The voice cast all did great as usual.
The added scenes of Batgirl/Barbara Gordon was a nice little mini movie in it's own. She had very little time in the graphic novel so it was I found necessary screen time to spend time with the character before what happens to her later on. It doesn't improve the story but that was never going to happen since the graphic novel is already perfect, it's more for adding minutes to the runtime and character development.
The animation was the big negative for me. It looked cheap and there was no reason it couldn't look better. Though it is fine as it is and I can see how Bolland's artwork would be really hard to animate. The first 30 mins had the best animation because they didn't have to rely on source material.
The music was surprisingly better than I expected.
I don't understand some people's complaints about things that were straight out of the graphic novel. No one complained about them being in the actual story, but seeing it on the screen all of the sudden some people now have a problem with it. This story isn't completely canon and should be taken as a semi-elseworlds story.
After the trailer I was expecting too give it a 6-7/10, but it was better than I expected and I will be watching it several more times. Ranking it with other DC animated films it probably ranks between #5-10 all time with Mask of the Phantasm and Under the Red Hood being at the top.
I give it an 8/10
The added scenes of Batgirl/Barbara Gordon was a nice little mini movie in it's own. She had very little time in the graphic novel so it was I found necessary screen time to spend time with the character before what happens to her later on. It doesn't improve the story but that was never going to happen since the graphic novel is already perfect, it's more for adding minutes to the runtime and character development.
The animation was the big negative for me. It looked cheap and there was no reason it couldn't look better. Though it is fine as it is and I can see how Bolland's artwork would be really hard to animate. The first 30 mins had the best animation because they didn't have to rely on source material.
The music was surprisingly better than I expected.
I don't understand some people's complaints about things that were straight out of the graphic novel. No one complained about them being in the actual story, but seeing it on the screen all of the sudden some people now have a problem with it. This story isn't completely canon and should be taken as a semi-elseworlds story.
After the trailer I was expecting too give it a 6-7/10, but it was better than I expected and I will be watching it several more times. Ranking it with other DC animated films it probably ranks between #5-10 all time with Mask of the Phantasm and Under the Red Hood being at the top.
I give it an 8/10
Tell Your Friends