Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
This is why I'm a fan
23 January 2006
To be perfectly honest, I was not a Talking Heads fan before this I saw this. A friend had to drag me to see it when it came out. But it totally blew me away! I wound up being totally obsessed with TH after I saw Stop Making Sense, so I don't think it's just for fans at all, it made me a fan.

The thing about SMS is that it's just pure music, and pure joy. No filler: interviews with the band members backstage, crowd shots, spliced segments of music videos, blah blah blah. If you love a band's music, why bother with the other crap? It's just drama (which there was plenty of on this tour, apparently, if you read the interviews).

David Byrne is such a freak, and his unadulterated joy at being able to BE a freak on stage and get paid for it is infectious. This is a show for every self-conscious teen who felt like shrinking into his chair during class, but who busts out dancing in the privacy of his bedroom.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
David Tennant/Griffin Dunne
19 November 2005
Warning: Spoilers
I don't know what all the complainers expected. You take a 800 page book, cram it into 154 minutes, did you really think they'd be able to get all of it in there?

My kids asked me why they didn't just make a couple of movies, or a mini-series, instead of trying to get it all into one feature length movie...all I could say was it's all about the money. It would've been most likely too expensive to do it right, so they did the best they could. Yeah, it's far from perfect, but if you honestly expected perfection, you haven't seen a lot of movies lately.

I have one burning question for all of you obsessive HP fans, though...I'm amazed no one else has mentioned it so far:

Barty Crouch Jr. is played by Griffin Dunne in the Pensieve courtroom scene when he is arrested and brought before his father.

David Tennant plays him in every other scene, including the one where he tries to sneak out of the courtroom before Karkaroff gives him up, but for some reason, they used a totally different actor in that one short sequence.

Anyone know why?

Did anyone else even noticed the change?

It's driving me nuts, I can't find ANY information on it on the web, and I can't imagine it's something that some trivia site hasn't picked up on already.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed