Review based on first two episodes only. A slower start than expected from this anticipated series. This is one series where you really do have to have watched the Cartoon Rebels show. I wacthed the first two seasons of that, so i was somewhat familiar.
What works?
I think Ray Stevenson's dark Jedi is interesting, not evil as such , but more of just a mercenary attitude . I hope they don't do full pantomime with him later on.
I quite liked his apprentice too (although she is clearly being set up as an antagonist for Sabine , Alt girl smack down ).
VFX is mostly strong, apart for some obvious use of 'The Volume' I like some of the political elements hinted about with Ex Empire workers.
Star ship sequences were well handled.
I liked some of the production design here that somewhat captures the feel of the OG movies What doesn't work?
Odd dialog sequences. Decisions where to have lots of what i can only presume were meant to be dramatic pauses between conversations with characters make dialog scenes sometimes feel oddly artificial , and makes them less dramatic.
I like Dawson as an actress, but I have to say she struggles to make a convincing action hero . The action scenes aren't particularly realistic and lack a sense of danger. Lightsabre battles look more like a stunt show being performed.
As mentioned the pace feels a little slower than expected and at times borders on a little dull It might be mentioned later in series, but I can't help but wonder where the financing would come from for this new empire (although the same issues can be said for most modern SW) I know Rebels has its fans; however I personally feel Filoni characters tend to be particularly overwritten in general but in particular in Rebels. Every character is the last of their kind, some type of highborn or royalty, retconned into an existing major characters backstory. Think about what made the original movie work. We had a farm boy, two criminals and an old veteran. Relatable.
As it goes, its ok, fans of Rebels I expect will enjoy more, but objectively it's somewhat average.
What works?
I think Ray Stevenson's dark Jedi is interesting, not evil as such , but more of just a mercenary attitude . I hope they don't do full pantomime with him later on.
I quite liked his apprentice too (although she is clearly being set up as an antagonist for Sabine , Alt girl smack down ).
VFX is mostly strong, apart for some obvious use of 'The Volume' I like some of the political elements hinted about with Ex Empire workers.
Star ship sequences were well handled.
I liked some of the production design here that somewhat captures the feel of the OG movies What doesn't work?
Odd dialog sequences. Decisions where to have lots of what i can only presume were meant to be dramatic pauses between conversations with characters make dialog scenes sometimes feel oddly artificial , and makes them less dramatic.
I like Dawson as an actress, but I have to say she struggles to make a convincing action hero . The action scenes aren't particularly realistic and lack a sense of danger. Lightsabre battles look more like a stunt show being performed.
As mentioned the pace feels a little slower than expected and at times borders on a little dull It might be mentioned later in series, but I can't help but wonder where the financing would come from for this new empire (although the same issues can be said for most modern SW) I know Rebels has its fans; however I personally feel Filoni characters tend to be particularly overwritten in general but in particular in Rebels. Every character is the last of their kind, some type of highborn or royalty, retconned into an existing major characters backstory. Think about what made the original movie work. We had a farm boy, two criminals and an old veteran. Relatable.
As it goes, its ok, fans of Rebels I expect will enjoy more, but objectively it's somewhat average.
Tell Your Friends