I'll totally put my hands up, and say upfront, Tennant and Smith are my favourite Drs, I like Capaldi as an actor, he's brilliant, and he had some good stories, but I never took to him as "the Dr"
Reversely, I Liked Whitaker as the Dr, but hated the scripting and stories, and imo, all her companions where more like comedy sidekicks rather than actual partners .. again, not on the actors, that's the writing...
I was thrilled when I found out RTD was back, I mean, he's literally Dr who's saviour... And he was responsible for one of my very favourite franchises, Queer as folk, the UK original is best, but the USA version was very very good, and made it's own bones over the 5 (iirc) seasons, I haven't watched the new version yet...
And whilst I would have liked to see Whitaker get a season with RTD, it was understandable that he wanted a fresh start, and I did like the look of Mr Gatwa.
Then came the Xmas special, and then the first 2 EPs of s14 dropped ..
And it's horrible. I don't care about the character being straight or gay, it shouldn't be either, that's the drs whole thing, he looks at us humans and thinks our sexual habits are just weird (even the river song storyline seemed more about the people and nothing to do with sex etc) RTD has always injected a little bit of playfull sexuality into his versions, but he kept that mostly on the Torchwood side, with Captain Jack, who is another of my favourite characters....
But the new RTD stuff has just been dumb, and that's a criminal shame, don't worry about the story, LOOK AT ME INSTEAD...... honestly, it's genuinely upsetting because it feels like a giant has fallen, and he's taking the Dr with him.
Shut it down, put it back on a shelf for 5 or 10 years, and let someone else pick it back up when it's sat for a bit.....
Reversely, I Liked Whitaker as the Dr, but hated the scripting and stories, and imo, all her companions where more like comedy sidekicks rather than actual partners .. again, not on the actors, that's the writing...
I was thrilled when I found out RTD was back, I mean, he's literally Dr who's saviour... And he was responsible for one of my very favourite franchises, Queer as folk, the UK original is best, but the USA version was very very good, and made it's own bones over the 5 (iirc) seasons, I haven't watched the new version yet...
And whilst I would have liked to see Whitaker get a season with RTD, it was understandable that he wanted a fresh start, and I did like the look of Mr Gatwa.
Then came the Xmas special, and then the first 2 EPs of s14 dropped ..
And it's horrible. I don't care about the character being straight or gay, it shouldn't be either, that's the drs whole thing, he looks at us humans and thinks our sexual habits are just weird (even the river song storyline seemed more about the people and nothing to do with sex etc) RTD has always injected a little bit of playfull sexuality into his versions, but he kept that mostly on the Torchwood side, with Captain Jack, who is another of my favourite characters....
But the new RTD stuff has just been dumb, and that's a criminal shame, don't worry about the story, LOOK AT ME INSTEAD...... honestly, it's genuinely upsetting because it feels like a giant has fallen, and he's taking the Dr with him.
Shut it down, put it back on a shelf for 5 or 10 years, and let someone else pick it back up when it's sat for a bit.....
Tell Your Friends