I'll get to the point: I have never watched a film where the villain has been so sympathetic and the protagonists have been so despicable.
The storyline is this: Depression era America. Jumped-up college drop out Jakob runs away and joins the circus. He is taken under the wing of August, the circus owner who gives him a job, food and board. Jakob repays this kindness by embarking on an affair with August's wife Reece (Witherspoon, I cant remember her characters name right now).
But what is so terrible about August? What makes him worthy of this betrayal?
He pokes an elephant.
Yes, there is a scene where August is training their newest star, Rosie the Elephant and he prods her a few times with a metal poker. Now the act does look violent to the soft-headed viewer, but this is a bloody elephant we are talking about! Their hide is several inches thick. Trust me, compared to the savagery of the jungle in which her kind evolved, these pokes would barely register.
In another scene, August beats the elephant to its knees and we are supposed to believe this makes him the villain. But this has to be the weakest fanny of an elephant in existence, being floored by a mere man. Frankly, Rosie is an embarrassment to her species.
And to Rosie I say this: I'm sorry you were born in depression America and not the forests of India, but born into the depression you were and there is only one law of this human jungle: make money or starve. So I'm sorry that you were born a circus elephant, but this wasnt any fault of August's. He is the only thing stopping you from starving, because in a country where people struggle to feed their own livestock, an elephant would be soon for slaughter.
Then there's Reece, August's wife. Rescued by August from presumably a life on the game and turned into a star, Reece actually has a very comfortable life. If she is being abused mentally or physically by August, the director does a crappy job of showing this. If August is cheating on her, it is never implied. He seems to love and care for her well enough. He does beat her when he finds out she's having an affair with Jakob but by this point in the movie I'm on his side to be honest.
Poor August. Here he is with the stress of a traveling circus on his shoulders. He is employing hundreds of unskilled labourers during a time where work is thin on the ground. And their thanks to him is to talk bad about him behind his back, slander him just because he wants his animals trained enough to not attack the crowds. They say no good deed goes unpunished and in August's case that couldn't be more true.
The story is told in a Notebook-style flashback - an old man recollecting his youth. At the beginning of the movie Jakob laments that he has five children and none of them care enough about him to let him live with them. Well, Jakob, maybe that's because you're a really selfish jerk.
The storyline is this: Depression era America. Jumped-up college drop out Jakob runs away and joins the circus. He is taken under the wing of August, the circus owner who gives him a job, food and board. Jakob repays this kindness by embarking on an affair with August's wife Reece (Witherspoon, I cant remember her characters name right now).
But what is so terrible about August? What makes him worthy of this betrayal?
He pokes an elephant.
Yes, there is a scene where August is training their newest star, Rosie the Elephant and he prods her a few times with a metal poker. Now the act does look violent to the soft-headed viewer, but this is a bloody elephant we are talking about! Their hide is several inches thick. Trust me, compared to the savagery of the jungle in which her kind evolved, these pokes would barely register.
In another scene, August beats the elephant to its knees and we are supposed to believe this makes him the villain. But this has to be the weakest fanny of an elephant in existence, being floored by a mere man. Frankly, Rosie is an embarrassment to her species.
And to Rosie I say this: I'm sorry you were born in depression America and not the forests of India, but born into the depression you were and there is only one law of this human jungle: make money or starve. So I'm sorry that you were born a circus elephant, but this wasnt any fault of August's. He is the only thing stopping you from starving, because in a country where people struggle to feed their own livestock, an elephant would be soon for slaughter.
Then there's Reece, August's wife. Rescued by August from presumably a life on the game and turned into a star, Reece actually has a very comfortable life. If she is being abused mentally or physically by August, the director does a crappy job of showing this. If August is cheating on her, it is never implied. He seems to love and care for her well enough. He does beat her when he finds out she's having an affair with Jakob but by this point in the movie I'm on his side to be honest.
Poor August. Here he is with the stress of a traveling circus on his shoulders. He is employing hundreds of unskilled labourers during a time where work is thin on the ground. And their thanks to him is to talk bad about him behind his back, slander him just because he wants his animals trained enough to not attack the crowds. They say no good deed goes unpunished and in August's case that couldn't be more true.
The story is told in a Notebook-style flashback - an old man recollecting his youth. At the beginning of the movie Jakob laments that he has five children and none of them care enough about him to let him live with them. Well, Jakob, maybe that's because you're a really selfish jerk.
Tell Your Friends