- Dean Winchester: You put the only weapon we have against Michael in the mail?
- Arthur Ketch: Ah, not just any mail. I paid extra. Certified Priority Express.
- Dean Winchester: He paid extra.
- Alternate Michael: This one's a bit scrawny and a bit familiar. I recognize you, Garth.
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: We've met? 'Cause I think I'd remember that.
- Alternate Michael: Oh, I've spent some time in Dean Winchester's head - his, um, memories. You were his friend.
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: Still am.
- Alternate Michael: Makes one of us.
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: But I've got a family now. And there's a war coming - your war. And whether I like it or not, for my family - for my little girl - I gotta be on the winning side.
- Melanie: You have nothing to fear. Only one in seven volunteers explode when they drink it.
- Garth Fitzgerald IV: Russian roulette odds. I like it. Sláinte.