Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Great movie.
20 November 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Great movie. Even if I have the feeling it could've been even better..

It's a great movie. To begin with, I think it's impossible for someone not to acknowledge how awesome the story behind it is, written by such a gifted mind as Philip K. Dick. Maybe that's the reason the motion picture cannot get a 10/10 rating. How could anybody possibly direct a movie who lives up to this story's potential? (One could argue that Riddley Scott did this once, creating perhaps the best sci-fi movie ever, out of Dick's "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?", but that's another story).

One has to admit that Spielberg does his best in order to direct such a story. He's careful so as to keep a good pace, not exaggerating, not extracting you from the story with useless futuristic fx, the acting is good, with some of the secondary roles being even better than the movie's star -Tom Cruise- and the story goes on very well, giving you the opportunity to contemplate at its every step: "Is this justice?", "Could this be a set up?", or even posing oneself harder, actual philosophical questions, when watching Agatha asking: "Is it now?", while watching closely the movie as the plot moves on.

The ending was unexpected enough and it all began to make sense in an excellent way, proving once again how great the story was. The very last moments (let's not disclose anything more here) though, were more optimistic than what I would have possibly liked, leading to an unnecessary sort of happy-ending.

Overall: great. But it could have been the movie of the decade.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Oliver Twist (2005)
7/10
Nice, but I was expecting for more
16 November 2005
For more? Yes, indeed, because a Charles Dickens work directed by Roman Polanski was very promising an idea to me. When I first watched the trailer, I said "I MUST watch this one".

The trailer does gives a very good picture of the movie, capturing its atmosphere at its best (as any movie trailer is supposed to do). What when cannot possibly deduce from the trailer is that Oliver Twist doesn't really reach a climax in any certain point and I think this is its main drawback.

The story is beautifully depicted and one sees a nice picture of past centuries' London, the story is very interesting, but not a great amount of intensity is added to it by Polanski.

Certainly worth watching, but unfortunately not the masterpiece one could have expected from the Dickens-Polanski combination of its creation.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed