Ted Neely is the worst Jesus in film history, hands down. I love the original Broadway soundtrack of "JCS", and after listening to Ian Gillian's (of Deep Purple fame) incredible performance as Jesus, Neely's wimpy passive/aggressive Jesus is practically distracting. Carl Anderson's performance of Judas, however, is stunning.
So how do you turn the best original American rock opera into a movie? Well, you get singers that can act. Or, actors that can sing. This is the biggest problem with the movie version of JCS. The actors don't sing as well as they could, and the singers don't act as well as they could. Ted Neely does a fine job acting (and looking) like the stereotypical long haired, baby faced Jesus, but his singing is jerky, hesitant, and colorless. Carl Anderson as Judas, on the other hand, is a firebrand singer, but his acting is a tad overdone. Ditto for Yvonne Elliman who has a gorgeous voice, but is completely overwrought in the movie.
It must also be noted that Webber and Rice had to "flesh out" the original Broadway soundtrack a bit to extend it into a full length movie, and not everything they added was as sure fire as the original songs. This also translates into awkward moments of silence in the movie, where people who remember the soundtrack are already singing the next lines in their heads.
The scenery is wonderful, but you wonder about the use of all the anachronistic hippies, Romans with machine guns, and the like. The pure 70's-ishness of the dance routines also dates the movie - terribly.
Still, this movie is basically the songs it contains, and the songs are incredible. It sounds hard to believe that any combination of religion and Andrew Lloyd Webber of all people (give Tim Rice most of the songwriting credits) could produce anything worthwhile, but there you have it. Porn legend Ron Jeremy is supposedly cast somewhere as a face in the crowd, but I'll be damned if I can find him.
The bottom line is: it's worth seeing once, but if you want the real thing, listen to the Broadway soundtrack, and imagine the visuals in your head.
So how do you turn the best original American rock opera into a movie? Well, you get singers that can act. Or, actors that can sing. This is the biggest problem with the movie version of JCS. The actors don't sing as well as they could, and the singers don't act as well as they could. Ted Neely does a fine job acting (and looking) like the stereotypical long haired, baby faced Jesus, but his singing is jerky, hesitant, and colorless. Carl Anderson as Judas, on the other hand, is a firebrand singer, but his acting is a tad overdone. Ditto for Yvonne Elliman who has a gorgeous voice, but is completely overwrought in the movie.
It must also be noted that Webber and Rice had to "flesh out" the original Broadway soundtrack a bit to extend it into a full length movie, and not everything they added was as sure fire as the original songs. This also translates into awkward moments of silence in the movie, where people who remember the soundtrack are already singing the next lines in their heads.
The scenery is wonderful, but you wonder about the use of all the anachronistic hippies, Romans with machine guns, and the like. The pure 70's-ishness of the dance routines also dates the movie - terribly.
Still, this movie is basically the songs it contains, and the songs are incredible. It sounds hard to believe that any combination of religion and Andrew Lloyd Webber of all people (give Tim Rice most of the songwriting credits) could produce anything worthwhile, but there you have it. Porn legend Ron Jeremy is supposedly cast somewhere as a face in the crowd, but I'll be damned if I can find him.
The bottom line is: it's worth seeing once, but if you want the real thing, listen to the Broadway soundtrack, and imagine the visuals in your head.
Tell Your Friends