When Stu (James Marsden) finds the painting lying sideways of Mother Abigail (Whoopi Goldberg), it is an 18" x 24" portrait, oriented with her head to the right. When he picks it up to show Glen (Greg Kinnear), he turns it to the right, thereby orienting the painting upside down. However, when he turns it around, it is oriented correctly but is now a 24" x 18" landscape orientation. There are two different paintings.