Sorry Mac....you are pretty to look at with your bee stung lips and nice bod, but Seth kicks your butt in the acting arena! I have been following this story for a long time and read the book, and I feel that Seth perfectly captured the droll but self deprecating humor of Mr. St.James, where as Mac just kinda,(sorry), sounded like his voice is still changing. Consolation if any? I believe that Michael is too complicated for anyone to replicate! See, and enjoy!