Like most British musical productions of the time, this can be a tad quaint; it's more semi-operetta than musical and lacks much in the way of memorable songs you'd find yourself humming afterward. Of course the music was nearly twenty years old when CCC made it to the sound screen and much of it didn't age well. But what the heck-- just go with it. "Ali Baba" is a good yarn, and this expands on it entertainingly. Dear old George Robey injects a light-hearted element into a sometimes dark and brutal tale. The sets and cinematography leave little to be desired except possibly color. This was such a sumptuous spectacle onstage that I'd be willing to set aside my objections to colorization in this instance. But one can imagine the color!
The original story (set in Persia) had only the one slave-girl, the formidable Marjanah, who out of devotion to her master singlehandedly killed off the thieves and their chief. Working this with two slave girls, one good and one bad, is a pretty good device, since a nice virtuous slave-girl doesn't go about performing mass murder, while a ruthless bad slave-girl is capable of just about anything. Lots of ruthless people in this opus, and Fritz Kortner's odious Abu Hassan is an especially nasty piece of work.
Pearl Argyle makes a winsome and courageous slave-girl Marjanah, beloved of Ali Baba's son Nur-al-Din (John Garrick), who regales her with excruciating love ballads. Much is made of the barrier of class distinctions standing in the way of their union. Supposedly only the Caliph has authority to 'free' her and make her available for marriage, when as family property a female slave could be handily made a wife-- in fact slaves were preferred, since they were so much more submissive than free-born women. But Marjanah was the property of Ali Baba's wealthy merchant brother Kasim Baba, who was not a generous man. Luckily that obstacle is removed...
Things heat up when Anna May appears. As Zahrat, also a slave in the household of Kasim Baba, at first she seems the expected go-to girl for Treacherous Oriental Temptress; however, there's more to her than just slinking about looking inscrutable. She gets in some real acting, and even half of a song: the haunting "Cleopatra's Nile", to charm robber chief Abu Hasan. Alas, she should have been dubbed-- and I suspect that's why the second verse is lost in the scene's fade-out (to see what you're missing, go to YouTube and search on "Cleopatra's Nile" "Chu Chin Chow" for a gorgeous version, remastered in 2005). Zahrat has had the misfortune to fall in love with that villainous creep of a bandit (go figure), a heartless monster if ever there was one. But even she has her limits!
Sydney Fairbrother has the thankless role of Ali Baba's shrewish wife Mahbubah, whose disposition is however much improved by their sudden affluence after hubby raids the treasure cave. She'd probably always dreamed of a pet monkey! 'Mahbubah', by the way, isn't Arabic, but a Hindi or Urdu name meaning 'Beloved'. It's easy to see how she became an embittered hag, since she, her husband and son are kept in rags and no doubt worked like slaves by Kasim Baba, who cares for nothing but accumulating more riches. Doesn't even give them a place to live. But Ali Baba is cheerful nonetheless, for he is obviously a fool, and it takes wiser heads and bolder hearts to save him from a dreadful fate.
As Kasim's plump and indolent wife Alcolom, Thelma Tuson comes into her own when Ali Baba virtually inherits her from his rash and ill-tempered brother. Her delightful giggle launches their musical tête-à-tête-- and after all, quoth Ali Baba, "what can Mahbubah say? Hath not the Prophet ordained that a man shall marry four wives?" As he points out, Alcolom, being of such ample proportions, will be equal to three. Poor Mahbubah! But perhaps she too will become fat and jolly in time.
Francis Sullivan's bloodthirsty Caliph seems a bit bland and could have at least used more makeup; the Visier is a more impressive presence. But they serve their purpose in the story, so one needn't quibble. The lavish banquet mounted by Ali Baba to please the Caliph makes a fitting climax to the story, with dancing girls in (rather western) frilled chiffon and Anna May as the star dancer, in an Egyptian-styled costume. Zahrat ensures that the blasé Caliph finds this entertainment stimulating!
Curiously, the Asian actor who portrays Mandarin trader Chu Chin Chow is not mentioned in the credits, although this is the TITLE ROLE. Tsk! Surely he could have been included, even if his character is early on eliminated and then impersonated by the bandit chief. Perhaps someone can identify him.
1 out of 1 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends