Schirkoa (2016) Poster

(2016)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Captivating, challenging and fearless. An outrageously clever fabrication of a dystopia
thesentry-607471 November 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Having 'horns', 'tails', 'fins' or 'wings' will bring one's death, while the central streets of Schirkoa are forbidden to immigrants in this imaginary world ruled by intellectuals. Identities dilute under 'head-bagged' silhouettes, personal dreams and aspirations are sacrificed for the sake of a trivial ordinary society meant to copycat the citizens' lives; love is just a moment of lust and eventually an instrument used to turn in the beloved ones and secure one's own social and political ascension.

Sprinkled with allegories such as 'bags' worn on one's head to level identities, 'wings' as a way to 'fly above others' in a standardising society, or 'horns' as a symbol of the demonic metamorphosis borne by those spiritually vitiated with their acts of betrayal, and reigned by a masterfully aestheticised graphic, generously and thoroughly depicting an entire world with a fascinating obsession for details - such as the cigarette leaving behind twin loops of smoke or posters spread around the imagined city reflecting the war between the two sides (intelectuals and immigrants) -, Ishan Shukla's 'SCHIRKOA' is simply mesmerising.

There is no mercy shown to the characters in this animated micro-cosmos: a whore, citizen 197(A) - just another number in a row of anonymities and 'the white witch', an 'immigrant' maybe, who discovered her true self or whom she wants to be and tries to hide it in order to spare herself of the 'Schirkonian'-style trial. The characters themselves seem to be mirroring the perverted nature of the world they are part of.

A memorable dystopian 'pastoral' is the scene of the flying paper planes covering the sky, launched from the roof by citizen 197(A) and 'the white witch' living their secret idyll - another suggestion of the suppressed ideals hindered from their right to have recourse to imagination in order to manifest themselves freely and unable to find a better way of emerging otherwise than through 'empty' hovering paper shapes.

SPOILERS:

Another ineffaceable moment is the transformation of 197(A) into a 'beelzebub' - a demon becoming aware of itself when every 'bag' around him starts to 'ignite' in his presence and who, attempting to perhaps 'withdraw' the deed that led to this, travels to the place of the trial of his betrayed partner only to face the final outcome of his actions and embrace his true identity, take his true shape. The 'beelzebub' is the ultimate product of the society of Schirkoa, it is what this dystopian society turns its individuals into. In spiritual mythology 'beelzebub' is identified as one of the 7 princes of hell and often as the second in command after Lucifer. It would be hard to imagine this is just a random thing in Ishan Shukla's comprehensive vision but we will spoil no more of the thick layers of meanings and mythology lying underneath and leave the pleasure of having them discovered for the public's own delight.

SPOILERS end.

There are many 'watersheds' in 'SCHIRKOA', powerfully dramatising the story and endowing it with many twists and turns. It is a true roller-coaster of emotions that enchants, surprises and contradictorily also shocks, intrigues and even frightens a bit. It will lift you and throw you to the ground. It is intense, engaging and reality- detaching in under 15 minutes. A short (animation) film in its pure nature, epic and ample! This must be one of the top 3 animations of 2016 - if not the best itself. Outstanding work!

-Be Epic! London International Film Festival
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
In the dystopian city of Schirkoa, a teenage prostitute, Little Whore (LW), recollects her tragic affair with a senate member - Baghead 197A
contact-742-5008352 November 2016
• The animation work here is fantastic, the character design and backgrounds pop-up and have a lived-in quality to them, there's a sense of history to this place that we can't shake. Every corner of the frame is packed with detail. The soundtrack fits the dystopian themes, and it makes us watch again, trying to decipher its many mysteries within.

• The world building is phenomenal, it has some striking and unforgettable visuals. Crowds of people wearing bags over their heads, vehicles and metro-stations that resemble our world and yet belong to a parallel dimension altogether.

• The narration tells a simple story of a rising politician having an affair with an illegal immigrant, but the images speak of so much more. Every frame is packed with semiotics, not quite hidden but just there for us to take in. Fascism, Immigration, politics and more come packed in this imaginative dystopia. It feels a bit like Brazil with its images of urban decay and bureaucratic dwellers.

Winner at the Oaxaca Film Fest 2016, SCHIRKOA contains lush animation, excellent character design and social commentary packed within every inch of its frame.

Enrrico Wood, Oaxaca FilmFest
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Good animation short!
RodrigAndrisan9 July 2017
I liked this film too! Drawings, animation, music are all exceptional. I did not really understand what is the "strong social message" that all the others are writing about, maybe somebody can tell me. Is it a metaphor for today's society in the United Kingdom? Smell of Brexit? Immigrants and everyone with bags on their head? It made me think about the political films of Costa-Gavras, "Z" (1969) and "State of Siege" (1972) and a film with Antonio Banderas, "Imagining Argentina" (2003).
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An intelligent piece of visual art with a strong social message
hlc-cicff5 February 2017
Welcome to Schirkoa. Imagine a place where immigration was considered a plague. Where no identity was preferable to any identity. A society of faces made bland and generic by decree. The Bag Act was the new law of the land, enforced by the intellectuals of a dystopian society. That's the story behind 'Schirkoa', the short film written and directed by animator Ishan Shukla. This beautifully animated short tells the story of a dismal metropolis where everyone hides their identities for fear of persecution.

This is a place where a good alias is everything. The main character identifying herself only as 'Little Whore', narrates the tail as she describes her first meeting and the relationship she has with a mysterious bureaucrat known only as '197 A'. One day the bureaucrat decides to end it all by jumping off a building. Before he leaps, he meets the gaze of a woman from another rooftop, preparing to do the same. Our storyteller never sees her mysterious bureaucrat again, but lives on to witness and describe the events that follow. A relationship between the 'White Witch' and 197 A ensues, leading to a twisted plot laced with love, betrayal and chaos.

Most certainly a 'cartoon' for adults, 'Schirkoa' is an intelligent piece of visual art with a strong social message, as well as being completely entertaining. I could see this short film being the prototype for a much longer feature or a series. The film created a frighteningly curious world with a rich storyline and compelling visual effects. It engages and gives cause for reflection on the most frightening aspects of a postmodern society revisited by coercive 'nationalism'.

For a thirteen minute film, the invested craftsmanship in the soundtrack and animation was well worth it and due credit should go to the other animators as well; Yiming Lim, Nico Agatha Wibowo and Milan Padhiyar. The music and sound design were exquisitely composed and scored by Nicolas Titeux and I look forward to seeing more work from Indian filmmaker Ishan Shukla and his fellow animators.

EJ Wickes/Cult Critic/CICFF
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
a perfect city
Kirpianuscus3 December 2019
A perfect city, a forbidden love affaire, a not usual couple. And the truth , changing everything. A dystopian portrait of correctness and interdiction against immigrants as a parable. Headbags as only reasonable manner to hidden the reality. And few splendid scenes about freedom, love and sacrifice.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed