Believe it or not, out of all the films this year, my most anticipated one after Sonic the Hedgehog 2 came out was Lightyear.
I just loved the concept; a film about the actual Buzz Lightyear astronaut that inspired the toy from the Toy Story universe...well, that was what I thought it was gonna be with the first announcement we got (we'll get back to that later), and when I saw each passing trailer and clip on YouTube (don't worry, I avoided spoilers BTW), I got more and more hyped, and I thought that this was gonna be one of Pixar's greatest.
However, I got cold feet after seeing that people didn't quite like it all that much. Heck, this is the only Pixar movie on IMDb that got a score below a 6/10. But hey, most of the Child's Play movies also got a score below a 6, and the only one I didn't like was Cult of Chucky (mainly just because it's the most boring one IMO), and I still wanted to go into Lightyear with an open mind, and how was it?
I'm not gonna go heavy into spoilers or write anything too detailed since it's still in cinemas and I've only seen it once, but it's pretty solid in my opinion. I enjoyed our main heroes (Sox and Darby get the best lines here), it's visually stunning, the action sequences are cool, it doesn't really get boring at any point, and it does a nice job at reimagining Buzz Lightyear as an actual human space ranger rather than just a toy.
However, it's not perfect by any means. Zurg didn't really leave too much of an impression as a villain, which is a shame since he could have been an amazing antagonist and his design here is supreme. I also wasn't a fan of the twist they did with him too (again, no spoilers, but I would have preferred him being Buzz's father over what we got). But the film's biggest issue was the framing device we got. Contrary to what the first announcement of the film told us, and what I believed for the longest time, this wasn't about a real astronaut in-universe that inspires the Buzz Lightyear toy, but is actually supposed to be a film that Andy saw that led to him getting the toy for his birthday. It's a fantastic idea on paper, but in the end, it creates a plethora of confusion within the Toy Story universe...
First of all, and this is the most minor thing since it isn't actually in the film, but there's this promotional art of Andy seeing the film at the cinema, but why are his toys with him? He was only allowed to bring one toy to Pizza Planet, and weren't the toys unfamiliar with Buzz before meeting him? Secondly, as great as Sox was, he creates some plot holes in the Toy Story universe as well. Wouldn't he have become a popular toy too, if not moreso than Buzz? If Andy's mum couldn't get a Sox toy for his birthday, wouldn't she have been able to get it anytime afterwards? And third of all, the biggest one of all, this does not AT ALL look like something that would have came out in 1995. It makes sense to make the film computer-animated since this was supposed to be a live-action film in the Toy Story universe, where everything is CGI, but you'd think that they would have made it look like a computer-animated film mimicking what a 90's live-action sci-fi film would look like (with film grain, creatures that mimick practical effects, etc.), but it looks (and also feels) more like a modern reboot that DID come out in 2022 rather than a 90's movie, and I feel that the filmmakers just forgot what that framing device was setting up and just made it look like a modern movie anyway.
And even if they neglected the whole framing device thing they set up, I feel like they could have done more with the sci-fi aspect. This is Pixar after all, and they could do wonders with a sci-fi movie (and they have done before with WALL. E in 2008). Sadly, it just feels kinda underwhelming in the end, which is a shame since they had the potential to get really creative.
But in spite of it's shortcomings, I still enjoyed Lightyear a fair bit. It's not the greatest Pixar movie and it has a terrible framing device that makes no sense in context, but it is an entertaining enough sci-fi flick and a solid watch on the big screen.
And yes, I didn't mention Buzz Lightyear of Star Command at all until now, but Disney and Pixar don't acknowledge it anymore, this movie completely ignores it, and the Beyond Infinity documentary treated it like it doesn't even exist, which is a shame since it's a pretty great show from what I've seen.
2 out of 8 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends