The first 6 episode season was near perfect. The world they create Is epic and offered a plethora of opportunities to explore in this zombie post-apocalyptic world.
So, super excited for season 2 of course. You have all these opportunities to pursue and what do we get? A son gets shot in a hunting accident and staying at a farm. Right, ok. That's the best you can do?
The worst part of season 2 is the character development and the writing. It's more like a tea-party soap with a zombie theme. It just doesn't create that same sense of realism.
Also I'm just not very interested in the main characters. Often all I feel Is, sure, die. If that's how you think. There's no realism you'd even survive If you behave like that. They do so many silly things.
I.e. They send 2 people to get stuff, Lori panics right after for no apparent reason and she decides to go there too, alone. Of course reading a map while driving, hitting a zombie, crashing and o o o, what a suspense.
Or silently entering buildings knowing the zombies respond to noise, so It's just easier to knock before you go In. It is full with all these silly things you wouldn't do.
I have no sympathies for the main characters with only a few exceptions (I.e. Daryll, Dale). But 1 is even a bigger jerk than the other.
So, yes, disappoint with S2 comparing It to S1. At times so annoyed by the writing and timing of things I almost decided to just stop watching. But of course, the need to know what will happen next trumps that. Hershel enters the stage, a nice positive
Also because the make-up department and production level is just top-notch. So 3 thumbs up for their work!
Season 3 started out quite decent actually, only to fall in those same traps again in the second half. Dumb decisions, weird plot developments, stretched out storylines and no sympathies for most of the characters. Michonne enters the stage, that's a nice surprise. So It wasn't all bad.
Somewhere, just before the end of season 3 I gave up though. It just wasn't like the first season anymore and I was getting quite sure now It wouldn't get better. Too many annoyances to still enjoy It.
But, now, many years later, I'm binge watching It again with my wife. She loves It, although she's also experiencing the same things. She's just a bit more forgiving than me I guess.
So, finally, I've made It to season 4 :-)
And what do you know? It's the best season since S1 because they now finally start to behave like humans in a zombie world. They now knock before entering buildings to name 1 of many things they finally start to utilise. It took them 3 seasons to figure that out. Hershel dies and adds to the drama and seriousness of the world, since they approach everything so serious without much humour, you have to make It gritty like that.
Their more logical human nature and consequence of their actions now starts to create more character immersion. The way they die is still a bit odd at times though.
Season 5 is surprisingly even better than S4. The conflict on what's right or wrong, the things they do, the chaos, the psyche, the doubt and after Hershel's dead in S4 there's more good people dying. Not that I like that, but that's exactly the point. It makes you feel It's more "real" and nobody is safe. You get more immersed.
Season 6 continues in this form. More of the same, but mostly good stuff. A bit repetitive by now though. And the ending is quite weak.
Leading into S7 though, wow! Now we're talking. That first episode, even though It's very stretched out, Is like Game of Thrones red wedding style. Now we're talking. This is tense, dark and sickening, but men, It's so immersive and intriguing. It's not pleasant, they are on the other side of things now and you can just feel the pain.
The build-up to the revolution is of course what we all hope for, but they can't deliver. The season finale is a bit of a mess, especially with that built up anger. And It's a sign, because Season 8 is just terrible. What were they thinking? The writing is so bad! And the logistics don't make sense. The whole weapons and ammunition thing was always a mess to be honest, but now It's about numbers (people). A big theme now apparently, which party has the numbers to win. And the numbers go all over the place like It doesn't matter. They just write without thinking with parties and roles that don't need to be there, actions that are simply retarded and therefor just a drag to watch.
Luckily It picks up again in S9 with a decent level. A bit of a reset, some refreshment in the story helps a lot. It feels like the next stage in their life with some new dynamics. Halfway now. It's good, but as always, the second half Is always a bit of a letdown. So fingers crossed.
It's all hits and misses with this show. Entertaining, sure, most of the time and with certainly good peaks, but men, also such lows.
0 out of 1 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends