Review of Sherlock

Sherlock (2002 TV Movie)
1/10
horrible, horrible, horrible (possible spoiler, if you're unfamiliar with the books)
29 February 2004
Warning: Spoilers
This isn't the worst movie I've ever seen (I did watch Solarbabies in my childhood) but....

It's really *really* bad - If you waste the money to rent this, try watching it as a satire, a comedy, or British revenge for the collapse of the British Empire.

The adaptation is terrible - Mycroft Holmes is never met in the books, he's just referred to as Sherlock's smarter brother. A morphine and cocaine addict, Sherlock didn't get "hooked" by Moriarty, and used the drugs by choice. Sex was totally a taboo subject for the era, and none of those scenes fit either. The STUPID STUPID attempts to impose modern morality in a movie blatently ignoring the MOST BASIC Victorian morals is pathetic.

I could go on, but it really is just horrible horrible horrible!!!
13 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed