Change Your Image
Rodney Smith
Reviews
When Trumpets Fade (1998)
Best war movie: simple and matter-of-fact
This is one of the most symmetrically constructed films that I've ever seen. The scene placement and timing is almost mathematical in the telling of the tale.
The story is a snapshot of a reluctant soldier at a particularly ugly point in a war.
This movie could have been filmed in black and white and you'd barely notice. The make up, costume, and facial expressions tell half of the story. (Look at the faces of the "one-week veterans" as compared to the "greenies".)
This is one of the best movies that I've ever seen and is easily the best war movie that I've ever seen. It doesn't hand you anything on a silver platter and it doesn't leave you confused.
Utu (1983)
Brilliant study of revenge
To me, a good movie uses the introduction to snap your tether of disbelief; the middle to entertain you and deliver you to the end; and the end to make it worth the journey.
This movie does it better than any other movie that I've ever seen.
The story is about revenge ("utu"), how the cycle starts, how it changes, and the price to be paid to end it.
The time and the place are not important, though the movie is beautifully shot and historically valid. The action is only a device to tell the story, though it is compelling and riveting. The subject matter is profoundly serious, though there are elements of comedy even during the most serious scenes.
Overall, this is one of the best constructed films that I have ever seen. The pacing of the scenes, the respect for the intelligence of the audience, the dark endearing humor, and the impact of the message all make this one of my favorite movies.
The director's cut provides additional scenes that explain some of the details that are missing from the original, but these extra scenes foul the sharp pacing that makes the studio cut work so well.