Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
This short is imaginative and full of great sight gags.
7 June 2006
oddly enough,Curly Howard had a brief gag appearance as the head chef in the restaurant but while this seen was in theaters it got cut from all TV and video copies and may have been lost forever.I would love to see that scene as it was the only post Hold that Lion cameo Curly made since his May6,1946 stroke that forced his retirement.That cut scene was also never used in stock footage as train passenger scene was.All that survives is a poster showing Curly holding a rolling pin at Larry and Moe.Does this have to do with TV rights,copyrights and things that were signed after Curly's death in 1952? Other that that the short was one of Shemp,s best,hilarious,even colorized.IT WAS ALSO THE FIRST SHORT WITH THE BLOCK PRINTING OF THE THREE STOOGES IN THE BEGINNING SEQUENCE AS UP FROM 1945-1949 OTHER SHORT HAD THE three stooges IN SCRIPT WITH FIRST CURLY AND THEN SHEMP.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Curly's speech was impaired
7 June 2006
I agree that curly was forced to use comedy routines when he was ill having had at least one previous stroke(April 1945).His speech was impaired and he appeared to have difficulty getting out every word.He also didn't appear to be using his right upper extremity very well and appeared a bit befuddled.Even in March 1946 Curly needed extensive medical attention for his hypertension and we all know what happened May 6th,1946.This was also Harold Brauer's first short with the stooges. It appeared as though Larry Fine had taken some of the comic burden off Curly's shoulders and he was very funny,but Curly's performance was just sad.Despite this the short was not that bad on the whole;though it appeared to drag a bit and trick photography was used but surprisingly no old stock footage.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed