Alan hits Elaine with a golf cart, but puts the blame on David. Meanwhile, David takes advantage of Elaine's empty apartment and plans a romantic dinner for Jessica.
It's Alan & Elaine's anniversary and the newly separated couple don't know how to handle it. David decides to come clean to Jessica about his one-night stand.
Alan sets out to get Elaine back, only to find she might be seeing another man. He recruits David and Amy to help get to the bottom of things and win back his wife.