Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Finally - credit for the Pipe Band.
27 February 2014
Warning: Spoilers
This movie has a special personal angle for me, as much of the 'atmosphere' of the Officers' mess was researched by the producers (and actors) at the London Scottish Regiment, 59 Buckingham Gate, Central London, in which my late father was a serving officer at the time. Not a lot of artistic license needed to be added!

The pipe band in the movie, which was uncredited, was the London Scottish Pipe Band, formed in 1859 and still going strong in 2014. Their 2007 CD is entitled "Tunes Of Glory". It is their pipe-sergeant, Willie Ferguson, who plays "Johnny Cope" at dawn to rouse ALL officers to dancing practice! And many of the London Scottish officers (of whom I have fond childhood memories) appear as dancing extras in the 'party' scene when Barrow freaks out! All of the above should confirm that the authenticity of the culture and attention to detail was faultless. Colin Lesslie managed the entire production to perfection.

And the acting of the stars was so good, that when watching the 1946 production of "Great Expectations" on TV last night, the last thing that would have occurred to me was that these were the only two movies in which Guinness and Mills appeared together - so different in every respect. Now THAT's acting!
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Simply No.1 on my movie hit parade.
4 February 2001
A classic tale of the canny Highlanders taking the sassenachs to the cleaners. The essence of the situation has great similarities with other contemporary movies like 'Whisky Galore', and has inspired more modern ones like 'Local Hero'.

The five owners of motor cars in the parish of Laxdale hold a tax revolt to protest the absence of a proper road into a remote village on the Wet Coast of Scotland near Skye. A parliamentary delegation is sent from London to restore order!

All acting performances are wonderful, with early appearances by character actors who went on to become household names. Prunella Scales as a very young schoolteacher; Rikki Fulton as a Glasgow poacher. I particularly enjoyed Kynaston Reeves as the Meenister, Jamieson Clark as the grocer, and of course Roddy MacMillan as the undertaker. And the general, oh the cheneral!

My favourite line is from a bit player, spoken at a public meeting. "Forty miles from the sea? No view of the Cuillins and no river? Man, I would rather live in Hell than in a place like that!"

Truly a way of life that has all but disappeared, even in Applecross where the movie was shot. On my last visit I arrived in the village by one good road and left by another.
16 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed