the books. better casting choices will be made.
9 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed