Reviews

This is thought-provoking and dramatic. Being based on fact strengthens the points which may be drawn from it. Highly recommended for anyone interested in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, this is an excellent commentary on the situation in the Occupied Territories. Viewers can make up their own minds about resolutions to the problems.

Now I know George Clooney's views on war (he's very much against it), it becomes easy to suggest that this is a reasonable Hollywood war & thrill movie with a few thoughtful and important bits slipped in.

It has some very memorable scenes which put it into a different class from others of its type. Although there is rather too much violence for me, I wouldn't mind my children watching it because there is more to see than just the shooting. As a violent introduction to the benefits of Peace and the demerits of War it definitely deserves to be watched, although Peace purists are unlikely to enjoy it much.

This combination of authentic original footage and modern interview makes fascinating watching. There are so many surprising aspects to this story. How is it that these people remained undiscovered for so long. Were there no aircraft flights over the area? Was there no trade at all? After seeing this also view Black Harvest for more of this absorbing story.

William Hurt is very believable as a west country postmaster and the adoption process is taken apart in a sympathetic and believable manner. The film has charm and pace while dealing with a difficult subject. If it were to be made now would there be a different emphasis in the light of current obsessions with protecting children from paedophiles?