Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Arctic Tale (2006)
3/10
Global Warming Done Cute
18 February 2008
My wife wanted to rent this and watch it. It really is cute in some places, but there's nothing here that's any better than the Planet Earth episode on polar bears. In fact, the opening sequence of the bears emerging from their den is remarkably similar...

The storyline is contrived and the references to changing climate blatantly obvious.

It truly is sad that these magnificent animals die, but that's the essence of the natural world, right? Some animals prey on others, climate changes in natural cycles. Polar bears survived the last stint of global warming just fine. The ice sheets were so small 1000 years ago that crops could be grown in Greenland. Wine grapes were grown in England. Where were the polar bears then? This movie was not nearly as good as "March of the Penguins". I came away from that movie inspired. I came away from this one wanting to gag.
11 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the Best Movies Ever Shown on TV
7 February 2007
Warning: Spoilers
My wife and I watched this in the mid-Eighties when it was broadcast here in the United States. I seem to remember it being shown on BBC's Masterpiece Theatre, which we were addicted to at the time...

This is a gripping movie and the characters are well-developed. Shot (as I remember) in Norway, the 'polar' scenes are very believable as are the costumes and props.

Anyone who is interested in this genre and period of history really owes it to themselves to read the book from which the movie was made: "The Last Place on Earth", by Roland Huntford. I loaned out my copy and it was never returned, but this is a very large, very well-written, can't-put-it-down book.

There is no spoiler to share: Everyone who knows anything about history knows that Scott lost the 'race', but while some (mainly Scott-supporters) may say that Huntford is biased in his telling of the race to the Pole between Amundson and Scott, the book and the movie draw the same conclusion and I believe the viewer will as well: Scott was a well-intentioned fool and has been glorified as the quintessential British Explorer/Martyr for all these years simply because his recovered diaries spin a better story. Amundson was not good at self-promotion.

I have been telling people how great this movie is for over twenty years. It has never been re-broadcast, so buying the movie is the only way to see it.

For another perspective on a TRUE British hero, people should read the book "Shackleton" by the same author.
14 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed