markedasread's Reviews

Gagma napiri (2009)

9/10

Gripping and visually impaling in the land of the lost

17 August 2010

Stranded in a war-torn-worn-down Tsibili in the aftermath of the conflicts between Abkhazia and Georgia in the early 90′s, 12-year-old Tedo and a slightly reluctant mother find themselves living as refugees, trying to make ends meet. As Tedo's glue sniffing friends are arrested for petty crimes and the mother prefer scummy lovers over him, the young boy embarks on a journey back to Abkhazia to find the father left behind.

The Other Bank much reminisces of Greek director Angelopoulos film Landscape in the Mist, where the children also leave what they call home on a quest to find a missing father. They both encounter various kinds of people who treat them in various ways, some times quite unexpected. What makes The Other Bank interesting in particular is that it is set in such a remote location, showcasing a reality (and the scenes it takes place in) characterized by poverty, uncertainty and everything else that war brings with. The boy moves through desolate landscapes and cross borders where passing may rob you of your life.

Politics strongly pervades pic, but philosophical aspects hand in hand with a few visually impaling scenes and a grand acting by the lead performer turns it into a definite winner.

11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Welcome (I) (2009)

8/10

Unpleasant take on modern refugee policy

22 November 2009

In Philippe Lioret's latest film Welcome the title is obviously a contradiction, but the meaning of the contradiction itself is just as obvious. It's about illegal aliens in Europe, in this specific film narrowed down to Calais in France. And they are certainly not welcome.

Pic holds an unsettling tone throughout. While story lines tend to diverge, it's reminiscent of Ulrich Seidl's Import/Export in that it tells a story about people in motion in contemporary Europe. People whose conditions were bad from their take-off point, but becomes nonexistent in the grand, boarder-less EU. The limitations with this modern refugee policy of EU is that it only benefits our own. This is all old news for Lioret's protagonist Bilal (Firat Ayverdi) who comes from war-torn Iraq. His journey to Calais where the story begins has been long and painful, and the way to his love in London seems to stretch far beyond the horizon for the seventeen year old refugee.

These are harsh times, Lioret proclaims through images of a port district infested with immigrants, battering cops and even authorities that manifest a despicable manner not only towards refugees but just as well to people trying to help them. One of them is Simon (Vincent Lindon), a disgraced ex-champion in swimming. He seeks atonement in Bilal for his previous mistakes in life and the two becomes committed to each other. But in these harsh times nothing is certain and struggle lays ahead for both of them.

Philippe Lioret covers pretty much the whole lot of it. Each of his characters carries around on fear, despair, desires, love, longings and struggle. It is classic ingredients taken from the ordinary lives of those immigrants. In Welcome, however, it blends well with the non-immigrants as well. It is something they have to live with constantly, but something that is exposed to us at times as well. It is indeed an unpleasant take on modern refugee policy, but it is nevertheless a necessary take.

19 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Police, Adjective (2009)

7/10

Police, subjective.

1 November 2009

In "Police, Adjective", Romanian director Corneliu Porumboiu devotes himself to the story of a small town cop reluctant of busting a minor for endorsing hashish with friends. Although vague at first, we learn that the civil police Cristi is having an unease conscience about nailing the young man, which may inflict seven years in prison for what Cristi believes to be a petty crime that will – soon enough – be looked upon more liberated. Throughout pic we follow his daily routines and interactions in the downbeat and austere town of Vaslui, including scenes of parodic bureaucracy and laudable lengthy takes.

"Police, Adjective" is admittedly in many ways difficult to interpret. The first half of the film deals with classic police work (classic as in reality, not classic as in previously depicted on film) including Cristi's pursuit of suspects and filing reports. For an audience used to clustered action flicks, this may seem as tedious and unbearable to endure. From a more objective perspective, I find it somewhat original and daring. This course of the film is harmless, it is on the contrary a certain, yet inevitable cul-de-sac initiated by a mere typo, that pushes it in a slightly too academic stand. On the other hand, it could also be considered an ironic twist when deciding how Cristi's moral dilemmas should be solved.

One of the more unfortunate aspects of Porumboiu's directing, in particular substantial for "Police, Adjective" but nonetheless equally visible in previous film "12:08 East of Bucharest", is that the (black) humor sometimes may appear so subtle that when juxtaposed to foreigners it can be completely lost (in translation.)

Watching Porumboiu's battle between an objective and supreme law versus Cristi's subjective conscientious law is evidently quite fascinating, despite being a bit too submissive at times.

26 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Snijeg (2008)

8/10

Psychological study in aftermaths of Balkan war

26 October 2009

Debutante Aida Begic opens a tale about Eastern Bosnia in 1997. A sparsely, seemingly deserted village in the aftermaths of the Balkan war. But wait, there are six women, a grandfather (acting imam), a few girls and one boy left alive. Oblivious of the fates of beloved ones, life in the small village continues as usual. At least until one day the two sharp-minded businessmen arrives on a quest to buy land in the war-torn Bosnia, naturally also in the village of pic's assembly. Moral dilemmas including family values and definition of true freedom comes to surface and force the group of women to form divided camps.

Snijeg interposes – by all means – an uncomfortable feeling and pathos for the causalities of war, but also the ones outliving it. Underlying aspects of pic are not beautiful, but it manages to radiate a poetic feeling of how life can go on when it has to. The women of the film are confronted with change, for better or worse. They have lost a lot of things, but what they do have left is their freedom and despite their despair what they need to realize is what they want is all they've got.

All my regards to Aida Begic for portraying this tender subject with such care and modesty, yet managing to include some enigmatic and symbolic scenes which begs for discussion. It's a most successful debut feature that has already earned great reception worldwide – not to say the least by scooping the Critics Week Grand Prize in Cannes.

5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

A Prophet (2009)

9/10

Requiem for a prophet

26 September 2009

A juvenile delinquent named Malik (Tahar Rahim) goes to prison after spending most of his up-growing in juvenile correctional facilities. Malik soon learns that he's no longer a small fish in an aquarium, but a fry in an ocean. And swimming with the big fish is quite a different state of affairs as he is bound to discover.

Pic's protagonist is recruited by the Corsican gang and being an Arab by appearance (granted, apparently not religiously), he continues to live as an outsider of not only society but also fellow inmates as he has done most of his life. But he continues to float and find his way behind the bars.

In the exquisite direction of Jaques Audiard, the film accelerates well through good character development and profound script. The education of Malik is in my opinion one of the main pillar of the film because it is an education on so many levels. Of least to get ahead in business. Dirty business, granted, but it is business nonetheless.

It's the small things that distinguishes this little gem from many other movies on prison culture. It has to be, Audiard knows this and has created yet another great piece of cinema for his fans.

59 out of 79 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Sonbahar (2008)

8/10

Enthralling...

20 March 2009

Warning: Spoilers

I almost missed the very limited screening of only three days (with director Özcan Alper present) when this came to my town. I cannot begin to tell how glad I am that I went to see it.

"Sonbahar", known to the international audience as "Autumn", is the first film by débutant director Özcan Alper from Turkey. This film is very well made, it is profound and striking. Overall I deem it a fantastic debute. We're introduced to a man, Yusuf, who has been imprisoned for the political events of the 90's in Turkey. He is released on grounds that you can discover on your own and is now returning to his childhood home, to a mother in a little cabin on a mountain village. Inside the cabin which literary reeks of serenity we see pictures of a young Yusuf that tells us he's been gone a long while.

Not much is said or even happens. It's a lightly populated village with most habitant's being too old or too young. Meanwhile, we're left with the impression that not much has really happened since Yusuf was imprisoned, and it's hard to believe that someone can ever grow old in the landscape where time stands still. Yusuf keeps his distance from the other locals and mostly hangs around with an old friend. They leave one day to a nearby village where he meets prostitute Eka. A brief relationship is introduced. But what is really interesting is not so much their relation, but rather how they are both connected. They are both prisoners. Yusuf is a prisoner of the politically oppressed, while Esa is trapped in prison of prostitution. Eka asks Yusuf about the time in real prison, a marvelous comment: "So you spent the best years of your life in prison because you wanted socialism? Are you crazy?" But the comment is perhaps less amusing than it is important to pic's political context. Naturally Ekas prostitution has kept her in an equal prison, isolated from social prosperity and vicinity.

The movie is very slow, the takes are lenghty and the photography is hypnotic, enthralling, as is the environment of this little village. Much reminds of the cinema of fellow Turk, Ceyland, but also the works of Andrei Tarkovsky. A must see.

8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Vanished Empire (2008)

10/10

On the inception of Western culture in Russian 70's

19 March 2009

Living in a country where Russian cinema is something foreign, not only in terms of language but also because the import of movies from all of Eastern Europe is quite poor, let me just begin by saying that this movie is a true gem discovered.

Advertised by some as a common love story, "The Vanished Empire" should be seen as much more. While love, or perhaps rather infantile teenage crushes is present throughout, director Karen Shakhnazarov tells the tale of a Russia torn between conservative party-political-values and new western influences featuring the tunes of Shocking Blue, Deep Purple and jeans that begs to deviate from otherwise more traditional clothing. All this started to penetrate a crowd of youths in the early 70's, it just, well, seemingly was a bit more difficult for protagonist Sergei with pals Kostya and Stepan than the contemporary American teen.

Both script, directing and cinematography holds a great deal of quality. Try to catch this! Don't let Timur Bekmambetov's "Night Watch" be the only Russian movie you've seen for the last four years - and the next four to come...

14 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

markedasread

Reviews

Tell Your Friends

Recently Viewed