Mike's family comes to Bucksnort to surprise him for his birthday; a shocking family secret involving Rudy is unveiled; Constance and Clara attempt to help Brandon find a girlfriend via online dating apps.
Mike jumps at a chance to earn a wealthy restaurateur's business as her egg supplier; after Mike seeks Beau's help with his pitch, Beau attempts to get the business for himself.
Mike and Rio are thrilled about having their first Christmas alone as a married couple, but a wrench is thrown into their romanticized holiday plans as they are interrupted by crisis after crisis; Kay invites Beau home for Christmas.
Jacob must figure out what his true passions are; Rio takes driving lessons from Kay, but their friendship hits a bump in the road when Kay learns that Rio has secretly been getting lessons from other townspeople.
When a tornado touches down in Bucksnort, everyone's concerns about their current situations are heightened; Mike and Beau are still at odds about their egg businesses; a mix-up with pregnancy tests leads to confusion.
Rio and Mike must come up with ways to make money to afford a new water heater; Mike decides to sell their chickens' eggs at the local farmers market; Rio tries to find new clients for therapy.
Mike and Rio enter the best hen competition at the county fair with their prized chicken to prove themselves to the community; sparks fly between Rudy and Constance; Kay and Beau struggle with some marital issues.
Mike and Rio host the town's Huskers kickoff party, but no one believes they can pull it off; Rio loses Portia, the pig that's been selected for the lucky pig race; Beau and Kay frantically try to hide the fact that they've split up.
Rio tries to help Kay get over jealousy of her sister Stacey; Rio learns that Mike and Stacey used to date; Rudy and Constance want to take their relationship to the next level.
When Rio jokes about Mike's lack of follow-through when it comes to his hobbies and various projects, he sets out to prove Rio wrong; Constance struggles to end her romantic endeavors with Pastor Paul.