I was SO excited for this show. Although I've only read one Stephen King book ("The Shining"), I highly respect him as an author. I think that he is, even today, really ballsy when it comes to the content and themes that are in his books (I'm specifically talking about books like "The Outsider" and "It"). However, "Castle Rock" is not an adaptation. It is instead an original story set in the canon of King's books.
This show sounded like it would be freaking awesome. However, I was less than impressed with the 8 episodes that I watched (out of 10, so don't judge me for not watching enough. I'm not like one of those people who gave "Iron Fist" bad reviews just because they watched and hated the first episode.)
PROS:
CONS:
Overall, this show was extremely disappointing. However, I do hope that season 2 will do a better job with its pacing.
This show sounded like it would be freaking awesome. However, I was less than impressed with the 8 episodes that I watched (out of 10, so don't judge me for not watching enough. I'm not like one of those people who gave "Iron Fist" bad reviews just because they watched and hated the first episode.)
PROS:
- The performances were (mostly) really good. I liked that this show actually had actors that were in previous King movie adaptations. Bill Skarsgard and Chosen Jacobs were both in 2017's "It" and will star in 2019's "It: Chapter Two"; Sissy Spacek had also appeared in Brian DePalma's adaptation of "Carrie". I really liked that performances from Sissy Spacek (no surprise there), Scott Glenn, Melanie Lynskey, Bill Skarsgard, and (mostly) Andre Holland. (Also, Jane Levy was in this show. That was tacked on, but so was she. Which isn't a bad thing; I really like Jane Levy.)
- This show did take its time to unravel its events, which is normally fine. However, this does lead to a big flaw.
- My biggest pro was the entire seventh episode of the series. This episode is absolutely FLAWLESS and is the reason why my rating for this first season was originally an 8/10 (at the time of writing this review, it is at a 5/10). I loved the way that Alzheimer's was depicted in this episode. Sissy Spacek was INCREDIBLE. And it really packed an emotional punch, especially at the end of the episode.
CONS:
- THIS IS JUST A NITPICK BUT... Holland did a good job acting, but there were moments where it was hard to take him seriously. He tends to look like he's trying to frown, and it looks really silly. I can't tell if that's just the way his face looks or if he's just messing with the director. Either way, it really threw me off.
- The show takes WAY too long to unravel its mysteries and events, and I ended up asking more and more questions, but didn't end up getting too many answers. Note that I watched MOST of this season, and I still wasn't very satisfied with the answers that I got.
- I will admit this. I have not seen the last two episodes of the show. However, I have heard from many people that the season's ending was very disappointing. So I will hop on that bandwagon in this mostly decent review.
- Also, the twist brought into those last two episodes just made the show SO convoluted. There was a twist about Skarsgard's character that is introduced in episode 9. However, the first 8 episodes make no damn sense in retrospect. They just completely ruined the entire continuity of the show just so it could subvert audience's expectations about the character.
Overall, this show was extremely disappointing. However, I do hope that season 2 will do a better job with its pacing.
Tell Your Friends