Reviews

3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Watch at your own risk
27 March 2019
The first thing you'd notice in Tribes and Empires is the lavishness of the set and costumes, and effects. Never before I've seen such quality in Chinese TV series.

Cinematography is great. Cast and acting is superb. You will get carried away with their emotions, particularly courage, loyalty, despair and jealousy.

The main storyline is highly engaging because of your emotional investment in the main leads, but the side stories tends to drag on with not so important character/storyline that didn't even make a difference in the end.

What this series suffer the most is the conclusion, of which there is none. It will take you on a gentle, beautiful, heartwrenching ride, and then leave you hanging mercilessly, hoping someday there will be season two.

So, beware, watch at your own risk.

Is it worth the risk? I knew what was ahead and watched anyway. I did not regret it. If you can read Chinese you can read the novel. I prefer to make up season two in my head.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Great Movie - Exactly like the Book
30 May 2016
I had the exact same feeling when I finished reading the book when I watched the ending of this movie. It felt something was missing in there, like it was remote and emotionally detached - an anticlimax ending to something that should have blown up in your face.

But somehow I learned to deal with the disappointment, and found out that it was exactly how it should be.

This is a story about Katniss Everdeen.

Katniss had been forced to fight. She was used as a tool by two opposing political forces. She had not been a fighter before the games, it should be natural that she was not on the front line of the war, and saw little actions. It is befitting for her story to end in a personal level.

The deaths were written briefly in the books, and they were just as detached as it was in the movie. Perhaps it's just how Katniss' personality deals with it. She didn't look too emotional when it happened, but we know she'll have her scars for the rest of her life.

If it had been done differently, the movie might have more favorable rating out there, but it would lose the feeling of the book.

And the book was not an action book, it was a bitter,darker reflection of our modern society - which is already in the grasps of manipulative Media Empires.
2 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
More enjoyable than the other one...
12 November 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I'm not a huge fan of brainless action flicks usually.

Yet while White House Down didn't have the most sophisticated plot lines, action sequence or CGI, I still find it much more acceptable than Olympus Has Fallen. It's like they're twins, with opposite personalities.

One thing I clearly liked better in this movie was the characterization.

They are humane, more realistic and relatable to most people. Their interactions and dialogs are fluid and fun to watch (even though they're improbable in real life). You can find yourself rooting for them in the movie.

Even the villains are more...three-dimensional. Walker had clear objective and well-explained personal motives that are actually quite understandable (but not quite agreeable). Kang's motivation was valid enough, but stoic, one-dimensional deliverance rendered it unbelievable.

The other thing I liked about White House Down was that they included competent female and child characters instead of just using them as "maiden-in distress" kind of props. Waving a flag is much more useful than curling up in a ball crying your eyes out.

While the terrorist vs. lone hero plot is definitely a cliché - it was surprising to see domestic hate-group terrorists in the movie. Usually, Hollywood depictions of terrorists are foreigners who speak in heavily accented English or no English at all.

As with any other action movies, in which the heroes seems to deter bullets magically, the movie requires turning off half your brain in order to enjoy the ride. But the questionable details (aside from the whole white house security breach by janitors part) aren't so obvious. Not many people would actually know details about the Presidential Limo, the Air Force One or the U.S's homeland security protocols. The problem solving in the movie is so simple that it is quite justifiable to solve them by throwing off grenades and launching missiles.

Unfortunately, the thing that cripples the movie the most is the action itself: the half hearted one-on-one fights that never show off the gritty, skillful fights people seem to expect from today's action movies; The machine guns used mostly to shred furnishings apart instead of doing serious numbers on body counts; The scarcity of blood and gore; The lack of fancy high explosive weapons and thus the absence of highly destructive explosive scenes. The list may cause a major let down for most hard core action flick fan. Then again this is a PG-13 movie...

But I'm not saying an action movie with all the violent stuff mentioned above would necessarily be a good movie. Story always comes first.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed