Well, firstly I'm not sure if this film has been given a UK cinema release, I watched a US DVD.
I must admit I wrote off this film before they had even started shooting it - I had imagined it being set in NY etc... with loads of 'eat lead ******er' and wall to wall machine guns. I loved the fact that the 1971 version was very true to life in that the rain never ceases and Carter bought it on a dreary day on the outskirts of an offshore coaltip.
People are always 'updating things for the new millennium' when they really don't need to be touched, and the fact remains for me that the original version wins hands down on all scores. Quite how Caine agreed to be involved in this is beyond me, and only serves to prove his best work is (mainly) far behind him.
So, 5/10 I'm afraid from me, I really can't believe that many of the reviewers havent seen the original - but that would probably explain the high average rating - despite it all a good storyline never dies...
I must admit I wrote off this film before they had even started shooting it - I had imagined it being set in NY etc... with loads of 'eat lead ******er' and wall to wall machine guns. I loved the fact that the 1971 version was very true to life in that the rain never ceases and Carter bought it on a dreary day on the outskirts of an offshore coaltip.
People are always 'updating things for the new millennium' when they really don't need to be touched, and the fact remains for me that the original version wins hands down on all scores. Quite how Caine agreed to be involved in this is beyond me, and only serves to prove his best work is (mainly) far behind him.
So, 5/10 I'm afraid from me, I really can't believe that many of the reviewers havent seen the original - but that would probably explain the high average rating - despite it all a good storyline never dies...
Tell Your Friends